HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >


Enchilada Sauce?

I have a recipe I want to do that calls for Enchilada Sauce. I have looked in multiple stores and cant find it. What is this and can I make this at home .

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Any grocery store as far as all of my down here carry it in the Mexican aisle. Also whole food does and also any Mexican store or grocer. You can make it at home too. I have before, but it has been a while and don't have the recipe anymore. I truly don't use it too much and when I do I buy it.

    2 Replies
    1. re: kchurchill5

      Are you from NYC or familiar with the grocery stores/shopping here? It would seem relevant in answering the question.

      1. re: chow_gal

        I have lived up there for a few short months now and then. I was there just recently with a friend and made dinner. This is where I made the flat tacos, another post. I found premade sauce enchillada. I was just a regular grocer. Sorry can't remember the name, but just an average store. My friend lives up there and continues to make my recipe and buys the sauce so someone obviously carrys it. Besides I also said that every store down here seems to carry it. I am sure every region is different. I didn't mean every store in NY would. I just know I found it before and so has my friend and I would think most would carry it.

      1. I have also found enchilada sauce to be a frequently elusive grocery item! It seems like such a staple everywhere else in the country, you'd think New Yorkers would have easy access to it, but no.

        If it's not in the Mexican aisle of your grocers I occasionally find it with salsas or canned vegetables. I know Fairway and Associated both carry it.

        1 Reply
        1. re: JungMann

          All my salsas and canned veggies are next to the Mexican. Seems wierd it would not be available.

        2. Canned enchilada sauce? Why? Easy to make.

          I saute some onion and garlic (personal taste dictates amounts) in olive oil, I add a tablespoon of HOT chili powder (pure, not that stuff McCormick's sells) again personal taste dictates. a tablespoon of flour and saute until flour is brown, add chicken, vegetable broth stirring until thick as you want it add fresh or dried oregano according to personal taste and viloa! Simple and delicious enchilada sauce. Salt may be added also, again you know the routine.

          You're welcome.

          1 Reply
          1. re: Stuartmc910

            Like I mentioned, I make it very seldom and when I do it is usually last minute. Like I have 20 minutes for dinner on the table. I usually keep a jar in the cabinet so I pick up some tortillas, sour cream I usually have, avacado always, onion and beef always, lettuce always, tomato and the rest. 15 minutes and dinner. I have made my own and yes easy. but just down always have time. Dinner is sometimes a 15 min notice and 30 min later dinner has to be on the table ... That is why I keep sauce on hand at times. I do like home made better. But as little as I make it, canned is ok unless a nice dinner party. That is different. But a 15 min dinner at home for some of my kids friends is fine for me.

          2. just bought some enchi sauce at the grocery store since I love making cheese/ground beef/chicken enchi's and I use El Pato red enchilada sauce..it was on sale for $1.15 for the big can..
            I really like this sauce..to me it has just the right spices.
            Las Palmas red sauce is spicy, even if it is labeled mild..it can take over a dish..

            1. I'm a little confused by the question. Are you looking for some particular kind of enchilada sauce? Because I don't think I've ever been in a grocery store that didn't carry it. The cans are usually kind of small, so maybe you're missing them.

              7 Replies
              1. re: douglas525

                Ditto, my stores all do. Old El Paso and Rio something or other, standard Mexican food in any store. Many stores do carry other brands like mine but that is just the standards is most grocers

                1. re: kchurchill5

                  Guys, I looked in Gristedes and Food Emporium, neither carried it. Please stop implying I am a fool who cant shop in a store.

                  1. re: princeofpork

                    I'm not, I just know when I was up there 3 months ago, I just went to the local store. Can't remember the name and they had it. My friend also has gone to other stores closer to his home and he buys it too. I will have to find you the name of the store. It isn't a specialty store, Just a average grocery store. Honest. I've been up there 3 times in 1 year and I make Mexican for my friend cuz he likes it. I was able to fine the sauce twice, 2 different stores.

                    I wasn't implying anything. I just know they have it somewhere up there.

                    1. re: princeofpork

                      Ah, I think I see the problem. You're looking in higher end places. Stick to Key, C-Town, and the like, and you'll have no problem. I do 90% of my shopping at the C-Town right next to the projects in the LES. For some of the finer things, you'll need to go elsewhere. But for your staples, including enchilada sauce, you'll find things here a lot cheaper.

                      1. re: princeofpork

                        Princeofpork: I have a two cans of enchilada sauce sitting in my kitchen (1 red, 1 green) that I purchased at Gristedes on 32nd @Third Ave., but if they no longer carry it -- and I beileve you in this -- you might try Kalustyan's.

                        1. re: Hurner

                          Was in Queens and got it at FoodTown!!Thanks for the help.

                          1. re: princeofpork

                            Glad you found it, and so this is probably unnecessary, but two comments anyway. OLD El Paso is a good, authentic and reliable brand for this type of thing. That said, traditional Tex-Mex style (and our choice at home) is a simple Chili Gravy made as you would expect with oil, flour, everyday chili powder and water. Takes about 2 minutes and has the perfect complimentary effect for the dish.