HOME > Chowhound > New Jersey >
What's your latest food project? Get great advice

Unofficial poll on best places to eat in NJ (high end and cheap) - moved from Tristate board

mtevcm Jan 17, 2009 01:16 PM

Okay all...just for foodie fun on a cold day...let's take an informal poll of the best places (high, middle of the road and cheap end) to eat in NJ, best locales to stroll to find ethnic food, and most overrated. I am a world traveler who loves to eat, and former NYC resident, so I was initially miserable when I came out to the burbs, thinking there would be no wonderful place to eat. I was wrong. While there certainly aren't as many places as NYC, there are many jewels. And, like someone else said on the blog earlier, it's the burbs---so everything is spread out. Add your thoughts, and I will put mine below (decidely Central and Northern end of the state, as that's where I am) to start off.

Mid to higher end restaurants:
***Stage Left in New Brunswick (higher end, unless you do the limited hrs for lunch, but fabulous food, service and wine...will help you with the wine too and not be rude...consistent too...I can never say enough about it...catch their podcasts...go for the special events...Paul Hobbs is coming...sad the wine shop is no more...remember tasting some special barrel bourbons there...yum

Stagehouse (Scotch Plains)...prix fixe great, lovely hangar steak and mushroom soup with truffle oil and a killer potato tarte...average desserts though

Boulevard Five72 in Kenilworth...yum, nuff said

A Toute Heure in Cranford...my shining star of the moment...pleeeeeez go! Fun, original, and on the slow food movement tip. Flavor is "in" again.

Frog and Peach...consistent and good

Catherine Lombardi's in New Brunswick (yum...owned by the Stage Left crew)...fab food...fab cocktails...

A little cheaper Middle of the road in price restaurants:
Makedas in New Brunswick (LOVE IT) or Mesob in Montclair for Ethiopian

Daimatsu Japanese Restaurant in Mountainside...consistent and yummy sushi...ignore the look of the place and go to eat...whatever is on the specials board, make sure you order it...and they know how to do lovely little fried oysters and more

Thailand Restaurant (yes, that is actually the name) in Clark, is consistent and authentic, with great seafood. They're in a converted silver metal diner, but ignore the looks and eat there. Packed on the weekend, for sure. Fast and friendly for takeout too.

Really cheap restaurants/and fab takeout places:
Udupi Village (Montclair)...horrible ambience but the super duper tasty and super inexpensive dosas and uthappams are so filling and yummy

European Provisions in East Brunswick...lovely sandwiches made from their own smoked hams...in the Polish tradition...order a ham here for the holidays, but make sure it has the bone in, as it is more flavorful

Mr. Tod's Pie Factory in Somerset..Chocolate cream, sweet potato, pumpkin, or key lime are my favorites, but all the berry and apple pies are really good, considering no one knows how to make pie anymore, or charges way too much. His price is right. The main locale in Somerset is only for takeout pie, though I heard he has a small place in a different location in Somerset to sit and eat pie too, I think. Do not order for the holidays, unless you are prepared to wait in a massive line snaking out the door. Go on some other random weekend and treat yourself.

Locales for cheap eats that I love:
1/Polish food shops in Linden (homemade hams and cold cuts to die for at fab prices for fresh meat)...and some prepared foods, like stuffed cabbage, pierogies, mushroom soups, mushroom salads, and more
2/Little India in Edison and Iselin...chaat shops, markets, cheap eats and more...pick up the Indian meal in a bag and some yogurt and mango pickle at a market and you have a cheap meal that's way more nutritious and inexpensive than fast food
4/AUTHENTIC Japanese and not for an arm and a leg, head over to Edgewater and go to Mitsuwa plaza mall for wonderful food stands with real Japanese broth soups (ramen), soba, rice bowls, sushi, udon, and more...there's wonderful Japanese food markets with tons of wonderful teas, cakes, confections, candies, and fish...don't forget to stop for green bubble tea!

Place I haven't gone to yet, but I am dying to go to, considering how many people I know love it:
Lorena's in Maplewood

Most overated and overpriced and wouldn't return:
David Drake (for the price and all the hype, I was expecting one of the more memorable meals of my life)...good but not great...though the place is romantic

Would love some more ideas from you or thoughts on my picks!

