HOME > Chowhound > Southeast >
What's your latest food project? Get great advice
TELL US

Tupelo Honey/Mayfel's Breakfast Asheville?

Scirocco Aug 27, 2008 04:17 PM

We usually eat dinners in Asheville, but ended up there for breakfast this past Sunday. Had a pretty good breakfast at Tupelo Honey (my French Toast was a little dry although the blueberry sauce was excellent) and we'd definitely go back. But, then we walked past Mayfel's and I saw "Caramel Apple French Toast" on their specials menu which got my attention.

Question is, which is better for sweet stuff (pancakes, waffles, french toast)? I didn't know if Tupelo Honey gets the long lines because of the press it gets or if it truly is better. I've also had TH's sweet potato pancakes which I did like quite a bit.

Or somewhere else downtown that's better for my sweet weekend breakfast cravings?

  1. s
    SharaMcG Nov 17, 2011 12:09 PM

    Sunny Point is always my favorite for sweet breakfast. The orange-scented corn cakes are delicious and most breakfast plates come with fresh, seasonal fruit. Last year I had an oatmeal brule that was to die for, and the bacon is maple-pepper glazed and so good. I like Tupelo Honey, too, especially the granola pancake (order one: it's huge). Mayfels...meh.

    -----
    Tupelo Honey Cafe
    12 College St, Asheville, NC 28801

    1. w
      waynesvilleres Jan 26, 2010 04:28 PM

      Do not got to Mayfel's! I made better breakfast when I was in Boy Scouts. Nasty! If you want to try something different but that will blow your mind check out Chorizo in the Grove Arcade. This is latin style food and they have an amazing breakfast that is very traditional. And, let me tell you it is very close to authentic but with a twist. Forget about the usual boring breakfast, check out Chorizo. I can't wait to go back!

      1. j
        jappel16 Nov 12, 2009 08:47 AM

        I visited Asheville a few years back and loved Tupelo Honey and Early Girl. Now I live here and took a friend to both. I was unimpressed. The service was good at Early Girl and is generally good at Tupelo but the food was dry and just average at Tupelo and the coffee was awful and the food just okay at Early Girl.

        I like Sunny Point but it's true; the wait can be long. My new favorite brunch place is Mayfel's. I was skeptical about it at first, it looks kind of grungy outside and I had not read great reviews. Inside is fine, the servers were adorable and my friend and I split blackberry French toast which I'm still thinking about a month later and the omelet of the day which was delicious (and I am not that easy to please...I am a chowhound after all!)

        Going bacak to mayfel's for my birthday brunch. The wait there is not great either but not as bad as Sunny P. or Tupelo Honey. I didn't know about the Food Network bump. That explains the longer lines at Tupelo. It's not that great.

        Anyone know a good brunch place, casual, that takes reservations??

        -----
        Tupelo Honey Cafe
        12 College St, Asheville, NC 28801

        Mayfel's
        22 College St, Asheville, NC 28801

        1 Reply
        1. re: jappel16
          m
          mark Nov 12, 2009 09:18 AM

          fig does brunch now and takes reservations. more casual (plenty of jeans & shorts when i went) than at dinner hours. food is more reasonably priced as well.

        2. c
          ct_price Oct 21, 2008 09:44 AM

          Tupelo Honey most definitely has been kissed by Rachel Ray and gets the crowds because of the Food Network zombies who don't know how to experiment outside of what they see on TV. Mayfel's is quite good - their bacon is especially rockin'. I recommend their sweet breakfast and a good cup of tea for your early morning weekend victuals. Their decor with the crows is rather unique as well.

          1. Scirocco Aug 30, 2008 09:32 AM

            OP here. Thanks for the suggestions. I knew I could count on the CHs to steer me in the right direction (and away from the bad directions!) ! We have been by Over Easy several times at night and wondered about it.

            Will definitely have to try Sunny Point sometime. We usually like to go downtown just because we like to wander around afterward; but it sounds like it's worth a separate drive over to Sunny Point. Especially since it has a few options for my elusive "sweet stuff"!!

            1. m
              McChow Aug 29, 2008 11:06 PM

              My opinion:
              Over Easy is the best breakfast downtown.
              Tupelo Honey is a close second.
              Early Girl always disappoints.
              Sunny Point is fantastic, not downtown, but worth the drive and the wait.

