HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
What's your latest food quest? Tell us about it

Sauerkraut disaster!

jono37 Feb 4, 2009 07:46 PM

Working from a recipe in Michael Ruhlman's Charcuterie, I chopped a head of cabbage, and submerged it in brine, placing cheesecloth over the cabbage, with a plate on top to keep everything packed down. I left this in my garage, initially uncovered; after a few days I placed a cover over it just to keep it dust free. I took the cover off after 9 days, and the container with ringed with green, malodorous mold. While dumping out the vile concoction, I did take note of the fact that actually the cabbage was intact and not decomposing. If I had been able to stomach it, I probably could have salvaged the cabbage, but there was no way to avoid the irresistible urge to cover my nose and dump the whole thing out.

Where did I go wrong? Did I need to tightly seal the container to begin with? Could the cabbage have been too old, causing it to be seeded with mold which blossomed in the bowl? Was the solution not salty enough?

Help! I was dying to have homemade sauerkraut and am willing to try again despite this fiasco.

  1. Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. d
    dmd_kc Feb 4, 2009 08:47 PM

    Did you follow the recipe to the letter? I don't own that book, but does he go by weight? I think the salt:vegetable:water ratio is the key. You have to keep the cabbage way under the top of the water. Also, I don't know where you live, but temperature is one of the most important aspects. The recipes I know say you have to keep it in the 60s or below. How warm was your garage?

    I rarely ferment anything. One of my best high school friends had a Korean grandma who had a "kimchi fridge" in the basement that was NOT to be opened. Woe to us the day our friend James got too curious. Korean food is among my favorites, but that smell still sticks with me today!

    3 Replies
    1. re: dmd_kc
      ChiliDude Feb 5, 2009 04:23 AM

      I've made kimchee using Napa cabbage several times in a large-mouth closed glass jar place in my garage during the winter. Because my wife cannot tolerate the wonderful aroma of the stuff, I cannot use the indoor refrigerator. I assume that making sauerkraut is a similar process.

      I've never had a mold problem, probably because the fermentation takes place in a closed environment.

      Just Googled 'making sauerkraut' and the 2nd hit that came up was...


      Take a look, but watch out for the typos...like the word 'scrum' instead of 'scum.'

      I still believe that a large closed jar will work better than covering a crock with cloth and plate will work better.

      1. re: ChiliDude
        Morganna Feb 5, 2009 04:42 AM


        I'm picturing a blob of rugby players pushing on the kraut keg. ;D

        1. re: ChiliDude
          Passadumkeg Feb 7, 2009 02:58 AM

          Chiledude (sic), I don't want to sound like an alarmist, but is your closed jar a screw top? If it is it could crack or "explode" from the CO2 gas build up in the fermentation process. I make both kim chee and Kapursta (Ruskkie kraut), but only use an inverted close fitting plate w/ a heavy sterile rock to hold it down over the cabbage. I cover it immediately w/ cheese cloth to keep out unwanted mold spores.
          Jono, In cabbage fermentation, brewing and wine making it is important to cover the product to keep out the little wild spores floating around in our environment (Oh my god !).

      2. Bryn Feb 4, 2009 08:56 PM

        sounds like you need more salt in that brine to inhibit the mould growth. DON'T eat things with mould on them, you could get poisoned by the toxins moulds produce.

        1. k
          Kelli2006 Feb 4, 2009 09:07 PM

          Ive never read Ruhlman's books but I don't know how you could ever get cabbage to ferment with just a brine. Sauerkraut is dirt simple to make with just shredded cabbage and a box of kosher salt in a ceramic or glass crock.

          I watched my mother and grandmother make kraut by layering 6" of shredded and cored cabbage with generous amounts of kosher salt and the covering the crock with a plate that is weighed down with a clean brick. The container is placed in a cool dark area and left to ferment for a few weeks. You only need to skim off the foam that forms and make sure the kraut is always submerged, but that is all you need to do.

          BTW, a single cabbage doesn't make enough kraut to bother with.

          1. j
            jeanmarieok Feb 4, 2009 09:29 PM

            I've had sauerkraut mold before, and I've just thrown it out and tried again, with good results. I've even had it mold just using salt and no brine. My husband was wondering if maybe the crock or plate I had on top were dirty, but I was extra careful after the first mold problem. So I don't know what caused it, but try it again, and you'll probably have better results.