  1. w
    winepoet Aug 26, 2012 06:37 AM

    okay read through not sure if I am seeing what I am looking for going to NPAC newark would love some portugese suggestions

    1 Reply
    1. re: winepoet
      Curlz Aug 26, 2012 08:00 AM

      For Portuguese restaurants, search the board for Newark and Ironbound--and then go to Casa Vasca or Seabra's Marisqueiria! :-)

      Fwiw, the restaurant at NJPAC is now being run by the family that owns Fascino and Bar Cara. While I haven't been to the NJPAC spot since they took over, they can be reliably counted on for very good eats!

    2. p
      ParadiseWaits Apr 26, 2009 02:27 PM

      Favorite tomato pies: DeLorenzo's Hamilton
      Farvorte pizza: Vesuvio's Belmar
      Favorite Thai: Four Seasons, Edison/Tuptim, Montclair
      Favorite Chineese: Little Schezauan Little Silver
      Favorite Italian: Too many to mention
      Favorite Seafood: Harry's Sea Bright
      Favorite All Around Restaurant: Bay Ave Tratorria, Highlands
      Favorite Mexican: Joyce's Bakery, Bound Brook
      Favorite Southern: Jameson's Neptune
      Favorite New American: Stage Left, New Brunswick,
      Favorite Burger: Red, Red Bank
      Favorite 'Special Occasion': Nicholas, Middletown
      Favorite Fix Price: Green Gables, LBI
      Favorite Romantic: Whispers, Spring Lake

      1. Ike Apr 24, 2009 01:26 PM

        On the inexpensive side:

        Little Saigon at 19 Elm St. in Montclair is outstanding. Far better than any Vietnamese I've had in Manhattan (or virtually anywhere else).

        Also, check out Kamil's in Clifton for astonishing Lebanese/Turkish. It's cheap, too.

        And Chengdu 1, at 89 Pompton Ave in Cedar Grove (in Essex Co., near Montclair) for great inexpensive Sichuan. This is almost as good as Flushing and you don't have to go so far!

        1. a
          aacharya Feb 2, 2009 12:17 PM

          Best way to keep this thread working is for you to edit your original post and incorporate our comments - wiki style.

          If you want to keep your thread as-is, post twice in succession. Then people can look to your second post as a guide. Who knows - you may become a sticky!

          2 Replies
          1. re: aacharya
            seal Feb 2, 2009 02:50 PM

            Well, let's see...

            Trinity - Best high-end burger (Trinity Burger) and great Boar Arepas
            Drew's Bayshore Bistro - Voodoo shrimp
            Flakey Tart - as my Jamaican friend used to say, "Ev'ryting"
            Pad Thai - Chinese sausage fried rice, beef with garlic, jumbo shrimp curry w avocado
            Thai Chili - Papaya salad, Whole fish w tamarind sauce
            Jack's Rib N Ale House - best wings in NJ
            Belford Bistro - Agnolotti (sp?) and much more
            Ibby's - falafel hummus combo sandwich
            Nicholas - best high end meal in NJ
            Westlake Seafood - Winter melon soup, any seafood w salt and pepper
            Kanji - salad dressing!, specialty rolls
            Frankie Fed's - salad dressing, sausage pizza
            Jose Tejas - gumbo

            I'm sure I missed a few.

            1. re: seal
              shabbystorm Feb 22, 2009 01:08 PM

              Some Picks from my daily eating adventures - take a NJ road trip and try some great food. NJ Foods You Must Try!

