Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Feb 9, 2009 12:55 AM

Looking For The Best Of Everything Walkable From The Subway

I usually go to New York a couple of times a year. Of course, I have my favorite places to eat. But I wanted to hear from the best of you which restaurants/food stores you felt were the best in any particular category. I'll list mine, but I would certainly like to hear yours. One condition is that we never have a car when we are in town, so whatever listed needs to be walkable (within 10 blocks in a reasonably safe neighborhood) from the subway.

Pickles: Gus's (come on, there is no substitute)
Pastrami: Katz's (I know it's debatable, but I just don't like 2nd Ave, and Ben's is OK, but not close to Katz's)
Cuban: Little Havana, followed by Victor's
Corned Beef: Carnegie Deli (OK, touristy, but the Corned Beef is great)
Cheesecake: Junior's
Pizza: Still looking for great, but John's is good. Ray's is so-so
Rugalah: Ben Ash's (the only thing there I think is good)
Chinese Food: Wo Hop's
Pot Stickers: Dumpling House
Steak: Spark's (Peter Luger's tastes spoiled to me, though I do like their Strudel/Schlag combo)
Knishes: Maybe I don't like any except what my mother made. Don't like Yonah Schimmel's, Zabar's or Knish Nosh
Donuts: The Doughnut Plant
Bagels: H&H
Blintzes: Stage Deli
Lemon Cupcakes: Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery
Hot Dogs: Not bowled over by Nathan's or Papaya Dog, which seems to be OK, but the only real attraction is that it is cheap.
Soul Food: Londel's

Well, that's my list. How about yours? I once had a great Indian meal at a nice restaurant on the Upper West Side, but it was back in 86, and I can't remember the name. So, I'd love to hear favorites. Indian? Spanish? Puerto Rican/Mofongo? Others?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Cheeseburger: Corner Bistro -- can't leave that one out!

    1. I like the hotdogs at Papaya King at 86th & Third - so a block away from the subway. Also v. close to Two Little Red Hens Bakery, in case you wanted to try some of their cupcakes.

      1. I think most Manhattan residents don't have a car, or aren't willing to deal with the hassle of parking/driving, so basically you're just "Looking for The Best Of Everything" in Manhattan.

        For pizza, best in Manhattan right now is probably a toss up between Co. or Una Pizza Napoletana.

        For rugalah, I've always been partial to Zabar's.

        For Chinese: Grand Sichuan, Szechuan Gourmet, Chinatown Brasserie (upscale dim sum), Peking Duck House (just peking duck), the dumplings at TKettle, but a lot depends on what you're looking for (regional styles, particular dishes, etc.)

        6 Replies
        1. re: kathryn

          Where's TKettle? I found no results on menupages or that other menu site.

          1. re: Pan

            TKettle shares space with BBQ Chicken on St Marks Place.

            1. re: kathryn

              Oh, that place. I've never seen such high praise for their dumplings. Any particular dumplings you especially recommend there?

                1. re: kathryn

                  Thanks, kathryn. I'll definitely be checking them out soon.

                  1. re: kathryn

                    I love a good Chinese Dumpling. Can't seem to find them here in Southern Cal. They have stuff that passes for dumplings here, but nothing like what you can get in Hong Kong or Hawaii.

          2. Pastrami: In addition to Katz's, I like Sarge's. Different style but just as good.


            Pizza: Posto


            Steakhouse: Keens


            Burger: Blue Smoke and Shake Shack


            1. I also like the "Make Your Own" Sundae from Serendipity 3, using Chocolate Ice Cream, Hot Fudge and Peanut Butter Fudge. But they can be very rude and arrogant there, and they recently received a bad health dept. report, so this is on my "maybe not" list. I'll just learn how to make that Peanut Butter Fudge sauce myself and make it at home.