            1. d
              dberg1313 Feb 5, 2009 09:46 AM

              I have been making sauerkraut all my life (well, almost--about 40 years) and there are several things that might have gone wrong. You should be using a ratio of salt to cabbage that equals 3 Tbsp. salt to 5 lb. cabbage. You are correct to keep the cabbage entirely submerged in brine; I have had most luck weighting my kraut by using an extra-large ziplock bag full of water. I use 3-gallon food safe containers and the bag will sort of "spread" to cover all the cabbage if you squeeze out any extra air. (This is hard to describe but much easier to demonstrate.) It is my habit to cover the entire pail with a large flour-sack type dishtowel, but any thin cloth should work. Also, be aware of your temperature--the best temp is about 70 degrees; any hotter and your kraut will rot. Any cooler and the kraut will not ferment. You don't have to worry about minor variations in temperature, but if it gets sunny in your garage, it could get much warmer than you think. Kraut is still usable if you get a minor amount of pink or tan discoloration but I would be very reluctant to use any kraut that had mold--it can go into the compost pile, and try again. It is best not to disturb the kraut, or do so as little as possible, for the first few days. OK to lift up your weight to check on the progress; you should see some bubbling (it may even bubble over, but that's OK) but it should never be slimy or smell bad. You do not need to cover the container you are fermenting in tightly--in fact that is a bad idea. The fact that your cabbage was not "decomposing" may be one hint. It is possible you packed it too tightly or did not distribute the salt completely enough. I know in Pennsylvania the state has county "extension services" which will give free advice (check on line) about canning and preserving, also I would caution you not to use a glass jar to try to make kraut in. My mother did it successfully once, but she was the type to scrape mold off something figuring "You have to die of something" (!) I'd rather not chance it.

              3 Replies
              1. re: dberg1313
                Bryn Feb 6, 2009 03:55 PM

                the pink or tan discolouration is a yeast growing and it's likely part of the fermentation process.

                1. re: Bryn
                  julibelle Jul 25, 2011 05:06 PM

                  pink or tan are definitly no go areas - I am a pretty wild fermenter but I do toss any pink or beige...

                2. re: dberg1313
                  Passadumkeg Feb 7, 2009 03:03 AM

                  dberg, I come from Ruskkie Pennsy coal mining stock and I too have been making kapusta for eons. Grew up making 300 lbs worth with grand parents, ants & uncles and parents, powered by Yuengling! We now even grow our own cabbages.
                  I agree w/ everything you've said.
                  Good work.
                  Sosh Passadumbrowsky

                3. c
                  celeriac Feb 5, 2009 11:09 AM

                  To start with, you definitely don't want to seal it. It will probably explode if nothing else, and worst case it could produce other undesirable effects, although I don't know about that. To cover it, use a clean cloth so that air can still pass through but you're keeping contaminants (dust, bugs, etc) out.

                  What part of the container was covered with mold? The bucket/crock? Or the brine itself?

                  I have to say, I've had lots of things go funky in kraut making, I never let it faze me as long as the kraut looks fine, and I've never suffered ill effects. I've had wild mold and scum floating on the top of the brine, and I've either skimmed it off or dumped the brine and made a whole new brine, both techniques have worked fine for me. I believe the plastic-bag-on-top method may prevent a lot of mold growth, but I've never used it.

                  1 Reply
                  1. re: celeriac
                    juncojunction Oct 10, 2010 05:53 PM

                    My husband started his first sauerkraut a week ago. It's submerged in a round canister with a plate to hold the cabbage under water. He's been scooping a few moldy pieces of cabbage that are floating, but now the brine is brown. Any ideas or tips will be appreciated!

                  2. hohokam Feb 5, 2009 11:27 AM

                    I had the same outcome using their method. Not sure where I went wrong, and I haven't had a chance to make another attempt. I'm going to take another shot at it, but I'll probably use a different approach next time.

                    1. t
                      tastesgoodwhatisit Oct 10, 2010 08:06 PM

                      I would use a recipe that calls for salt by weight rather than volume - the actual amount of salt in a volume can vary by a few 100%, depending on the crystal size and shape.

                      1. m
                        minabell Apr 14, 2014 09:22 AM

                        I just opened the jar that I made the sauerkraut in to taste and see if it has enough salt and it was bubbly on top like champagne is that bad?
                        do I put the jar in the fridge now after a wok is it better to do so once I open the lid?

                        Show Hidden Posts