Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >
Oct 24, 2008 02:30 AM

Lobster Prices

I've been reading about Lobster prices hitting record lows, as the Lobstermen are getting only $2.25 LB for their catch. Does any one know what the retail prices are in Boston and vicinity?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I believe $2.25 is the price for new shell being paid in Maine.Locally the boats are being paid $3.25 to $3.50.Hard shelled(lobsters able to be shipped overseas and be out of the water for 30+hours)are being bought for $7.00+.There are retail prices for new shells as low as $3.99.Call around.

    2 Replies
    1. re: monger

      Try Market Basket, they seem to have the cheapest prices so far.

      About a week ago, I got an in-store special of $3.99 per pound.

      1. re: mcel215

        I'm pretty sure the Market Basket lobsters are new shell. I picked a few up about 2 months ago for $4.99 / lb. We steamed 2 and ate them for dinner and made the third into a lobster roll. Good stuff.

        Stop and Shop was advertising the 1lb-1.25lb lobsters for $5.99 this past week. It didn't say if they were new shell or hard shell.

        Super 88 had lobsters in their tank for $4.98 / lb this week. Sign didn't specify hard shell or new.

    2. Market Basket in Woburn was selling new shell lobsters for $3.99 a pound on Tuesday. The lobsters were small around 1 pound-1.25 pounds.

      1 Reply
      1. re: buffet king

        I bought five 1-11/4lb lobsters from MB, and even though they were on the small side, it cost me under $23.00!

        I steamed two Saturday night and three Sunday night. I had enough lobster meat leftover for 2 rolls.

        Now, that was quite a bargain for me..

        I do feel bad for those lobsterman though, it's a really tough business.

      2. I've seen them for as little as $2.99 pp, Market Basket is $3.99 pp, apparently there's a gult of those bugs in the market due to the economy, people aren't going out to eat them.

        1 Reply
        1. re: treb

          and lobstermen are not going out to get them. since about the first of September i've noticed an almost total absence of lobster traps in the areas that i usually dive. but there's no shortage of lobsters. check out the two big boys i pulled up on Columbus day on my Flickr page.

        2. Couple of notes. At Market Basket the deli clerks vary in ability, but a good clerk can get you hard shells if you ask. Usually hard-shells are $1 more per-lb and the larger stores keep separate tanks for the two. If you just go for the $3.99/lb, you might get a hard-shell or two.

          The Revere Mt Vernon (at the wharf) was doing their two-lobster special for $11.99 last weekend. Only certain hours and not certain Somerville, so if going specifically for this you need to call. (They always have a two-lobster special, but the price is less certain days and at off-peak hours.)

          11 Replies
          1. re: itaunas

            Yes, the Somerville Mt Vernon has this deal too. it's prominently advertised in the windows and on the board outside, for Saturday, Sunday, and Monday dinners. Does anyone know if you can order them for take-out? I know it's super-easy to steam them at home, but if I can just pick them up around the corner, that's even easier!

            Also -- think I've read the soft-shell lobsters are not as tender and take a minute or two less to cook, for anyone making them.

            1. re: chucktownlady

              We've moved a discussion of the differences between hard and soft shelled lobsters to the General Topics board, at

              1. re: chucktownlady

                I think they have restrictions that its for "in" dining service only, to encourage you spend money on drinks and other items. They also surcharge for people sharing, but for an upcharge it appears they will now do them baked stuffed now (in the past it was steamed only). Many Demoula's will steam free while you shop, although not 100% certain about the Somerville store (Chelsea certainly will).

                1. re: itaunas

                  Ok, now I want lobster! Yes, Marketbasket has them for 3.99 per pound and it's a toss up if you'll get hard or soft shell and it appears that they are relatively small (1 - 1.25).

                  Just called James Hook and they want 10.99 per pound for lobsters above 2 pounds.

                  Any thoughts on where to get "bigger" (which I know is not necessarily better) lobsters?

                  Thank you.

                  1. re: CambridgeFoodie

                    I just got back from Woburn MB and bought six lobsters.

                    They vary in size, but there are a couple that are 1&1/2 lbs, still for 3.99 per pound. I asked the gal for largest she could grab. Now mind you, there was a line, so they aren't going to be that discriminate! It's a busy place. And there are 3 hard shells and 3 soft shells, but I don't care.

                    I invited 2 friends for dinner, steamed lobsters, big salad, baked yukon potatoes and wine. I spent 30.00 on the 6 lobsters.

                    BTW, MB ran out last night, so call ahead if you go late in the afternoon. The guy in front of me, bought 24 lobsters, he said he has a restaurant and was making Lobster Fra Diabalo (sp?) out of them for his special tonight. There is no limit on how many you can purchase.

                    1. re: CambridgeFoodie

                      Supermarkets almost always offer chicken lobsters, although sometimes you luck out with larger ones. Selects I think you can only find with a fishmonger or a lobster pound, so you would have to call around for better prices. Some will sell lobster just under 2lbs for the price of halves. There is a fish market right past the rotary where 16/1A/60 intersect in Revere on the rt 60 part that usually has pretty low prices but I haven't been or seen it open this year. There are a few wholesalers and pounds in Lynn, but don't know about selling to the public (in the past definitely some did). However, if you are going to drive, you might as well go direct to Salisbury or Hampton which are pretty close (just as easy as Gloucester and better prices).

                      1. re: itaunas

                        The Star Market at Packards Corner has both chicken and select. In fact, last time we bought lobster there a few weeks ago, the seafood manager gave us selects at the per-price pound of chicken, which was quite a savings, plus after he had already totaled up our order and was taking them downstairs to steam, he threw in a free extra lobster!

                      2. re: CambridgeFoodie

                        The tanks at the Super 88 in Brighton have been restocked and are full of very lively lobsters of all sizes, many quite large. The posted price is $4.88 per pound and they looked like hard shells.

                        1. re: tmab

                          Thank you so much.

                          One last question...does Super 88 steam their lobsters?

                          1. re: CambridgeFoodie

                            Can't say no for sure, but I'd be surprised if they do and Ive never seen anyone getting a lobster steamed there. It is really pretty easy to steam lobsters (just take the rubber bands off) as long as you have a pot with a cover that's big enough.

                            1. re: CambridgeFoodie

                              Super 88 do not steam their lobster. I am also curious as to why no oriental market around here prepare the fish and then deepfry the fish for you to take home. In California all the markets do it.

                  2. Somerville Market Basket has them for $3.99/lb as of Sunday afternoon. I was able to get two that were 1.25 lbs each. Around the corner, Reliable Market had a tank with lobsters that didn't look much bigger selling for $12.99/lb. I was considering starting a lobster-flipping boom in Somerville. I can see the reality series now: Flip that Lobster!

                    1 Reply
                    1. re: Parsnipity

                      Thanks for your help.

                      In the end, I went to Jumbo Seafood tonight for their twin lobster (cantonese style) for $24.95 deal...awesome dish and I love that restaurant.

                      Last night they apparently had a 3 lobster for $29.99 deal but alas, it was not offered tonight.