              1 Reply
              1. re: McChow
                danna Sep 23, 2008 01:07 PM

                Tried Over Easy for the first time in several years this Sat.

                Biscuits are better than Sunny Point.
                Sausage patty no where NEAR as good.
                Apple butter is nice, but no where NEAR as good as the jam at SP.
                House hot sauce is awesome , as were the scrambled eggs.
                Service was *slightly* surly.

                (maybe i could buy some to go biscuits and smuggle 'em over to the west side)

              2. waitress Aug 29, 2008 05:10 PM

                I took my dad to Over Easy Cafe and we had a lovely breakfast and the server was nice , we went to Tupelo Honey the night before and the server was a little cranky.T
                The food was average , not as good as I had remembered.

                 
                 
                 
                1. m
                  miss piggy Aug 27, 2008 04:45 PM

                  I have heard nothing but bad reports about Mayfel's, but have never been myself (because of all the bad reports). I was going to suggest the pancakes at Laughing Seed with the awesome giner butter but I saw last tiem we were there that they took them off the menu. Sad! We used to get an order to share for the table...loved them!

                  Of the two, Tupelo hands down is going to be the consensus, I assume. And if you have not been to Laughing Seed, give it a try. Even my meat-loving, veggie-hating husband thinks it is the best breakfast downtown.

                  9 Replies
                  1. re: miss piggy
                    Scirocco Aug 27, 2008 06:36 PM

                    Ya, I figure that will probably be the case, but just thought I'd ask since for breakfast downtown, we've only been to Tupelo Honey. Also, I know lots of places do eggs pretty well, but I have a tough time finding good sweet stuff! :)

                    1. re: Scirocco
                      danna Aug 28, 2008 05:06 AM

                      Mayfels: went once, it was bad.

                    2. re: miss piggy
                      m
                      miss piggy Aug 28, 2008 06:18 AM

                      Ugh...just noticed all my typos in the earlier post. I hate that! Anyway, I meant to say "ginger" butter. Another thought would be to try Sunny Point - awesome breakfast, sweet stuff includes pancakes, waffles and stuffed french toast. Not downtown, but only about 5-10 minutes from there.

                      1. re: miss piggy
                        Jeff C. Aug 28, 2008 07:04 AM

                        I like Sunny Point, Tupelo Honey, and Early Girl Eatery for breakfast. Haven't tried Sunnyside Cafe or Laughing Seed yet but want to.

                        Haven't been to Mayfel's for breakfast but have been there twice for dinner. I wouldn't call it horrible, but it's certainly not as good as the others mentioned here.

                        1. re: Jeff C.
                          d
                          Displaced California Foodie Aug 29, 2008 05:03 PM

                          I was in Asheville for 2 weeks. Ate at Tupelo for 3 days then asked them where to go when Tupelo was closed on Monday: Went to Sunny Point as suggested by Tupelo and IT WAS WONDERFUL. The b-fast burrito was great. The jam was aswesome on the homemade angel bisquits. YUM. They are open for lunch and dinner too, Had a great portabello sandwich with melted fresh moxzzarella on foccacia that was excellent. Never went back to Tupelo and never will!
                          Early Girl: average at best.

                          1. re: Displaced California Foodie
                            lwhilyer Oct 17, 2008 10:17 PM

                            Why if you ate at tupelo for 3 days won't you go back?

                            1. re: lwhilyer
                              d
                              Displaced California Foodie Oct 22, 2008 05:55 PM

                              Because SunnyPoint was so much better than Tupelo - In my opinion.

                          2. re: Jeff C.
                            d
                            diablita FL Aug 30, 2008 05:57 AM

                            I like Sunny Point for breakfast as well. I haven't tried the breakfast at Early Girl. Lunch there is pretty good. One of my favorite late breakfast meals, also just outside of downtown, is the "Salvadoreno Tipico" plate at Cocina Latina. Black beans, eggs, plantains avocado and tortilla is a great way to start the day!

                            1. re: diablita FL
                              Jeff C. Aug 30, 2008 01:47 PM

                              My oh my, that sounds good, and I'll bet it it's also killer hangover food. "Tomatoes," as my wife and I call it, has some of the best cheap lunch and dinner eats in town. Now I want to try it for breakfast, too!

                      Show Hidden Posts