In Photos: A Report from Manresa, or, Kinch's Own Brand of Ingenuity
Full review with photos: http://www.kevineats.com/2008/11/manr...
I had two dinners in the Bay Area. For the first, I chose Coi in San Francisco. For the second, I ventured further south, to a restaurant nestled in the foothills of the Santa Cruz Mountains: Manresa, a showcase for Chef/Proprietor David Kinch's French- and Spanish-influenced contemporary California cuisine. I'd been interested in paying Manresa a visit for at least a couple of years, so would the place live up to my admittedly high expectations?
Here's what we had:
Petit Fours 1: "Red Pepper-Black Olive"
We started with roasted red pepper gelées and black olive madeleines. The gelées were nicely dense and chewy, but the madeleines really stole the show, with their warm, rich centers surrounded by slightly tough exteriors. I could eat them all day.
Amuse Bouche 1: Horchata and Lightly Toasted Parsnip
The horchata was topped with tonka bean, which had a lovely spice and chocolate aroma that worked wonderfully with the horchata's milky sweet spiciness. Very good.
Amuse Bouche 2: Chestnut Croquettes
Our server described these as "crumeskis(?)," a term I'm not familiar with, and told us to eat them in one bite. The croquettes had a warm liquid chestnut and foie gras center, which made a delightful pop in my mouth when masticated. Amazingly, they had a slightly liqueur-like finish.
Amuse Bouche 3: Arpege Farm Egg
The "Arpege" is a reference to restaurant L'Arpège in Paris and its owner Alain Passard, who ostensibly invented the dish. Kinch's version was topped with sherry vinaigrette and maple syrup, and was wonderful. The first thing I noted was a cool, refreshing, slightly sweet creaminess, followed by the warm runniness of the egg yolk, then followed by a sharp saltiness.
1: Foie Gras, Lightly Smoked, Quince Consommé
Very interesting texture on this one. The foie was, in a sense, halfway between a terrine and a seared preparation. The smokiness imparted to the foie during its cooking nicely balanced the sweetness of the quince, which otherwise would've been overwhelming. One of the better versions of foie gras I've had.
2: Roast Pumpkin Velouté "Blue Hubbard," Nasturtium Ice Cream
This reminded me a bit of the squash soup I had at Coi the previous night. Fortunately, it wasn't quite as sweet, and had a lovely temperature contrast thanks to the nasturtium ice cream. Surprisingly, the velouté didn't really draw attention to itself as I was expecting.
3: Into the Vegetable Garden...Their Natural Juices
Kinch is well-known for his pursuit of top notch ingredients, especially vegetables. This has led to a partnership with Cynthia Sandberg's biodynamic Love Apple Farm, where all of the restaurant's vegetables are grown. A corollary to Coi's "Garden, Late Fall" course, this dish is a seasonally-changing staple of Manresa's menu, and more than any other, is Kinch's heart on a plate. I don't know all the shoots, flowers, roots and seeds that were used here, but my favorite item was the potato. It was a fascinating study in contrasting textures and flavors, heightened by the "dirt" of dehydrated chicory root.
4: An Autumn Tidal Pool, Abalone, Sea Urchin, Foie Gras, Shellfish, Mushroom
The foie gras, along with the mushroom, lent an overarching richness to the soup, not unlike the shabu shabu broth at Urasawa. The other ingredients, specifically the uni and the abalone, were mild on their own, but together, they formed a cohesive dish that really captured the very essence of the sea. Inhaling the various aromas here was like taking a deep breath next to the ocean.
5: Black Cod in an Abalone Bouillon, Seaweed Persillade
I'm not a huge fan of cod, but quite enjoyed this course. It had a fantastic lingering saltiness that complemented the rich unctuousness of the fish. I still wasn't in love with the soft, spongy consistency of the cod, but the rest of the dish easily made up for it, especially the beans, which formed a great texture contrast.
6: Roasted Squab, Garden Carrots with Farro, Meyer Lemon Preserve
I wasn't enthralled with the texture of the breast piece, which was a bit tougher and rarer than I would've liked. I much preferred the leg portion, which was much richer, oilier, and more flavorful. The carrot was useful in cutting the heftiness of the bird, while the farro added a sweet "stuffing"-like taste to the dish.
7: Lamb Rack, Slowly Roasted, Cardoons with Bread Crusts, Tender Greens
This was a wonderful preparation of lamb. The meat itself was surprisingly light, and thus benefitted from the gravity provided by the very apparent layers of fat. I much enjoyed the addition of beech (shimeji) mushrooms, and the amalgam of cardoons and bread crusts reminded me, amazingly, of corned beef hash!