              Joe Leone's Point Pleasant NJ - Eggplant Pie!
              Kyoto Rt 9 Englishtown NJ - Sashimi
              Kyoto Rt 36 Atlantic Highlands NJ - Sushi Winter Roll
              Ming Edison NJ - Vegetarian Hakka Noodles
              Tung Hsing House Spotswood NJ - Chicken and Broccoli
              Krispy Pizza Old Bridge NJ - Grandma Pizza
              Carmen's Bakery Union NJ - Best Italian Bread!
              Hong Fu Highland Park NJ - Soup Dumplings
              Perlins Vegetarian Cherry Hill NJ - Mushroom Bourekas
              Yumi Sea Bright NJ - Cheesecake Tempura
              Surf Taco Point Pleasant NJ - Surf Taco
              Saigon or Saigon II Lincroft NJ - Vietnamese Egg Rolls
              Ling Ling Riverwalk Chinese Basking Ridge NJ - Pancake Wrapped Shrimp
              Organic Tofu House Ridgewood NJ - Seafood Pancake
              Bluewater Seafood Grill East Brunswick NJ- Roasted Potatoes
              Flaky Tart Atlantic Highlands NJ - Macaroni and Cheese
              Veggie Heaven Upper Montclair NJ - Vege Roast Pork
              Flirt Sushi Lounge Allendale NJ - Spicy Tuna Tortilla
              Mendokers Bakery Jamesburg NJ - Cinnamon Sugar Strawberry Paczki
              Big Ed's Old Bridge NJ - Baby Back All You Can Eat Ribs
              Rosa's Bakery Shrewsbury NJ - Ice Cream Cannoli
              Pop Shop Collingswood NJ - Pretzel Grilled Cheese Sandwich
              IHOP - Smiley Face Pancake
              Antonio's Mozzarella Factory Springfield NJ -
              Fried Eggplant Mozzarella Red Peppers and Pesto
              Greek Store Kenilworth NJ - Pastitito and Mousaka
              The Petite Cafe Nutley NJ - Try any one of the 100 Stuffed Cupcakes
              Cafe de Thai Matawan NJ - Mango with Sticky Rice
              Donna Toscana Chocolates Cranford NJ - Olive Oil and Salt Truffle
              Panico's New Brunswick NJ - Gnocchi
              Panera Bread - Breakfast Egg Souffle
              Lucy's Ravioli Kitchen Princeton NJ - Roller
              Harold's Deli Edison NJ - Pastrami Sandwich
              Dixie Picnic Ocean City NJ - Upcake
              Delicious Orchards Colts Neck NJ - Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
              Wemrock Orchards Freehold NJ - Peach Pie and Apple Cider Donuts
              Fuji Dayton NJ - Yummy Yummy Sushi Roll
              Mastoris Diner Bordentown NJ - Cheese Bread
              Harvest Moon New Brunswick NJ - Puddin Bites (Oh My)
              Ristorante da Benito Union NJ - Pasta e Fagioli Soup
              Abbate Bakery Matawan NJ - Pignoli Cookie

              Life is short! Eat Well - Stay Happy - Live Long!

          2. equal_Mark Feb 2, 2009 11:43 AM

            Boom - Belmar

            Best burgers in NJ.

            1. HillJ Jan 31, 2009 03:48 PM

              Spirito's for the bar pie, ravioli and garlic salad, Elizabeth
              Keyport Fishery for the shrimp & scallop platter w/extra coleslaw, Keyport
              Saigon II for the spring rolls, Lincroft
              Eurasian Eatery for the curry lasagna, Red Bank
              Bistro on Main Street for the greens & pear salad, Red Bank
              Trinity for the entire appetizer menu, Keyport
              Drew's Bayshore Bistro for the pork streudel, Keyport
              Angela's Pizza for the chicken marsala pizza, Hazlet
              Flakey Tart for the key lime mini tarts, Atl Highlands
              Havana Tropical Cafe for the shredded flank steak cuban style, Highlands
              Manow Asian Bistro for the curry dishes and jasmine tea
              Blackbird Dining Estb. for the homemade pasta, Collingswood
              Belford Bistro for the rack of lamb, Belford
              Bertucci's for the martinis (yes, the do it right), Hazlet
              Jameson's for the mac n cheese and fried flounder, Neptune
              Hot Dog Place for the amazing soups, Red Bank
              Chez Catherine for fine fish prep; especially sea bass, Westfield
              The Mad Batter for brunch, Cape May
              Peter Shields Inn for melt in your mouth lobster, Cape May
              Kenilworth Diner for gigantic cream puffs, Kenilworth
              Le Rendez-Vous for french food fix, Kenilworth
              Neelam for Indian food, Middletown
              Mr. J's for deli style "sloppy joes," Cranford
              The Manor for absolutely anything on the menu (especially tartare's), West Orange
              Okay...I have to stop here....too many!

              13 Replies
              1. re: HillJ
                MGZ Feb 1, 2009 07:04 AM

                Cheers, HillJ!

