HOME > Chowhound > Outer Boroughs >
What are you cooking today? Tell us about it

Peter Luger Question [moved from Manhattan board]

tinabull Nov 25, 2008 10:11 PM

3 of us are planning lunch or dinner at PL. Portion sizes in the US are much much bigger than here in the UK and I'm wondering if steak for 3 will be too much food for us, especially as we also want to try the bacon and one or two sides.

At PL is it acceptable for a party of 3 to order steak for 2 plus extras? Will we be asked to pay a supplement for the third person?

  1. f
    fourunder Nov 26, 2008 05:34 AM

    My experiences at Peter Luger have always been in large groups of 6-8 patrons......we have always ordered extras, e.g., the bacon, shrimp cocktail and sides....with Porterhouse less than the number of people at the table and I cannot recall ever being charged a service/sharing plate charge.

    If your concern is crucial for your peace of mind, contact the restaurant directly with your query and I am sure they will provide you with the appropriate answer. I have never really been a fan of their sides...but I do highly recommend their bacon. Check their site for the menu before you pose your query to them....FWIW, you can never over order their steak. If you go for lunch, consider ordering the burger.....one of the best you will ever have.



    1. NYJewboy Nov 27, 2008 10:24 AM

      Dude, here in the US overeating is a sport. Get 3 steaks minimum, and onions/tomato, and German fried potatoes. We are barbarians over here, but you already knew that. Luger's is the superbowl. You will not be sorry. Don't forget the beer.

      1 Reply
      1. re: NYJewboy
        Sra. Swanky Nov 28, 2008 09:47 AM

        Well said, Sir - very well said! :o)

      2. s
        sushiman Nov 27, 2008 07:16 PM

        I was just there. 4 of us had 3 steaks for 2.

        5 Replies
        1. re: sushiman
          tinabull Nov 28, 2008 01:57 PM

          Do you mean between 4 of you, you ate 6 portions of steak? Wow!

          1. re: tinabull
            fourunder Nov 29, 2008 06:20 AM

            FWIW, you can never over order their steak

            Apparently, a view shared by many others.

            1. re: fourunder
              tinabull Dec 1, 2008 11:12 AM

              Unless you eat so much that you feel quite ill afterwards - for me that really spoils the best of meals.

              I would prefer to be just nicely full than overstuffed, otherwise the lasting memory is of indigestion tablets!!

            2. re: tinabull
              sushiman Dec 20, 2008 04:45 PM

              Finished the first two and then ordered a thrid.

              1. re: sushiman
                Scagnetti Dec 22, 2008 07:34 AM

                That's what I'm talking about!

          2. NYJewboy Dec 22, 2008 01:29 PM

            Even though I like to suggest to others that they get gargantuan portions, last night 3 of us had a simple steak for 3. It was one of the best I have ever had there.

            1. r
              rothsteg Dec 23, 2008 08:04 AM

              My family and I have been going to Luger's for decades and range from quite big eaters by US standards to, shall we say, more disciplined types. Even without considering UK portions, we've always ordered "steak for..." fewer than the number of people at the table. The waiters never blink an eye and, on occasion, have told us that we're overdoing the sides--something that would never happen at a place like the Palm, where they unmercifully push their sides. Definitely down order and have no concerns about it. Most importantly, enjoy yourself at Luger's.

              1. BrookBoy Dec 26, 2008 12:10 PM

                My wife and I are long-time PL patrons, and it has been our experience that you can order what you want without any negative feedback. The PL steak for two certainly can be enough for three, especially with starters and sides, and the common wisdom is that their steak for two is the superior cut (ie, better than the steak for three, the steak for four,etc.)

                If you like leftover steak you could consider ordering two orders of the steak for two (yep, that would be for four in total);. You will certainly have a bunch left over, but in my experience leftover PL steak is pretty damned good the next day as well, reheated or not.

                Or order the steak for two and if you decide you want more, tell your waiter.

                Remember, though, that other than their own credit cards, PL requires cash. It is something to keep in mind if you begin to run the bill up.

                All the best on your trip, and I hope you all end up loving PL as much as my wife and I do.

                1 Reply
                1. re: BrookBoy
                  tinabull Dec 28, 2008 12:27 PM

                  Thank you!

                  We have reservations for Sunday night which is our last night in NYC before heading off to Florida for some sunshine. I'll certainly report back on our PL experience!

                Show Hidden Posts