8: Meyer Lemon and Quince Vacherin
There was a lot going on here. Underneath everything was a layer of gelée and a hard cookie-like base, which, together with the meringues formed a delectable contrast with the quince and lemon sorbets. As mentioned by my dining companion, the combination of the dessert's pastry base and gelée resulted in a taste not unlike Fruit Loops! The use of candied kumquats was reminiscent of the Hawaiian Bread Pudding I had recently at Ford's Filling Station, and added nicely to the dish's key sweet/sour interplay.
9: Spice Cake with Ginger-Port Pears with Coconut Caramel
A heavier dessert than the preceding one, the cinnamon spice to the fruit was key; otherwise it would've been too one-dimensional. Meanwhile, the lime sorbet added a much needed bracing tartness to cut the sweetness of the dessert, and the chocolate cake had a bit of mintiness to it as well.
10: Chocolate Pastille with Ice Milk, Prickly Pear and Coconut Granité
The "pastilles" were actually delightful lumps of chocolate crème, with a gentle sweetness that was deftly set off by the ardent crimson sea of tart prickly pear bouillon. The coldness of the granité and ice milk further bolstered the dish. My favorite of the three desserts.
Petit Fours 2: "Strawberry-Chocolate"
The meal began with petit fours, and with petit fours it should end: here, we had strawberry gelées and chocolate madeleines. Unfortunately, they weren't as strong as the starters, with the strawberry completely dominating the flavor of the chocolate.
Going in, I had heard mixed reviews about Manresa, and I was concerned about the restaurant not being "creative" enough. I'm happy to report that my fears were unfounded, and that Manresa actually exceeded my expectations. Kinch manages to innovate in his own way, based on an unwavering respect for ingredients, unflinching technique, and just a dash of fancy: proof that progression doesn't have to be flashy.
Full review with photos: http://www.kevineats.com/2008/11/manr...
re: Paul H
No, I realize that Ubuntu is way more casual. However, reading thru the blog of the OP, there are also reviews of Ad Hoc, Taylor's Refresher, The Red Grape, Slanted Door and Vik's in Berkeley.
For the upper end restaurants, the OP is interested in restaurants of former alum of French Laundry. It might be interesting to dine at a place with a Manressa alum and to compare the veg preparations
We were there last week where it kicked off our week in wine country tour, and had pretty much the same menu. I probably could have eaten about a dozen of those croquettes. Our experience was pretty much the same- we did do both a regular and premium wine pairing. My memory is kind of hazy since my wife and I were functioning on about an hour of sleep each, so I actually remember the amuses more than anything else, also that they poured us a second glass of champagne each in order to get through all of them- I seem to recall a uni topped kummamoto oyster as well. Overall, it was a very good meal, though I thought the desserts were the weakest part- the Meyer lemon was too overwhelming and the spice cake was just blah. I appreciated the freshness of his vegetables. Service was friendly and efficient, and the room was comfortable. They poured about 30 caramels into my wife's purse when we left.
I too had been wanting to make a trip up for a while, and although it more or less met my expectations, I was not blown away, especially at those price points ($700+ after tax and tip). We were glad we went, though.
re: kevin h
Cyrus, Terra, Redd, Bouchon.
Terra has some nice personal memories from me and the food is still very good and satisfying. Bouchon was fine, about what I expected (consdiered ad hoc, but the menu when we were there did not intrigue me- beef stew, I think?)
Cyrus was a pretty amazing dinner, the food was well executed- we did the tasting menu and the wine parings were well matched, but there was something about it- almost like if a bunch of your good friends worked there and put on a good show, but you could tell that they weren't exactly buying into the formality of it all- I mean, I wasn't put off by it or anything, but it almost had a slight silliness about it. I would still definitely go back. I like the ability to also choose your courses (kind of like at Manresa),
Redd was the biggest surprise, as the food was great and I thought a solid value at 125/ea for the tasting menu plus wine. The place had a nice vibe to it, though the room itself is quite loud and the service a litle bit stiff/cold. Definitely on my list of return places in Napa.
We also went to Willi's Raw / Seafood Bar in Healdsburg the night after Cyrus to decompress, and it was fine, but nothing to write home about. Small raw bar, small plates, somewhat overseasoned / sweetened. Disinterested hostess flirting with a few locals and a very enthusiastic server.
Agree about Bouchon. It's good bistro-type food, and I believe they're actually opening one in LA next year.
Interesting what you said about Cyrus. Indeed, I did detect a bit of silliness in Maitre d' Nick Peyton on my visit. Nothing off-putting though.
Redd is one that I wanted to try last time I was up there. I'm glad to hear it was great, as it'll be on my list next time I swing by Yountville.
Nice report. I liked Manresa quite a bit. I agree about technique and ingredients, really liked the left field aspect.
Re: same/similar menu, some items do seem the same (olive amuse, croquettes, egg, tidal pool) when I went but the majority from my time is different. I guess that's part of the price of success and gives the staff a break.
A lot of places do some things over and over because people want them. The French Laundry does the salmon amuse and coffee and donuts all the time.