HOME > Chowhound > Ontario (inc. Toronto) >

Discussion

Live lobster

  • 17
  • Share

Looking for some live lobster for tonight's Christmas eve dinner? Any good places to buy? I am a little concerned about quality. I work in Scarborough, but live in Markham. What is a reasonable price to pay today?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
Posting Guidelines | FAQs | Feedback
Cancel
  1. I live in Windsor right now, so my options are very few. I just ordered two lobsters for New Year's Eve from my local Zehrs (Loblaws). I was told that lobsters this week are $8.99 per pound, but there will be a special on for Dec. 29, 30, and 31 of $6.99 per pound, which is super cheap. In past years, I've paid anything from $10.99-15.99 per pound, so now's the time to buy. In Toronto, I've bought quality lobsters from Bill's on Gerrard, Avenue Seafood (Eglinton or Avenue/Lawrence location) and Pisces ($$$$$), but alas, none are in the Markham or Scarborough areas. I'm sure someone else will have suggestions for places closer to your neck of the woods. Best of luck! One more thing: I always ask to see the lobsters off of ice/cold packs, to make sure they're alive and kicking. One year, one lobster was very lethargic and the other was dead. My SO picked them up from the store and didn't know to check them for activity. They were disappointing in flavour and texture. I hope never to be faced with that situation again.

    1. If you live in Markham, you could go to Bergon Lobster, at 500 Don Park Road, Unit 4, Markham, Telephone: 905 475 6374. They are open until 4:00 p.m. today and the lobster is $9.95 per pound. Cheers.

      2 Replies
      1. re: farmgirl1836

        Thanks for the recommendations. Bergon is at 50 Don Park Road. It looks interesting! It might turn into my first seafood store in Markham. I have lived here for 6 years and have lamented some good food shopping, especially good seafood.

        1. re: peter2

          Here is a thread with 96 very recent posts on the subject of pricing and location of live lobster. The recommendation of Bergon by farmgirl1836 is a very good one.

          http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/560535

      2. Perhaps someone can help you with more info on this but there is a place in Thornhill just north of the railroad tracks that run across the top of the city. I don't remember the name of it but I bought some lobsters in there once and they were fine.

        I think it's on Glencameron.

        DT

        2 Replies
        1. re: Davwud

          Fisherman Bros.

          1. re: Helen

            they closed their location on glen cameron a few months ago. They said they were planning on moving to Yonge St where the old lcbo was. I still don't think they've re-opened as of yet. I miss this place and hope they come back soon.

            http://fishmancomp.com/

            I've tried calling (no answer) and emailing (bounced back), the website hasn't been updated in ages...

        2. Metro has live lobster on sale now for $7.99 a pound.

          Not sure if they're available at all locations, or if the quality varies from store to store, but we've been buying them occasionally from the Liberty Village location since it first opened as a Dominion, and we've always been happy with them.

          2 Replies
          1. re: gregclow

            I'm getting lobster from Bill's Lobster tomorrow-they're open on Xmas! Open til 7pm tonight I believe.

            1. re: deabot

              Bill's Lobster my choice always. Great quality. Multiple sizes

          2. http://lobstergeorge.com/

            George gets them fresh 2 times per week from Nova Scotia. He supplies most of the better restaurants and grocery stores in the city.

            Get them from him.

            1. I know its late but i would recommend Seafood Depot Inc. They are on Aviva Park Dr, in Woodbridge, near weston rd and hwy 407. The lobster is usually 13-16$ per pound and is very fresh. You can usually find big lobsters too, as we try to get something around 3-4 lbs.

              3 Replies
              1. re: BlueTeam

                if it's $13 to $16 lb, that's expensive. Bill's Lobster is selling it for $7.99 right now.

                1. re: foodyDudey

                  Love Bill's...may drop by and get me some this weekend!!!

                  1. re: foodyDudey

                    bills is now 12.99 a pound at Bill"s see my rant on other thread.. Supply cut off looks like

                2. Hey Hounds.

                  I'd like to do lobsters for V-Day but don't really want to drive back down to the city on Saturday. Especially in the early morning so as not to get shut out.
                  It wouldn't be my first choice but could I buy them around lunch on Friday for dinner Saturday without cooking them?? IOW, keep them alive in my fridge??

                  DT

                  1 Reply
                  1. re: Davwud

                    I have given up on Seafood Depot. We have been going for many years now, but every year it gets worse and worse. Even my mother-in-law who is Italian has given up after our Christmas eve dinner. Everything tasted awful.

                    Definitely never going again.