Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > San Francisco Bay Area >
Nov 13, 2008 01:59 PM

Who makes the best French onion soup?

Came across this blog about ... and only about ... French onion soup.

It covers the entire country. In the top ten is MacArthur Park in Palo Alto. His rating is 8.5 on a scale of 10. Artisanal, New York holds the number one spot.

Now I have a FOS craving. Given the richness and calories, I want the best local version. Absolutely no Bay Area soup I've tried stays in my memory ... so much so I can't even say where I tried it.

Some other local ratings ... only a few, there's more ... but just to give a feeling for this guy's taste.

Papillon Restaurant - Fremont, CA Rating 8 out of 10 ... this has me interested.

Twist Bistro - Campbell, CA Rating 7.5 out of 10 ... one of the best broths, points off for skimpy cheese

Absinthe - San Francisco, CA Rating 7 out of 10.

Cafe Bastille - San Francisco, CA Rating 7 out of 10.

Perry’s - San Francisco rated locally at the bottom ... 4.5 "The cheese was cheap swiss, and the soup tasted like a glass of water with an entire salt-shaker dumped in"

Asked on the General Board what qualities make for a great FOS.

So ... what is your favorite?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Sadly, because I wanted to like the place for its prices and its proximity, it is not at the Rendez-Vous on Solano Ave. in Albany. Too much crouton, too little soup. Not one of your better finds.

    1. Left Bank in Larkspur used to have a very good version but it has been years since I tried it. Generally, quality at the Left Banks seems to have fallen but maybe Scott Howard propped it up before he left. An old LB chef does a good version at his restaurant in Berkeley, Liaison.

      2 Replies
      1. re: tomatoaday

        Perhaps a bit too salty the last time I had it. I also find restaurant onion soup, onion deficient. My last home made batch had 6 pounds of to 2 quarts of broth.

        1. re: wolfe

          Yeah, that is all too true. Often there will be a nice cheesy top, and decent broth, but the onions are too few as I mentioned on the general board query.

      2. Fleur de Cocoa in Los Gatos for delicious, authentic French onion soup.

        An extra bonus -- extraordinary pastries and chocolates.

        Fleur De Cocoa
        39 N Santa Cruz Ave, Los Gatos, CA 95030

        1. Cafe de La Presse makes an excellent Soupe à l’Oignon

          Cafe De La Presse
          352 Grant Ave, San Francisco, CA 94108

          1. NOT the classic beef based FOS, but Wood Tavern has been known to make an amazing pork based onion soup. Given that I am a pork partisan, that's a plus for me.

            1 Reply
            1. re: lexdevil

              Le Croissant in San Rafael makes great homemade soups, including FOS.

              FOS with a grilled MAC on the side is a great lunch.