HOME > Chowhound > General Tristate Archive >
Dec 5, 2008 04:30 PM

On the Way Cafe in Rye NY

A big thank you goes to all the board members who recommended On the Way Cafe in Rye NY on the right only a block before Rye Playland. It's a true foodie's paradise and one you might easily overlook because of its unassuming exterior. We just spent five days in the area over the Thanksgiving Day weekend and ate there four times! Not only is the food very good - well-prepared from high quality ingredients - but Chris, the waiter, was very friendly and went out of his way to make sure we got what we wanted. We had three breakfasts and one lunch there and I was impressed with the following: thicker, great-tasting bacon, Thomas' English muffins (not a cheaper substitute), lively-seasoned yummy hash browns, a wonderful omelet with a plentiful carmelized onions and bacon filling enwrapped by the egg (not how I expected it to come but a delightful surprise), delish sausage links, eggs cooked precisely as we ordered (every time), creative lunch menu, salads with very fresh baby greens, and deliciously seasoned and crispy French Fries. All this at very reasonable prices - $9.95 for a huge, complex salad and $6.95 for a full breakfast of two eggs any way you like 'em, sausage, ham or bacon, hash browns and toast, crusty roll or English muffin. You won't go away hungry! The new owner is a delightful young woman by the name of Ashley O'Brien. She's just celebrating her first year in business. Keep it up, Ashley, you're doing everything right!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Glad you enjoyed it kathy! We think it's great too and haven't been in about two months. And now that you've mentioned it I'm thinking breakfast tomorrow...

    1 Reply
    1. re: laylag

      Very nice indeed. I would have liked to have seen potatoes with the omelettes (how much is a bag of potatoes?), but otherwise the food was good, the service was attentive AND pleasant, and the wall (a temporary construction wall) fun to draw on.

      Oh, and the coffee was very good.