HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Discussion

Raw Bar - Pearl's, Mary's, Aquagrill, or...?

  • PegS Sep 3, 2008 10:18 AM
  • 12
  • Share

SF Chowhound looking for a decent seafood restaurant with a main emphasis on raw oysters and raw littlenecks, but would also welcome a place that has more unusual selections as well (langoustines, whole sea urchin, cockles etc.). We're NOT looking for a white tablecloth place, unless the selection of exotic shellfish warrants the splurge. Right now I'm looking at Pearl's, Mary's, or Aquagrill (which seems to have more choices for shellfish if the online menus are correct?), but would certainly welcome any other choices. Thanks much!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
Posting Guidelines | FAQs | Feedback
Cancel
  1. im not too positive but marys and pearl's usually only have 1-2 types of oysters at any given time.

    for selection in a setting you requested, try shaffer city or the bar at grand central oyster bar.

    aquagrill and fresh are my favorite pure seafood restaurants...you may want to look into fresh in tribeca as well.

    1. Aquagrill and Shaffer's (formerly known as Shaffer City) are best for just oysters. Both are pretty casual. For more exotic stuff, it's a little more difficult as it depends on fish markets, etc. and what's fresh. I believe Aquagrill usually has periwinkles. For uni, I typically go to a Japanese place for that (Kanoyama had some great baby abalone a while back, Lan on occasion gets them too).

      4 Replies
      1. re: kathryn

        I'd go with Aquagrill (grab a seat at 5) ... sit at the bar ... kick back.
        The periwinkles make a great bar snack ... there are other notable "gnoshes" here.
        Ask Tracy.

        1. re: kathryn

          Agreed, Aquagrill and Shaffer City are the best oyster bars in the city for oysters, period.

          1. re: guttergourmet

            second.

            1. re: oystersallday

              yup.

        2. Aquagrill's is very nice when I went they did have periwinkles. Fresh is a very good seafood restaurant but I don't know what their raw bar is like. I was surprised with Bar American's selection of fun seafood "cocktails" with conch, and razor clams. Shaffer City has a good selection of oysters.

          1. Pearl and Mary's are not about the large selection of shellfish....just one or two selections of very high quality....you received good suggestions above...I like Aquagrill myself, its particularly pleasant at off hours...

            3 Replies
            1. re: Cpalms

              Thanks all, for the feedback. Kathryn, we're hitting Yasuda when we're there so perhaps we'll get our uni fix! Looks like Aquagrill is the front-runner but I'll do some more research on Bar American and Shaffer too.

              1. re: PegS

                Yasuda has always had the most amazing uni. Enjoy!

                1. re: potluck

                  The Peace Passage oysters at Yasuda are also wonderful.

            2. Look I'm not a new yorker but i've been eating oysters my whole life and I have NEVER found better selection than the Oyster bar in GCS. I haven't been in about 7 years but I bet it is still the king. No matter that I can eat the freshest out of the ocean when it comes to amazing variety and quality this is the place I woulld go.