HOME > Chowhound > General South Archive >
What have you made lately?
TELL US

Birmingham — New Jewish Deli

SkippyLeBeef Jan 27, 2009 11:59 AM

Max's Delicatessen is in the Colonnade off 280 and 459. They opened Friday, had lunch there today.

Awesome pastrami and corned beef sammiches.

Other items include:
Mini potato knish w/ brown gravy, latke with homemade apple sauce and sour cream, BBQ salami served with housemade honey mustard, matzo ball soup, roasted beef brisket with mashed potatoes and gravy, mixed pickle plate with old and new dill pickles, The Cliff burger topped with pastrami and slaw, sauteed chicken livers and onions, hot or cold beef tongue, a variety of Reuben sammiches, Max's famous coffee cake, cheesecake and chopped liver.

Definitely going back.

It was packed at lunch today. Small wait for a table.

  1. b
    Big Daddy Jan 27, 2009 01:23 PM

    We picked up a menu the other night and can't wait to try it.

    2 Replies
    1. re: Big Daddy
      SkippyLeBeef Jan 28, 2009 07:25 AM

      They do breakfast too. Can't wait to try their bagels....

      1. re: Big Daddy
        Brawny Feb 2, 2009 11:13 AM

        EVERY restaurant/deli will open to rave reviews. Check back in six months...time will be the real test.

      2. Dax Jan 28, 2009 11:12 AM

        I am SO excited about this. If I didn't have plans for dinner, I would be there tonight. Maybe tomorrow for lunch.

        Here's an article from al.com

        http://blog.al.com/bob-carlton/2009/01/maxs_an_authentic_jewish_delic.html

        Website only has number & address but I just asked them to fax me a copy of the menu.

        http://www.maxsdelionline.com/

        5 Replies
        1. re: Dax
          Dax Jan 29, 2009 04:42 PM

          I stopped in to get a Reuben to go today. It was awesome with tons of chopped pastrami and the right amount of kraut, dressing and a piece of swiss. I ordered the combo for $1.99 more which was supposed to include fries and slaw. I never got the slaw. The fries are regular frozen steak fries but coated with a decent bit of dried seasoning (kind of like lawrys but better?). I'll definitely return to try the other stuff.

          They told me no breakfast/bagels yet (?) but considering it.

          1. re: Dax
            b
            bovinekid Jan 29, 2009 08:52 PM

            I also got a Reuben there today, but I did dine-in. Definitely the best corned beef I've had in town. I had a couple of issues with the service, though.

            I was in there after the lunch rush, so it wasn't especially crowded. Still, after I was seated I had to wait a pretty long time before anyone acknowledged me. There were plenty of staff, but it seemed like no one wanted to wait on me. In fact, given how many of them there were and how few customers, I nearly walked out. The hostess seemed confused before she seated me, so I was probably not in anyone's actual section.

            One of the owners was wandering about the whole time and seemed pretty oblivious. I guess he didn't recognize me from having gone to high school and religious school with his daughter. He was talking to one customer when I left, but for the most part he seemed pretty anti-social for an owner of a new restaurant who spends all his time in the dining room.

            Another (very) minor gripe was that the sandwich was pretty messy, and I only had the napkin that the silverware came wrapped in. There was plenty off staff around the whole time, so I could have easily flagged one down and asked for one, but I wanted to see if they would offer first.

            Most of the time I was sitting there, I was thinking about the various members of my extended family; all Jewish, all less tolerant of bad service than I, to varying degrees. I couldn't help thinking "If they want to attract Jews to this place, they better step up the service."

            I'll definitely be giving them another visit, though.

            1. re: Dax
              Dax Jan 29, 2009 09:52 PM

              Ahh, sorry I forgot it was corned beef on the reuben, next time I will try the rachel.

              1. re: Dax
                SkippyLeBeef Jan 30, 2009 09:54 AM

                A lady in the same office as I called in an order earlier in the week, waited 30 minutes, went in and her order was nowhere to be found. She waited 30 minutes on her reorder and when she got back to the office found she didn't get exactly what she ordered. Oh, well....working out the kinks....

              2. re: Dax
                Dax Feb 28, 2009 01:50 PM

                Stopped in today to eat in and have a latke and pastrami sandwich. Latke was awesome, fried a dark brown though. Pastrami was good if a little underseasoned. I prefer the corned beef.

                While I was eating, I was reading a Bham Weekly and the owner came over to point out the Bye One, Get One Free corned beef coupon (takeout only).

