Looking for a very private nice restaurant near LaGuardia
Ideally, they could offer a small private room, but a very private booth would also work. And it's for a 3 o'clock lunch. Italian would be great, but I'm listening...
Ponticello isn't too far, have had a holiday lunch for the past 2 years in their wine cellar room. Would highly recommend, although not sure about that time of day, but you should call.
If I remember correctly Piccolo Venezia, which is ten minutes away, has a private room downstairs and IMHO, excellent Italian food.