HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Good burgers?

bklyneliza Oct 29, 2008 04:29 PM

I posted this in "the best" area but got no responses and I can't imagine people don't have some feelings about this!

I'm trying to find the best burger (or some ideas!) in the city. Lots of people say Corner Bistro but then the NYMag says it's actually overrated. Any ideas would be really welcomed.


  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. j
    jthefoodie RE: bklyneliza Oct 29, 2008 06:39 PM

    This is actually a very popular/controversial topic around these parts...have you tried running a search on "burger" on this board?

    This should get you started (177 replies as I write this!) http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/234881

    Happy burger eating

    1. i
      italianagambino RE: bklyneliza Oct 30, 2008 07:44 AM

      I like a shake shack burger!

      2 Replies
      1. re: italianagambino
        drbelfer RE: italianagambino Oct 30, 2008 08:07 AM

        Have to agree - enjoy shake shake to most, but also enjoy burgers from Five Guys

        1. re: italianagambino
          bklyneliza RE: italianagambino Nov 2, 2008 01:52 PM


        2. b
          bnemes3343 RE: bklyneliza Oct 30, 2008 08:11 AM

          The Burger Joint at Le Meridian (Five Guys is great, but I don't think they're in NY)

          5 Replies
          1. re: bnemes3343
            PAULSCOHEN RE: bnemes3343 Oct 30, 2008 07:09 PM

            five guys in on 55th between 5th&6th. but my pref would be burger joint. itwould be like comparing chopped liver to fois gras

            1. re: bnemes3343
              steakrules85 RE: bnemes3343 Oct 31, 2008 05:16 AM

              I don't know what the fuss is with burger joint. Way overpriced and overrated.

              1. re: steakrules85
                Stuartmc910 RE: steakrules85 Nov 6, 2008 08:49 AM

                I agree. The burgerI and the fries were just so-so. Wait in line for that? Never again.

              2. re: bnemes3343
                drbelfer RE: bnemes3343 Oct 31, 2008 12:00 PM

                The Burger joint is good but 5 guys and the shake shack are better

                1. re: bnemes3343
                  drmoze RE: bnemes3343 Nov 5, 2008 08:25 PM

                  Five Guys has 5-6 locations in NYC, incl. Queens and Brooklyn. Although I still prefer the nearby Shake Shack.

                2. j
                  jmd350 RE: bklyneliza Nov 5, 2008 08:52 AM

                  I am almost afraid to mention it...Blue 9 Burger. Best burger day and night. Mango Chili sauce rocks!

                  1 Reply
                  1. re: jmd350
                    drmoze RE: jmd350 Nov 8, 2008 02:30 PM

                    I tried the Blue 9 not long ago (medieval), and was quite disappointed. I thought the burger was closer to McDonalds(!) than to the Shack/5Guys/BJoint. Expected much better after reading so many rave reviews for it, but it was a fairly bland, not-very-juicy burger.

                  2. c
                    ceasar11 RE: bklyneliza Nov 5, 2008 12:26 PM

                    just tried five napkin burger and thought it was pretty good.

                    1. b
                      BW212 RE: bklyneliza Nov 5, 2008 05:33 PM

                      I really like BLT Burger. The mix of meats they grind together is delicious.

                      1. n
                        NYCFoodGuy.com RE: bklyneliza Nov 5, 2008 08:45 PM

                        Here's my top Burgers: Brooklyn Diner ($16), well worth the price... big burger, vermont cheddar, smokehouse bacon, frizzled onions all on buttered and grilled brioche bun...fries are lackluster but this is one delicious grease bomb (photo attached)

                        Burger Joint ($6.50) also well worth the experience and the price. Its a simply prepared burger thats simply delicious. Shoulder steak singed over an open flame, two kinds of cheddar and the works (L/T/red onion/mayo/mustard/ketchup/pickles). Fries, similar to mcdonalds, but better, come in a brown paper bag. Make sure you call ahead and cut the line when you get there.

                        Here's some other great burgers: Houston's, Harriets Kitchen UWS, Virgil's Real BBQ, Peter Luger's (for lunch), Veselka (good diner burger)

                        You can see photos of all these delicious burgers on my review site, accessed through my username...

                        3 Replies
                        1. re: NYCFoodGuy.com
                          PAULSCOHEN RE: NYCFoodGuy.com Nov 5, 2008 10:00 PM

                          nycfoodguy do you mean you can call ahead to place you order? bjnt doesn"t take reservations , do they?

                          1. re: PAULSCOHEN
                            a_and_w RE: PAULSCOHEN Nov 6, 2008 07:23 AM

                            He means call ahead with your order. Not sure about the cutting in line, however. I always thought you have to wait like everyone else even for phone orders, though there's a window on the side where you can pick up your food if you've already paid.

                            PS: Second the Houston's and Brooklyn Diner suggestions.

                            1. re: a_and_w
                              ginsbera RE: a_and_w Nov 9, 2008 01:04 PM

                              I would have to say my top burgers are:

                              - Shake Shack - still holds the crown for me
                              - Market Table - my "fancy" burger favorite
                              - Paul's - great cheap burger, though it is steamed more than griddled and lacks char
                              - Burger Joint - used to be a contender for tops, but is on the decline these days
                              - Daddy-O - fantastic bacon cheeseburger and under appreciated
                              - Soda - bar in Brooklyn serving a big beefy burger sure to fill you up
                              - Five Guys - a good fast food burger, but overrated in my opinion
                              - P.J. Clarkes - a bit pricey for what you get, but consistent and tasty
                              - Island Burgers and Shakes - Good burgers, but really just impressive for the toppings

                              IMO, Corner Bistro is overrated. If you need to season your own burger a restaurant then that's a problem.


                        2. d
                          dlevine1781 RE: bklyneliza Nov 6, 2008 07:36 AM

                          I'm actually not a fan of 5 guys - they give you a lot for the money, but only cook it one way - also, i'm not a fan of the fry's. If you are looking for a similar type burger place, i would recommend goodburger - they have a bunch of locations in the city - the burgers are Awesome!! and their fry's are great!! and you can pick how well you want the meat cooked.

                          1. m
                            mrsharky RE: bklyneliza Nov 6, 2008 08:00 AM

                            Not sure if you're still looking for this, and I know it's not Manhattan, but I had one of the best dang burgers I've ever had at a little bar in Brooklyn - The Dram Shop.


                            1. f
                              foodwhisperer RE: bklyneliza Nov 8, 2008 09:51 AM

                              There are so many posts on best burgers on Chowhound. In any case, seems different folks like different type burgers. New Yorkers surely have different taste on burgers than out of towners. My choices for burgers in restaurants are Walker's, Big Nicks, Soupburg. Ive had most of the others and these are most to my likeing. Bouley upstairs has a good burger but its too bloody for me. Cercle Rouge has a good salmon burger.

                              1. n
                                notmikey RE: bklyneliza Nov 8, 2008 10:40 AM

                                I think the burger at the Spotted Pig is awesome!! The brioche bun is amazing, the meat is great, and the blue cheese ties the whole thing together. i don't get why so many i've spoken to hate on the burger at the Spotted Pig.. Corner bistro is a basic burger, nothing special, don't believe the hype.

                                1 Reply
                                1. re: notmikey
                                  foodwhisperer RE: notmikey Nov 8, 2008 09:24 PM

                                  I pass teh spotted pig all the time.. Never tried it , I think i'll try their burgers , sounds good

                                2. r
                                  racer x RE: bklyneliza Nov 9, 2008 02:46 PM


                                  Soup Burg.

                                  Show Hidden Posts