                Bovine, I had the same napkin issue as by the end of the sandwich, I was a bit of a mess and my single napkin was destroyed. They should have dispensers on the table if using paper napkins.

            2. a
              AnnaFlannery Jan 31, 2009 09:11 PM

              Went there last night (Friday the 30th) around 6:30. Fairly full place, prompt service. The food was very good - but we ate very light (were going to the movies afterwards) and our turkey sandwich and chicken salad sandwich came to $17. - no extras, water to drink. If we'd bumped the sandwiches up to getting combos and gotten any drink but water, we'd be pushing 30 bucks for two for sandwiches....

              But they *were* good!

              2 Replies
              1. re: AnnaFlannery
                p
                pinotboy Feb 1, 2009 07:58 AM

                I had lunch there yesterday (Saturday). I had the pastrami with an order of fries. Dax is right; the fries are just typical frozen steak fries, but the pastrami was excellent. Maybe not quite up to what is served at Katz's Deli on Manhattan's Lower East Side, but heads and shoulders above anything else in Birmingham.

                1. re: pinotboy
                  b
                  Big Daddy Feb 2, 2009 09:28 AM

                  I'd attribute some of those problems mentioned above to being newly opened. Went last week with my wife and two small children and we had a great experience. They definitely seemed overwhelmed, but nothing outrageous happened.
                  My corned beef on rye was great -- small piece of bread but properly stacked meat inside. It attracted lots of older Jewish people, which I always take as a good sign. They raved about the tongue.
                  When we told the owner our son is named Max, he brought us some desserts to sample. I recommend both the chocolate cake and the poppy-seed/orange cake.

              2. b
                birminghamvisitor Feb 22, 2009 10:58 AM

                I can attest that Max's is really awesome!! My wife and I went yesterday for lunch...super busy, and boy was it delicious. I had really high expectations going in b/c of this thread, and Max's lived up and exceeded them!

                The pickle plate that they brought out was amazing! I have never had pickeled green tomato before, and thought they were awesome with the ranch. We had the latke appitizer and I had the Russian Ruben (pastrami...oooh peppery and garlicy....mmmmm) and my wife had the Chicken Salad app. Everything was great, and the Rye was exceptional, and not overpowering with the rye flavor. My only complaint is that I no MUST go back b/c the Brisket sandwich with the Latke as the bread I must try! And there were quite a few other things that sounded really great too!

                Two HUGE thumbs up for Max's!!!

                2 things...the service was not perfect, but good enough, and it is not cheap, but I dont mind paying for quality...and I do have 1/2 of my sandwich in the fridge. (Monday's Lunch!)

                1. a
                  Andrew in Alabama Feb 23, 2009 08:41 AM

                  Let me put in another enthusiastic thumbs-up for Max's. We went in last night and were concerned to find an empty dining room at about 5:15, but by the time we left, the place was about 80% full on a Sunday night.

                  We tasted a number of things off the menu... the pickle platter is highly recommended... I haven't been able to find "new" pickles anywhere in Alabama, and these were great. Also the pickled tomatoes were really tasty.

                  The chopped liver was creamy and delicious, and I loved the rye bread it was served with.

                  Potato pancakes were thin and a little on the greasy side, but the flavor was spot-on and they were served appropriately, with applesauce and sour cream.

                  We ordered knishes but they were gone by the time I had a chance to try them.

                  On to the meats. We ordered a couple of the sampler platters, and chose tongue, pastrami, corned beef, brisket, turkey, and salami. All of the meats were very good, but the show-stopper was the house made turkey. It was just awesome... not dry at all and very very tasty. I could eat this every day. In fact, I am about to eat the leftovers for lunch.

                  The very friendly owner spent a good deal of time talking to us about his suppliers. He is originally from Detroit, and most of his meats come from that area.

                  I cannot recommend this place more... and try the turkey!

                  7 Replies
                  1. re: Andrew in Alabama
                    b
                    birminghamvisitor Feb 23, 2009 07:10 PM

                    SHEESH...GREAT...now I have to try the turkey! :-)

                    1. re: birminghamvisitor
                      SkippyLeBeef Mar 2, 2009 07:11 AM

                      Since my original post I have been back about five times. I work right around the corner. Lox and bagel, awesome. Combo chopped liver/pastrami sammich, probably one of my new favorites. On my most recent trip I did hear on table complain their food took 40 minutes. But at another table were two native New Yorkers and they were raving about the hot pastrami.

