Outer Banks - The Fudgery (Corolla, NC)
The name should have been a clue, but my addiction to sugar over-ruled my good judgement. In short, The Fudgery has bad fudge at high prices, and it is a total rip-off.
I am saving my fudge, though, because if someone tries to mug me while I'm on vacation here, I can use the bag-o-fudge as a bludgeon to beat my would-be attacker unconscious.
If you have to have fudge, go to Roanoke Island and visit The Christmas Shop (it is en route to the aquarium in Manteo). They have good fudge at good prices, in addition to a huge store filled with cool art, gifts, and Christmas stuff.