HOME > Chowhound > Los Angeles Area >

Discussion

Popped my Bay City cherry....

Yes, it's true, I had never eaten at Bay City Deli before. (Well, actually once, but I'm not counting it because I was a teenager and it was an un-memorable experience). So today I found myself with an hour to kill in Santa Monica. I decided to get a sandwich for lunch. I walked in to a PACKED deli (they were calling out the sixties, and my # was 95). After waiting for around 20 minutes, I ordered a small Godmother, with the works (mild peppers). I would have LOVED to sample some salads, and browse for some cookies and candies and pastas for a while, but I was on a tight schedule, and the overall energy of the place was kind of frenetic, so I just wanted to get my sandwich and split. So finally, after paying $6.35 (steal!) for my sandwich, I went outside to eat. It was DELICIOUS!!!!! The bread, the mustard, the meat....I could have ordered a second to take home! (And I kind of wish now that I had!) The ONLY complaint about the Godmother (and it's totally not a big deal) is that because the bread is harder than what's in it, everything was trying to slide out while I was trying to tug a bite of bread off. But like I said, not really a big deal. I never go to the Westside, but it looks like I'm going to have to make the trek occasionally, for I am now a Bay City BELIEVER!!!!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. I'm wondering what the calorie and sodium counts are for the godmother. This is always nice info to have (all the fast food joints do). I think I might be able to come close if I had one in front of me. Their "po-boy" as well for that matter.

    1. The bread issue is why it is KEY to the experience of the Godmother to give it a nice rest ... That way the dressing really penetrates the bread and the other fillings get a chance to settle and there is less sanwich slippage and more of flavor bomb all around..

      --Dommy!

      2 Replies
      1. re: Dommy

        I always liked the bread for the chewy texture. The hot peppers complete the deal.

        1. re: Dommy

          Good to know-will let it rest a bit next time.

        2. I love Bay Cities. I don't mind the wait for the cold sandwiches when it is busy; I like watching them work and there are always interesting things to look at and people to watch and talk with. But I avoid it during prime lunchtime because the parking situation outside can get so nasty and downright frightening. I often buy a couple of rolls to bring home, but do realize that they go stale if you just look at them crosseyed, so I bag them up and warming them for a minute in a warm oven helps to revive them a bit. Newcomers to Bay Cities should realize there is a separate line for the hot foods to the right nearer the door, and hardly ever a wait there. The daily special hot combos are a great deal.

          2 Replies
          1. re: nosh

            Maybe because it was my first time and the Gods were smiling down on me, but I got a meter right in front-beats waiting in the line of cars tring to park in the lot.

            1. re: nosh

              I often park at the Vons across the street. Sometimes they have a security guard during peak hours, but then you can get a spot by the Denny's. It's half a block away but that Bay Cities lot is tough to take sometimes.

            2. I live pretty close to Bay Cities and I am a fan. The only problem is that on more than one occasion, by the time I get my sandwich home it is disgustingly soggy. I've avoided this by asking for no peppers and then buying them on the side. Their hot counter is also pretty good. I like the meatball sandwich and the spaghetti and meatballs plate. They also have some interesting candies, my favorite being the "Happy Hippos." I know that if they have hot bread out (which is just about always) that it's impossible for my boyfriend to not buy a loaf and eat half of it in the car.

              7 Replies
              1. re: Azizeh

                This is precisely why I very respectfully disagree with Dommy's preferred method of consumption. By the time you let the sandwich "rest," it's just sogged out.

                I look at it this way, sometimes you get the fresh bread and the sandwich is truly divine. Sometimes you get the bread that's been sitting for a bit and it's got a little too much chew. then it's just very good. Them's the breaks.

                I suppose you could buy a fresh loaf and have then make a sandwich from the warm bread, but I think they'd club you to death with your bread. Or at the very least the sandwich would end up costing more than it's already substantial amount.

                1. re: Frommtron

                  Okay, so this is what really happened with my sandwich....
                  I ate half of it there. Very chewy bread. I ate the other half at home, after it had been sitting for, oh, four hours or so. Really really soggy, but still delish. I think a good 10-15 minute wait would be perfect.

                  1. re: schrutefarms

                    Hmmm. Could be the reason I like my second half better than the first!

                    However, if you are lucky enough to get a sandwich made with a loaf fresh out of the oven, dive in immediately. The crust is nice and crispy rather than chewy.

                    Either way, certainly one of the treasures of the westside.

                    1. re: Frommtron

                      "Hmmm. Could be the reason I like my second half better than the first!"

                      Ya see... ;DDD

                      --Dommy!

                      1. re: Dommy

                        :) Well, sort of. Any longer than 10 minutes and it's bread pudding . . . in a really bad way.

                        1. re: Frommtron

                          I mostly have the soggy bread issue with the chicken parm. When it's a cold sandwich with the works, it can sit for a few mins...by the time you pay and get out of there in a lunch crowd, it's perfect.

                          I also posted a topic a little while back about the place... http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/573753

                          1. re: sarcasmsk

                            Right. A few minutes MAX and everything is great. I just wouldn't keep if sitting around for hours and by the next day you might as well just put it on a new roll.

              2. Popped my cherry too yesterday around 6:30 PM. Maybe because of the "holiday" or near closing, a ton of parking available. Maybe waited 2 minutes after being directed to get a number (guy I asked a little gruff, but not mean). I received a phone call so it had time to rest for about 10-15 minutes before we ate it outside. Definitely the bread makes the sandwich here (like that double baked rye at Langer's), kind of like a cross between a bready french loaf and dutch crutch. I detected a bit of sourdough flavor, but could be wrong. Got it spicy and it was a bit of a messy juicy thing, but tasty. Wish it was a little more packed with meat a la East Coast syle, but this is GOOD!