                You may not agree with every selection, but if reading that list doesn't make your mouth water, this may not be the best website for you.

                1. re: HillJ
                  tom246 Feb 1, 2009 07:20 AM

                  Been to many of the places above, I'm kinda liking Hillj's list.

                  1. re: tom246
                    HillJ Feb 1, 2009 10:07 AM

                    Thanks MGZ & tom246, I equally enjoy the rec's both of you have made on CH. Thanks for the reads & reviews during 08. Cheers to you both.

                    ps-I should have also added my "trainer" for the workouts so I can enjoy these favs w/less guilt!

                    1. re: HillJ
                      tom246 Feb 1, 2009 10:13 AM

                      Trainer, LOL... I just returned from a 90 minute walk through the hills of Western Monmouth County to work off nights like last night :))

                  2. re: HillJ
                    HillJ Feb 1, 2009 01:20 PM


                    Although the NJ-based Nomad Pizza Co. is not a "place...." it's a traveling wood fire pizza caterer....if you happen upon an event or private party where Nomad's is hosting, go out of your way to experience this absolutely show stopping eating opportunity.

                    Their event calendar for 09 is not posted yet, but check back in March.

                    1. re: HillJ
                      HillJ Feb 1, 2009 07:10 PM

                      D'jeet for burgers-Red Bank/Middletown

                    2. re: HillJ
                      dani0622 Feb 1, 2009 03:30 PM

                      I've been to a third of the places on HillJ's list and I agree with them. Now I'll have to check out the other half since we seem to have the same taste.

                      I also enjoy Zoe's Vintage Kitchen in Atlantic Highlands for breakfast and lunch.

                      Sugar and Sunshine Bakery in Plainsboro for cupcakes and triple chocolate cookies.

                      Hot Dog Tommy's in Cape May

                      McDonagh's in Keyport for a burger

                      Trinity, Keyport, for the Catalan Clams and if it's on the menu Tuna Cannoli

                      Drew's Bayshore Bistro, Keyport for the garlic crawfish and funny bone

                      Aki Sushi, Port Monmouth for their Sunday Sushi Brunch

                      1. re: dani0622
                        HillJ Feb 1, 2009 04:36 PM

                        dani, I've been meaning to try Zoe's! If work takes me out that way soon, I'll report back.

                        1. re: HillJ
                          dani0622 Feb 1, 2009 05:18 PM

                          HillJ -

                          Some stuff is very good, but they can overdo it. For example, they have a Linzer French Toast which would be great if they cut the amount of sour cream they used.

                          Love the ham sandwich and potato salad for lunch.

                          1. re: dani0622
                            HillJ Feb 1, 2009 07:07 PM

                            I pride myself on making killer french toast..so I won't bother ordering it. Have you tried their omeletes?

                            1. re: HillJ
                              dani0622 Feb 2, 2009 01:48 PM

                              I haven't had their omelets but I've had their eggs and it was a nice hearty dish. Pancakes were pretty good too.

                      2. re: HillJ
                        equal_Mark Feb 2, 2009 07:02 AM

                        Where is Bistro on Main Street in Red Bank? I can't find any reference to it and to my knowledge there is no Main St. in Red Bank...

                        1. re: equal_Mark
                          HillJ Feb 2, 2009 07:05 AM


                          Oops! The Bistro is on Broad Street! Thanks for catching that eM.

