HOME > Chowhound > General Tristate Archive >

MUST EATS? near rt.28 Margaretteville/Catskills Park/Kingston area?

dnm3k Jul 30, 2008 11:53 AM

My finance's family owns a house up in the catskills past Margaretteville in Bell Ayre Village, I tend to spend quite a bit of time up there in the summer, however solid eating options? There are only a handful I know of between Peekamoose, and ofcourse Sweet Sue's Phoenicia.

So, do any of the great and famed Chowhounders have any solid reco's to hit up once you get off the Thruway @ Kingston going West? I'd love to start checking out some different places up there.


  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. l
    loupeppe RE: dnm3k Jul 30, 2008 07:03 PM

    Alternatives to New World Home Cooking and myriad other woodstock favorites you will hear about are two that we like and can recommend:

    The Reservoir Inn in West Hurley, although the service can be frustrating. They serve pizza but don't let that deter you, their entrees are very good.

    A bit (well, more than a bit) off the beaten path is the Country Inn in Krumville. known for their wide selection of beer, they also have great food.

    1. c
      chaz RE: dnm3k Jul 30, 2008 07:08 PM

      There is a great barbecue place on 28 several miles west of Kingston=Hickory

      2 Replies
      1. re: chaz
        dnm3k RE: chaz Jul 31, 2008 08:01 AM

        I tried Hickory on my way up there a month ago.
        Im a big BBQ snob and so is my girl, she didn't care for their pork or their weekend special fried chicken. The pulled pork was definitely underseasoned however it still pretty much hit the spot and I'd definitely go back.

        1. re: dnm3k
          LloydG RE: dnm3k Jul 31, 2008 08:37 AM

          I tried Hickory a few weeks ago and had basically the same reaction. I did takeout in the car (ruining a pair of shorts), but I longed to sit on that deck and have a beer with my q. That might make it better.

      2. l
        loupeppe RE: dnm3k Jul 31, 2008 07:12 AM

        Have you tried the Public House in Roxbury? Although I've never been their website is intriguing: http://www.publiclounge.net/index2.htm. On my list is a trip to Roxbury to take in an Old Time Baseball Game (http://www.roxburyny.com/index.php) and a stop at the Public House.

        1. e
          EdAllegro RE: dnm3k Aug 3, 2008 06:12 AM

          You'll need to drive a little. Woodstock offers New World Home Cooking and the Bear Cafe. Both are excellent and worth the drive. If you go as far as Kingston, the Hoffman House is quite good. It's in the "Stockade" or historical district and worthy of a walk around the old town.

          1 Reply
          1. re: EdAllegro
            dnm3k RE: EdAllegro Aug 5, 2008 10:20 AM

            On a whim I hit up Winchell's Pizza in Shokan yesterday on the way home, pretty damn good deep dish pizza, awefully dough-y in a great way, crust was good. had the bbq sampler platter, brisket was a lil over cooked chicken was good and ribs were crusty a lil over cooked but smokey and I was surprised by how good the place was considering I always pass it on 28 but never went in until now, it just might be a spot I hit more often on my way upto Highmount.


          Show Hidden Posts