Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > General Midwest Archive >
Jan 2, 2009 06:43 PM

Porter & Frye (MPLS)

Any recommendations for P&F??? This will be our first trip........someone in my last posting urged me to get the tasting menu (which we'll probably do), but I was curious to see what people had to say. Thanks in advance!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Here is a link to my review-- we really enjoyed it. It was before they had started the tasting menu, so that was not an option.

    1. That was me who suggested P&F in your previous post. I don't know that you'll get too many responses here. It doesn't seem that many of us have eaten there yet. And I haven't seen anyone else refer to their tasting menu. The reviewers love it, though. Dara cites it in Minnesota Monthly in her "bests" listings. Scroll down to "Best Big Birthday Bash." Her experience is like mine has been:

      9 Replies
      1. re: FireRev

        I was there before they introduced the tasting menu. I would suggest that the Berkshire pork terrine is not to be missed.

        1. re: FireRev

          I haven't got into writing about my dining experiences before - but I wanted to say that P&F was outstanding!! One of the best meals that we've had in a long time....the food was very impressive and when you take into account the ambiance, service, wife and I compared it to similar experiences like Bouley (NYC), Blue Hill (NYC), La Belle Vie, and Maestro (DC). We went with the 7 course tasting menu for $95....the restaurant itself was a bit slow, (as in only about 5 other tables) so our server explained that "the kitchen was planning on having a bit of fun with us and try a few different items." And I honestly can't say that I was remotely disappointed with anything.....lets see if I can remember everything that we had:
          1. Apple Ravioli (apple within an apple gelee "wrapper")
          2. Duck w/ cabbage puree
          3. Foie Gras Torchon with maple & thyme (much more in depth than I describe)
          3. Tagliatelle w/ Black truffle
          4. Croque Monsieur w/ truffled honey & berry jam
          5. Lobster with Veal tongue
          6. Rabbit
          7. Cod w/ truffle (i believe that they said this was on the menu)
          8. Mint-chocolate Sorbet
          9. 7-layer chocolate cake w/ salted caramel ice cream

          ....and yep, sure enough - i'm forgetting two.....If I can think of them or have a bit more time to update my very lame descriptions, I will. But I wanted to say thanks for the advice on the tasting menu......we had an absolute blast enjoying the food & wine, meeting the crew, and -- just having a great night out. I dont' think that I can recommend Porter & Frye enough!!! Go there ASAP!!!

          1. re: nymoving2004

            I'm so happy that your experience was a good one. You might be interested to know that my wife and I last did their tasting menu no more than 3 weeks before you did. And they served mostly different dishes. The kitchen is constantly creating and experimenting. That's what we love about it...the guys love to do cartwheels back there, and we get the benefits of it!

            Those slow nights are maybe the best, because then the young guns like Josh and Eric have more time to come out with the dish and explain it a bit. We love that interaction and developing relationship with the chefs.

            My only concern is that the economy will take P&F down. So I'm trying to talk it up whenever I can!

            1. re: FireRev

              Reading Dara's 'Best Restaurant' article in Minnesota Monthly opened my eyes to the absurd talent that is at P&F right now. I didn't realize the incredible pedigree of their sous chefs. I can't wait to try out their creations.

              1. re: BigE

                You know what's fun? The guys in the kitchen are having a sort of competition with the tasting menu. At the end of our second tasting menu meal, Josh came out and was interested in what we thought of the dishes. We noticed some faces peering out of the kitchen and asked him. He said that they do want to know which of of their creations we liked most. This was Doug's, this was Eric's, this was Josh's, etc. It's a blast!

                Josh actually posts a lot of photos on Flickr, along with the story behind their creation. Take a look...


                Warning: You will want to immediately make your reservation for dinner!

                1. re: FireRev

                  Wow - you guys have me salivating and ready to go! I'm in town tomorrow night and would like to try this place out. Came to CH to do some research but don't need to look any further, I don't think.

                  I prefer a bar when I'm traveling as I hate to burn a two-top and prefer the atmosphere, usually. So, the big question - do they have a bar at which one solo diner can eat?


                  1. re: pgerding

                    They certainly do, upstairs, but I would still recommend sitting in the dining room-- they have out of the way tables- don't worry about burning a 2-top, and the dining ambience and attention is better.

                    1. re: cheeseguysgirl

                      I agree. The bar is cool. But take a table. I've never seen the room full, so don't worry about burning a table.

                  2. re: FireRev

                    F-me these photos are making me hungry! Nice find...and my wife and I just made a date for two weeks from now for this tasting menu...

          2. The original comment has been removed