                      3. r
                        robertjsweet Jan 31, 2009 11:52 AM

                        Some from my favorite's list

                        Italian-Libretti's, Nassau St, Orange NJ
                        Malaysian, Chinese, Asian, Vegetarian-Asia Restaurant, The Boulevard, Kenilworth NJ
                        Fried Seafood-Keyport Fishery, Keyport NJ
                        Pizza-Frank Pepe's, Wooster St, New Haven CT
                        Pizza-Reservior Tavern, Boonton(Parsipanny) NJFr
                        Spanish Food/Steaks-Don Pepe's Steak House, Route 46W, Pine Brook NJ
                        Hot Dogs-Amazing Hot Dogs, Bound Brook NJ
                        Huge Portion Comfort Food-Harolds, Edison NJ
                        French Fries-Curley Fries, Boadwalk locations, Wildwood NJ
                        French Fries-Pomme Frites, 2nd Avenue, NYC
                        Cheese Steaks-Steve's Prince of Steaks, Philadelphia locations. PA
                        BBQ-Bailey's Smokehouse at the Blauvelt Inn, Erie St, Blauvelt NY
                        Fried Chicken- Boom Boom Chicken, Main St, Fort Lee NJ
                        Ices-Rita's, various locations thru out the NJ area
                        Portuguese, Brazilian BBQ- Route 22 West, Union NJ
                        Hamburger's-Cheeseburger Cheeseburger, North Ave, Westfield NJ
                        Deli-Larry's Deli, St George's Ave, Rahway(Linden) NJ
                        Deli-Irvings, Route 10 East, Livingston(E Hanover) NJ
                        English Style Fish & Chips-A Salt & Battery, Greenwich St, NYC
                        Portuguese Brazilian, Spanish-Solar di Minho, E Westfiled Ave (Rt 28), Roselle Park NJ
                        Sushi- Still looking for some superior consistant sushimi
                        French- Still looking for either some peasant style or fancy french, a work still in progress

                        As you can see...I will travel for food and think I've presented some pretty good choices...feel free to agree or disagree but to each his or her own...we all have our favorites and these are some of mine

                        2 Replies
                        1. re: robertjsweet
                          Elora Feb 2, 2009 01:23 PM

                          Last I knew, Cheeburger Cheeburger was closed in Westfield. Did it reopen?

                          BTW, great sushi/sushimi to be had in Westfield at Nagoya in Westfield. Very consistant, high quality - great owner/chef, Henry, just delightful.

                          1. re: robertjsweet
                            andydl11 Aug 25, 2012 06:52 AM

                            Reo 22 is good for Portugese/Brazilian for but I think that Fernando's steak house in Newark is 10 times better. MUST GET THE 24 OZ FILET MIGNON ON THE TILE for $27.00. Its the best steak that I ever had

                          2. Caralien Jan 31, 2009 04:08 AM

                            Wouldn't this list be easier to use and navigate through if the places listed were linked to? (it's the "Link to a place" image next to the "post my reply" button.

                            1. Passadumkeg Jan 30, 2009 02:34 PM

                              Morgan Fishery, Rt. 35 N, Sayreville. Best seafood this side of the Piscatiqua River.

                              1. modernist Jan 28, 2009 05:42 AM

                                hi folks,

                                i am from los angeles, but working in philly and my friend is in somerset nj at the doubletree hotel.

                                whats a good place to eat? i will be arriving tonight around 8:30. polish shops sound cool. but which ones and what time do they close? same with authentic portuguese food in newark. which places specifically please?

                                chaat shops in iselin sounds cool too. but can i get specific names so i can locate them call to make sure they are open and go/


                                7 Replies
                                1. re: modernist
                                  Curlz Jan 28, 2009 07:38 AM

                                  If you're going to be in Somerset, your best bet is to go to New Brunswick...I'm sure a search for NB on this board will yield specifics, but:
                                  Makeda for Ethiopian (GREAT vibe and the food is terrific, imo)
                                  Stage Left
                                  Daryl's Wine Bar
                                  There are a few thoughts to get you started...but do a search on here for other ideas!

                                  1. re: modernist
                                    fourunder Jan 28, 2009 08:25 AM

                                    For Polish in Linden.....Big Stash has a lot of fans. They supposed to have excellent meats and a killer Prime Rib...they close around 11:00 PM ...and they have a full bar.

                                    Casa Vasca and Sebra's Marisqueira are two of the better places. Forno's. and Iberia have some love, but it's more quantity than quality. CV is Basque and Sebra's is Portuguese.




                                    1. re: fourunder
                                      tommy Jan 28, 2009 01:13 PM

                                      Big Stash's struck me as a cafeteria. Or a VFW hall. I certainly hope for the sake of NJ that it's not considered one of NJ's "best".

                                      1. re: tommy
                                        fourunder Jan 28, 2009 01:39 PM

                                        Actually, I have never been to Big Stash's, but I have heard from many, who do not know each other, that the food is good. My understanding is it is more like a blast from the past 60''s or 70's type place. I have never heard any mention of it being cafeteria style, but I wouldn't really know.