                      1. re: SkippyLeBeef
                        Dax Mar 2, 2009 08:31 AM

                        So they do have breakfast?

                        1. re: Dax
                          SkippyLeBeef Mar 3, 2009 07:13 AM

                          No breakfast yet. They tried it and the owner said they just didn't have their stuff together yet.

                          FORGOT TO MENTION: Can't remember if it's in Birmingham Weekly or the Black & White (but it's in one of the free bi-weeklies) Max's has a coupon right on the first couple of pages, upper right hand corner, buy one $8 corned beef sammich, get a second one free. The coupon says "carry-out only," but the owner said he would honor it for dine-in as well. FYI. I have two.

                          1. re: SkippyLeBeef
                            Dax Mar 3, 2009 08:12 AM

                            It's the Birmingham Weekly. I can't believe I wrote "bye one" above instead of buy one - wow that is bad.

                            1. re: Dax
                              b
                              Big Daddy Mar 3, 2009 02:10 PM

                              Since you're purchasing it to go, buy bye is appropriate.

                              1. re: Dax
                                salbham Mar 4, 2009 07:34 AM

                                Dax -- I've only been on chowhound for a week and every post I've created or responded to has had at least one typo (or three), wish this site had spell check, alhough in your case of "bye one" I guess this wouldn't have helped. I didn't even notice when I read the post!

                    2. bhamdining Mar 9, 2009 06:57 PM

                      Went for a late lunch last Friday and loved it! One of the best Reubens I've ever had, incredibly tender and tasty corned beef piled high. And I liked the hearty thick-sliced rye, which was able to stand up to all the meat and dressing and kraut. The chopped liver and pastrami sandwich was also great, although actually just a bit less of the assertive liver might have made for a better balance. Knishes and brown gravy were delish, latke a bit on the done side and a little greasy (but it still disappeared). We'll definitely be back; I didn't have room to try the cheesecake!

                      1. t
                        tarheelinbama Mar 11, 2009 06:28 AM

                        Went to Max's last night for dinner and was really impressed! Seems like they've been working out the kinks and listening to customer feedback (Dax - we were brought extra napkins with our meals).

                        Service was great. As soon as we sat down the owner brought out a basket of carrots and celery with ranch dressing. I ordered the corned beef and cabbage and my husband chose the rueben. We also got a pickle plate based on recommendations from this board, and loved it. My meal started with mazo ball soup, and it really was amazing. It was made using authentic, made-from-scratch chicken stock, juicy chicken and just the right amount of seasoning. I've never had soup like that at a restaurant, period.

                        The food didn't take long, and there was a mix-up in the kitchen and the chef made stuffed cabbage instead of corned beef and cabbage for my meal. The owner realized this before the plate even got to our table, but brought out the stuffed cabbage anyway for us to taste. All of the food was excellent. The corned beef is tender and thickly sliced, and not at all greasy. They get the rye bread from a bakery in Detroit and it's unlike anything I've tasted down here. They also have 3 different mustards on each table.

                        The portions are huge, and I don't understand complaints about the price. The rueben was $8.99 and the corned beef and cabbage was $13.99 (with 2 sides and soup) and you couldn't buy just the corned beef for that price at a grocery store. This is real, authentic food - not Subway. I can't wait to go back and try more of the menu items. We need more restaurants like this in Birmingham and I hope they stick around!

                        1. a
                          americurl Sep 3, 2009 12:46 PM

                          We finally tried Max's (got some take out) and were quite pleased. The Matzoh ball soup was absolute heaven. It had an awesome stock, seasoned perfectly with a little dill, and the matzoh ball was light and tasty. The hot tongue sandwich was off the charts, so tender and yummy. I tasted a little bit of hubby's chopped liver, and it was good, but I'm no liver fan, so I can't rate it properly. Service--still the same, a little slow, did not give us the fries we ordered. Price--yeah, a tad on the high side for deli food, but worth it. Quality--absolutely top notch. All in all, a good place to eat, and we will go back for more.

                          1. e
                            Endless Steven Sep 5, 2009 08:50 AM

                            My office ordered sandwich trays from Max's recently. Normally, my hatred for sandwich trays is legendary, but these were GOOD. I mean, really, really good.

                            I haven't been to the shop yet, but their mass produced sandwiches were awesome.

                            1 Reply
                            1. re: Endless Steven
                              Jannae Sep 6, 2009 03:32 PM

                              Has anyone been there for breakfast recently?

                            Show Hidden Posts