3. Casa Portugal
5. Gran Gusto
I've never been to Craige or Rialto, so while I'm familiar with the accolades for both, I didn't include them.
I haven't been to Craigie since it moved, and only twice before that, so my leaving it off wasn't a negative vote. I haven't been to Gran Gusto, either. But you can definitely take my omission of Rendezvous as a negative vote. And I like Atasca better than Casa Portugal.
The Blue Room
Green St Grille
Hot Off the Press (hey, it's based on food, not atmosphere!)