Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Oct 19, 2008 12:03 PM

How to bake pumpkin pie without a crust

I'm a crust guy over a filling guy when it comes to pie, and love a good flaky, buttery, salty crust. My mom makes a good one and I'm working on getting to down, but I'd also like to know how I can bake pumpkin pie filling (preferably in a round dish with straight sides) without a crust. Thanks for any suggestions.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. When I was a kid, my mom would do this for me. She'd just take some of the custard and put it in a separate small oven safe dish. Then she'd bake it alongside the actual pie at the same temperature. We'd know when it was done when you could poke the center with a knife and it would come out clean.

    1. A pumpkin pie without a crust is simply a pumpkin custard.
      The custard doesn't care whether it's baked in a ramekin or a pie dish.,1-0...

      1. Exactly, its just a pumpkin custard. You might want to make sure the pumpkin pie filling recipe has enough egg yolk and creme in it so that it will not come out shapeless from its baking container.

        Also, definitely make sure to butter the baking dish very well.

        1. Yup, as previously replies state, pumpkin custard can easily stand on its own! I usually bake it in a water bath like any other custard, to let it set gently and stay tender (whereas a pie needs a higher temp to get the crust baked and toasty).

          1. You could subsitute pumpkin bread/muffins for bread in any bread pudding recipe, just cutting back on the sugar by half. This would give the custard more substance.

            1 Reply
            1. re: greygarious

              I'm with 'another adam.' Using a water bath and gently cooking the custard will make it stay moist. I have made a souffle of sorts by separating the eggs, beating the whites and folding them into the rest of the mixture (which includes the egg yolks) then cooking it as one would any other custard in a water bath. It was really good. I used the pumpkin pie recipe from the back of the libbys can altering it as described.