South St. CheeseSteak-input?
- Hypnotic23 Aug 11, 2008 02:52 PM
My buddy from Philly said this is the best spot for CheeseSteak Sandwiches, any input would be great?
Living adjacent to Westwood Village, I am quite familiar with the South Street there. They do a serviceable Philly cheesesteak, which is improved greatly with the addition of some hot sauce. Their combo, with a small order of fries, side salad, and soft drink, is a better value than the sandwich alone. They have had some trouble maintaining an "A" rating from the health inspectors. South Street is not as bad as many of the vitriolic posts on this board would indicate.
But it is far from the best in town. See a couple of recent threads on this board. My favorite is Big Mike's in El Segundo. Also far superior is Philly West just south of Santa Monica Blvd. on Westwood. I admit I haven't tried the favorite from further east in town, Fredo's. Even the chain Philly's Best gets more love than South Street.
re: Das Ubergeek
Agreed Ubergeek. Service is arrogant and often non-existent. Food is ill-prepared... the last two times I went, the cheese wasn't even melted on the meat and the bread was basic, crusty French bread (the cheap, thin kind) from your average grocery store. Very disappointing experience considering the great beginnings of this restaurant in Westwood.
I've had pretty good cheesteak at Philly's Best (owners are very nice and the food is consistently prepared with authentic, quality ingredients) and Fredo's in Pasadena.
South Street is pretty much gone from my book of places to find cheesesteak sandwiches. Don't bother.
I've only eaten at Philly's Best in Burbank, so I can't reccomend in comparison. They make some good cheesesteaks though. I always order a side of Tastycakes to complete the Philly experience. The Propietors are always nice too. Make sure you get a sandwich card on your first visit.The Glendale location is supposed to open soon, so that will be closer to me then Burbank.
For what it's worth, South St. has the dubious honor of sharing the second-lowest service rating in the 2008 Zagat with 12 points (the loser and still champion with 11, Father's Office in Santa Monica).
Okay, so I'm not from Philly, but my friend who hails from there agrees with me that the best cheesesteak hoagie to be found in L.A. is Philadelphia Sandwiches in the NoHo Arts District.
11112 Magnolia Blvd, North Hollywood, CA 91601
I lived in Philly for awhile, and South Street has one of the worst cheese steaks I've ever had. Philly's Best is okay but not that great (I went to one in Buena Park, perhaps others are better). I have yet to try Fredo's, but of the places I have tried, Big Mike's is by far the best. Just be sure to ask for extra cheese - they are extremely generous with the steak, and the steak/cheese ratio becomes imbalanced.
My gosh, hooks, you have it nailed about Big Mike's. The area's clearly best Philly cheesesteak. Very generous with the meat -- the sandwiches are like footballs. But they do pack in so much meat and then peppers after that the cheese tends to get lost. Thank goodness I can take comfort in their superior onion rings.
I had South Street cheesesteak last night for the first time. It certainly was not the worst cheesesteak in the world, you need to go to Subway to get that, but it was perfectly acceptable. My only real complaint was they were a bit stingly with the meat. As a side note, the fries were great!
I've also had the Philly cheesesteak at Philadelphia Sandwiches and it was on par with the South Street one. I will have to check out Philly's Best soon.