Any recommendations other than Lee and Ricks for Oysters on the half shell?
Lombardi's Seafood Market has great apalachicola oysters. I know it is not a restaurant, but if you are willing to do the dirty work your self they are great and cheap!
1152 Harmon Ave
Winter Park, FL 32789-4994
Phone: (407) 628-3474
I agree with the Thirsty Gator. Its a hole in the wall, but I guess that's part of the charm. Great Rock Shrimp as well.
The Ale House has decent oysters as well that are resonably priced.