                                        1. re: fourunder
                                          breich Jan 30, 2009 10:37 AM

                                          Haven't been there in several years, but the way it used to work is that the front room was indeed sort of cafeteria-ish. There was another big room to the side that had table service and a menu.

                                    2. re: modernist
                                      sixelagogo Jan 28, 2009 10:54 AM

                                      Indian Chaat:
                                      Head to Chowpatty in Iselin, off of exit 131 from the Garden State Parkway

                                      While there I can recommend:
                                      Pani puri
                                      Dahi Battata Pouri
                                      Dehli Chaat
                                      Ragda Chaat
                                      Masala Paper Dosa

                                      For Polish, head to the Pole Town of Wallington
                                      Krakus restaurant
                                      208 Main Ave
                                      Wallington, NJ 07057
                                      (no website, but a quick review is here

                                      I can recommend their Perogis, Borsht, and many salads

                                      1. re: sixelagogo
                                        modernist Jan 30, 2009 04:35 AM

                                        thanks for the responses. our eating schedule ended up getting screwed up because of a wild goose chase. i tried to go to a portuguese bbq place called bbq 29 on route 29 but we got there just as it was closing. ended up eating at the hotel, but the point was to see my girl anyway, so food on this outing was secondary.


                                    3. Curlz Jan 25, 2009 01:58 PM

                                      For mid-high end (more mid on price, high on experience), I must add Blu in Montclair www.restaurantblu.com to the list!

                                      Also agree about Fascino, 'tho I'll admit that I haven't been back there since I discovered Blu.

                                      For a true bargain and authentic Greek food, Stamna Taverna in Bloomfield, just a block down from Holsten's (don't bother-eat dessert at Stamna!).

                                      Adega Grill and Casa Vasca are favorites in the Ironbound...

                                      1. r
                                        RPMcMurphy Jan 24, 2009 06:23 AM

                                        I agree with you on David Drake being overated and of course I agree with ya that Catherine Lombardi has the best cocktails in NJ!

                                        for cheap eats, I go to Thai Kitchen in bridgewater/somverville. great food. Or for more american comfort food and an alternative when anyone says "hey lets go to [insert chain here] I go to Brunswick Grove on milltown road....bar and gril.

                                        High end, Nicholas

                                        For other cheap eats, I haven't found anything on South River's main street that I didn't really like. No bad experiences.

                                        3 Replies
                                        1. re: RPMcMurphy
                                          bgut1 Sep 14, 2009 12:04 PM

                                          RP - I have to agree with your choice of Thai Kitchen. I enjoyed an excellent lunch there this afternoon. It was also refreshing to find a restaurant that was packed for lunch with people in line waiting to be seated.

                                          1. re: bgut1
                                            ambrose Sep 14, 2009 06:25 PM

                                            Just over a year ago, mmgpsych, whose gastronomic advice I always respected, came down hard on the Thai Kitchen restaurant near the Somerville Circle.


                                            So, I must ask my standard question about Thai Kitchen, namely which one did you go to? There are at least three, two of which are in Bridgewater. And can you elaborate on what you had for lunch? I am often in Somerville during the lunch hour and if I do Thai it's usually Origin or Splash of Thai. Thanks.

                                            1. re: ambrose
                                              bgut1 Sep 14, 2009 07:56 PM

                                              ambrose - It was the Prince Rodgers location. I had the Tom Kai Gai Soup and the #4 on the specials menu which consisted of shrimp, chicken, long beans and bell peppers in a spicy curry sauce. Never eating there before, I tried the medium heat level which was just hot enough for me. Everything was very fresh and tasty and in fact the Tom Kai was one of the best renditions I recall ever having. Reading mmg's post, I do have to agree with his comment about the portion sizes. In fact one of the diners next to me complained about his lunch portion and proceeded to order an extra side of noodles. Considering that I had the soup to start, it was just the right amount of food for me. BTW, I have also eaten at Origin and enjoyed my meal there as well.

                                        2. t
                                          tigermoth39 Jan 18, 2009 06:02 AM

                                          You should try Fascino and Culinariane in Montclair. A treat for your tastebuds.

                                          Show Hidden Posts