Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Nov 23, 2008 07:26 AM

Mangosteen Quality Control

Last week i bought a bag of mangosteens on Canal St...price was okay: 5 or 6 bucks for a reasonably large bag...two questions:

-- when i've eaten mangosteen in Thailand, the inner segments were usually clean, puffy white and there is a clear contrast w/ the deep purple some of these Chinatown mangosteens, the shell bled into the white fruit, coloring them pinkish or this common? (my first reaction was to wonder if the shells had been dyed in some way)...

-- the first two i ate were ok, but i tried them again after a couple days (they'd been in a very cold refrigerator) and they were wrectched: awful bitter taste...i threw out the whole bag...

Any thoughts on any of this?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. This is typical of mangosteens that have been frozen and thawed. Usually if you eat them shortly after defrosting, the skin hasn't had time to leach into the fruit, but if they sit around for a while this is what you get. I bought some 'fresh' mangosteens this summer in chinatown that were decent, but i think most of the mangosteens being sold are frozen, or previously frozen.

    3 Replies
    1. re: bothrops_asper

      thanks for the thoughts: this was first time i'd had them in NY...but i must say that the experience doesn't make me want to try them again in NY....i think i'll reserve my mangosteen eating for SE Asia unless hounds report better experiences here

      1. re: Simon

        Five or six bucks a bag is definitely pre-frozen mangosteens. Occasionally, you'll find fresh ones at a much higher price. That same size bag (perhaps a bit smaller) will be in the teens if it's fresh. I've purchased fresh ones at the fruit stand next to Pho Tu Do and in Flushing. It's not as good as eating them in the country of origin, but a ton better than those nasty bitter pre-frozen ones.

        1. re: Simon

          "i think i'll reserve my mangosteen eating for SE Asia"

          Good idea. Some things just don't travel well. Plus, paying huge sums of money for poor-quality imported fruit really sucks.