HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Discussion

good chicken pot pie

I went to Yaffa;s in tribeca , they redecorated the fancy half of the restaurant, the bar area is still the same. The chicken pot pie didnt even resemble chicken pot pie. the only reason I knew what it was , was because it was what I ordered. It had a piece of chicken breast on top of some vegetables and a spoon of pie dough on top .. technically it had some of the ingredients for chicken pot pie but it was like ordering pizza and getting a tomato, a hunk of cheese and a piece of dough,,,, Any recs for real and good chicken pot pie

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. I've had really good Chicken Pot Pie at Square Meal, but it's not always on the menu.

    1 Reply
    1. re: MMRuth

      Thanks everyone. This cold weather for some reason put me in mood for good chicken pot pie. Now i have some choices all over town ,,GREAT

    2. The chicken pot pie at Molly's is the traditional chicken pot pie and it's excellent.

      3 Replies
      1. re: sloane

        I've always been curious about the Molly's chicken pot pie but then again, I find it hard to stray away from the shepherd's pie

        1. re: ESNY

          I'm a shepherd's pie addict, and I've always been curious about both the chicken pot pie AND the shepherd's pie. But I can't stay away from their burgers.

          1. re: egit

            After a few years of going burger only, I finally made the jump to the sheperds pie and haven't looked back...

      2. Waverly Inn
        Tea and Sympathy

        1. Penelope's has a great chicken pot pie

          1. Friend of a Farmer on Irving has great Chicken Pot Pie

            1 Reply
            1. Bar Americain has a really good Chicken Pot Pie, although it's made from smoked chicken, but has a nice smokey flavor.

              1. While this is not an exact match with your question, if youre a chicken pot pie lover its worth noting that the "Twin Hen" chicken pot pie in the frozen food section of Dean and Deluca is great.

                1. Pershing Square has a terrific pot pie

                  1. Tartine in the West Village has one of the best Chicken Pot Pies in the world. and the price is downright cheap. Bring your own wine.

                    a fun and cozy place.