HOME > Chowhound > Outer Boroughs >

new pizza in park slope

secondbecky Dec 9, 2008 09:31 AM

I know the pizza topic has been done to death, but I wanted to weigh in on a new pizza joint that opened where pizza by the park used to be - Villa Rustica. we ordered for delivery, and were seriously impressed. Tomato and Basil was our favorite slice until we tried this one. (And of course we've always been fans of la villas grandma's pizza).
Anyone else try it and have comments?

(promise i'm not a spammer - i'm a foodie lawyer who lives in the hood and liked it so much I had to post!)

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. g
    ginsbera RE: secondbecky Dec 9, 2008 01:26 PM

    that's great to hear. I live in Prospect Heights and have not been able to find a good delivery pizza spot, Amorina can be pricey and Antonio's is plain bland. I've tried Tomato and Basil and found it horrible, too much doughy crust, but would be willing to try out Villa Rustica. Can you describe the pizza at all? Was it crispy? Good sauce? Cheese? Did you order a plain?


    1 Reply
    1. re: ginsbera
      secondbecky RE: ginsbera Dec 10, 2008 09:53 AM

      I'm a big crust girl. For example, I love La Villa's crust because its crisp and not too doughy (even their deep dish) and is perfectly seasoned with salt.
      My favorite crust ever is at Eddie's in New Hyde Park - it's like thinner than cardboard. Tastes so good.

      Sorry, got distracted there, Villa Rustica is crisp, medium thickness (It was definitely less doughy than T&B). The seasoning of the crust was probably what made this pizza so outrageous that I had to post - perfect salt AND garlic. So subtle until you realize what it is!

      The cheese and sauce weren't exactly memorable, which is a good thing. Not too much if I recall correctly (ie not overdone on the sauce or cheese which ruins a good slice). We had pepperoni and brocolli (a most delicious combination I swear).

    2. h
      herbm1 RE: secondbecky Dec 9, 2008 02:14 PM

      Where is this place?

      1 Reply
      1. re: herbm1
        parkslopemama RE: herbm1 Dec 10, 2008 09:26 AM

        I have not tried Villa Rustica, but I know where it is: on 3rd Street in Park Slope, just behind Stone Park on Fifth Ave.

      2. g
        gfood RE: secondbecky Dec 10, 2008 09:53 AM

        I believe that it is actually the same owners as pizza by the park, but they closed for a while, put in a brick oven, and upgraded the interior.

        I haven't tried yet, but now I will. Do you think is better than La Villa?

        4 Replies
        1. re: gfood
          ginsbera RE: gfood Dec 11, 2008 08:40 AM

          i hope it's not the same owners as pizza by the park, that place was a dump and had some of the worst health code violations I've ever heard of....

          1. re: gfood
            secondbecky RE: gfood Dec 11, 2008 01:16 PM

            different experience - i cant really say - depends if you want "slice-y" pizza or gourmet-y pizza. we'd never go to la villa just for pizza.

            1. re: gfood
              splenderrela RE: gfood Dec 24, 2008 05:43 AM

              Just to let you know gfood... It is not the previous owners that was formally known as "Pizza by the park". It is an Italian family owned and operated business.

              They indeed update the ambiance of the store, by putting in a brick oven stove and updated the interior and exterior of the store!!!

              You have to try it!!! There Pizza is out of this world!!! And YES!!!! It is alot better then La Villa!!!!

              1. re: gfood
                valpal RE: gfood Dec 28, 2008 02:33 PM

                The pizza does sound great, but just so you know - it isn't a brick oven, It's a regular high temp oven with brick around the sides just for looks! Ah, what a place needs to do to get attention from foodies!

              2. c
                cbking RE: secondbecky Dec 24, 2008 06:01 AM

                We had a large pie, 1/2 mushroom 1/2 pepperoni, delivered to Sackett St. a few days ago and it was pretty decent, especially for $15. Villa Rustica has now gone to the top of our list for delivery pizza (ahead of Tomato and Basil despite T&B's relative proximity).

                1. s
                  secondbecky RE: secondbecky Dec 29, 2008 07:47 AM

                  FYI : we had it again this time with the thin crust - not as good as the regular pie.
                  I love thin crust but it lost alot of the flavor of the regular crust.

                  Show Hidden Posts