HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Discussion

Turkish food - Beyoglu, Ali Baba or Sip Sak?

Want to try some Turkish food while in town this weekend. Any preferences among these three? Others you would recommend? Prefer UES or Midtown. Thanks!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. Never been to those but do love Turkish Kitchen on 3rd Ave (28th St)

    1. Never been to the other 2, but I like Ali Baba.

      1 Reply
      1. re: Lucia

        Second Ali Baba for the Midtown area. Beyoglu is perfect if you want to stay UES.

        www.thelunchbelle.com

      2. Turkish kitchen!

        Been to Turkish Kitchen and Sip Sak and have to say that the decor and ambience between them are night and day different.

        Sip sak means slowish service and sitting on unfinished plywood (yes, i have had splinters in my pants!!!). price is $$

        Turkish kitchen is gorgeous and while is not 100% authentic, it is really good food (so says my turkish friends). Price is $$$

        1 Reply
        1. re: eatereater123

          Haven't been to Sip Sak or Beyoglu, but would definitely recommend Ali Baba. Turkish Kitchen is also good, but a little more expensive and not as authentic. Also, Dervish on 46th between 6th and 7th Ave is quite good.

        2. On the UES, I would choose Uskudar. Delicious food served by a friendly staff in a small, cozy space with charming decor.

          http://www.menupages.com/restaurantde...

          1. Beyoglu was my fave restaurant on the UES when I lived in the hood! Sip Sak is also terrific, but totally different vibe (see eatereater123). Turkish Kitchen is still on my list of "must get to one of these days".

            1. Of the three, I've only been to Beyoglu, and I loved it. The only caveat is you need to stick with the mezes, which make up the overwhelming majority of the menu. Beyoglu always gets good reviews on here, but I've seen a few people mention that the entrees are just mediocre. If the lamb manti is available, definitely get it.

              2 Replies
              1. re: douglas525

                I happen to LOVE their shrimp casserole (on the entree menu).

                When we go, we usually order 3-4 mezes and 1 entree to split. They have such delicious pita! The cacik and patlican domates soslu are to die for! The ezme and that spicy sausage are also good meze bets.

                1. re: piegirl74

                  I second the cacik recommendation. I've also enjoyed the phyllo with feta, the hummus and the donner kebab, which is excellent.

              2. I have only been to Beyoglu. Was there for dinner this past weekend and loved the mezes. I encouraged my friends to order only mezes but was out voted so out of the 2 entrees and 3 mezes, the mezes were the best and that is definitely the way to go. Also the chocolate cube was really good, not one of their typical Turkish desserts, but I loved it. Also the bread is hot and delicious.

                Oh I also like Uskudar, but it is definitely a higher price point.