Primehouse New York or Blue Water Grill
I haven't been to Blue Water Grill in years but I always thought it was very mediocre. So I suppose if it was between those 2 places, I'd opt for Primehouse even though I've never been.
And not that you asked, but I do actually like Dos Caminos -- I think their guacamole is great.
I dunno about Primehouse but Blue Water is bad news. I would go for the steak and hope they don't screw it up and use decent meat.
Not sure how much your gift is for but I would probably choose Fiamma, though I would rather not have to go to any BR Guest venue.
Actually, I would go to Wildwood but you asked for a nice atmosphere.
Hope it goes well for you if you got that as a gift.