Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Wine >
Dec 7, 2008 09:42 PM

2 Buck Chuck . . . @ Trader Joes

Any opinions on this stuff?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. It is okay. I have some in my wine rack (2007). I have tried the Chardonnay. It is better than the prior year. Let's put it this way, it wouldn't be my first choice.

    6 Replies
    1. re: crazyspice

      I believe it's now Three-Buck Chuck ... I just bought some yesterday at $2.99 a bottle ($35.88 a case). Due to Massachusetts liquor laws, it's only sold locally at the TJ's locations in Cambridge, Brookline, and Framingham.

      It'll meet your needs if you are looking for inexpensive wine that looks presentable. I bought about six cases of the merlot and chardonnay for my sister's wedding last summer (they were operating on a shoestring budget) and bought a case yesterday as part of my grandmother's holiday present (she's a big wine drinker, usually opting for wines that are less than $7 a bottle).

      I enjoy dry wine but as I recall the merlot at my sister's wedding was VERY dry. Frankly, I'd be reluctant to buy it for my own consumption. Since TJ's in-store guide lists the cabernet sauvignon as being dryer than the merlot, I shudder to think what it may taste like. As the previous poster suggested, the chardonnay is more enjoyable, although in general it's probably safe to say that you get what you pay for.

      The other options besides the three I've already mentioned are shiraz, sauvignon blanc, white zinfandel, and a new variety called valdiguie -- none of which I've tried.

      I'd say give it a try. Obviously I don't think it's totally horrendous stuff or I wouldn't be foisting it on my grandma. Worst-case scenario if you hate it is that you're only out $2.99!


      1. re: tunamelt

        Charles Shaw wines (at least to me), taste like $7.00 bottles of wine. So the fact that you are paying $3.00 for them makes them a value, if you are in the market for a $7.00 bottle of wine. I rarely am, so they are not for me. Don't be fooled into thinking that the Cab will drink like a $30 Cab. It won't. And the Chardonnay cannot hold its own against $19 bottles. They are comparable to Woodbridge wines. And because the wines are produced from bulk juice sourced from the surplus market, the wines will vary from year to year, as there is no continuity insofar as vineyard sources are concerned. So if you like (or hate) a wine one year, that is no indication that future vintages will perform likewise.

        1. re: FoodieJim

          Uh, no. But I'm glad you enjoy it . ..

        2. re: tunamelt

          To the best of my knowledge, it has ALWAYS been "Three-Buck" Chuck in Mass. It's still TWO-Buck Chuck in California.

          1. re: zin1953

            And if we had it in PA I'll bet it would be Four Buck Chuck. Heh. In Ohio, where we bought some once, it's $3.39. Or it was then, a couple years ago I think since we last did that. It was, at the time, the highest price. Midwest and eastern US prices are due mainly to shipping. Ohio vs Mass price is probably due to taxes.

            TJ's is hardly the only player in this. In WV a while back, I saw a similar product, wine in regular 750ml bottles with plainish labels and corks, for about 3 bucks. The kicker: it was in RIte-Aid. Seriously. Did a quick search, I believe the label is called Five Oaks, a house brand just as Charles Shaw is at TJ's. I'm sure it's produced exactly the same way, with surplus grapes that will vary in quality from batch to batch (let alone vintage to vintage).

            1. re: CrazyOne

              Bronco has LOTS of labels . . .

              Albertoni Vineyards
              Alexander and Fitch
              Almond Creek
              Bad Dog Ranch
              Bears' Lair
              Black Mountain
              CC Vineyards
              Cedar Brook
              Charles Shaw, AKA Two Buck Chuck
              Chateau California
              Coastal Ridge
              Coastal Vines
              Congress Springs
              Crane Lake
              Domaine Laurier
              Domaine Napa
              Dona Sol
              Douglass Hill
              Down Under
              Fat Cat
              Forest Glen
              Forest Hill
              Grand Cru
              Grove Ridge
              Harlow Ridge
              JW Morris
              JFJ Winery
              Napa Creek
              Napa Crossing
              Napa Landing
              Napa Ridge
              Napa River
              Oak Vineyards
              Pacific Oasis
              Quail Creek
              Quail Ridge
              Raymond Hill
              Rock Brook
              Rutherford Vintners
              Salmon Creek
              Santa Barbara Crossing
              Santa Barbara Landing
              Sea Ridge
              Silver Ridge
              The California Winery
              Thousand Oaks
              Three Knights Vineyards

      2.'s pretty bad. If you are going to purchase wine at Trader Joe's I recommend choosing something else. They generally have much better wine on the shelf for $10-15 a bottle.

        2 Replies
        1. re: steve999

          Well for 5x to 7.5x as much, I would hope the $10-$15 wine is much better! If you ask me, Two Buck Chuck is sort of like the Motel 6 of the wine world.

          1. re: monkuboy

            "Two Buck Chuck is sort of like the Motel 6 of the wine world"

            Good analogy. I would also say the comparison of 3$ Chuck to what one would call a decent wine is like comparing generic "cola" to Coke/Pepsi or popov vodka to Grey Goose/Stoli.

        2. Search the Wine Board (where this will probably get moved to anyhow). There are lots of threads about TBC.

          1. Charles Shaw wines are terrible. Agree with others who say it's better to spend a bit more for a better wine. With all the hype, I tried a few different varietals a few years ago and had to pour the contents down the drain... undrinkable. So for me it was a waste of $3 per... but a good learning experience.

            1. Two buck Chuck is 1.99 a bottle in California. I have sure paid more and had less quality. I live in Canada where even the "cheap " stuff is at least $8 0r $9 bucks.

              1 Reply
              1. re: ddawnzer

                Certainly agree that there are many other "undrinkable" wines priced a lot higher than $2. 2BC is what it is... a brilliant marketing phenomenon.