Atlantic Grill?

[mustlovecoffee]

A client I am taking to lunch has picked this place:

Atlantic Grill
[phone] www.brguestrestaurants.com
1341 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10021

First question - Is it good?
2nd question - Recommendations from the menu?

[amysal47]

I was not impressed, had the simply grilled mahi mahi which was burnt and I rarely complain or send entrees back. My boyfriend's seabass wasn't much better I'm afraid...maybe just stick to the sushi?

[thew]

this place is solid. everything is good quality and well prepared. nothing cutting edge or new about it, but all the standards done well.

i haven't been in a while, but i remember they had a good lobster bisque, and a nice oyster selection.

[digsnola]

The raw bar is ok, but i would stay away from any of the fish. (I know it's a seafood resto but I'm being serious)

[Ora]

Good ambiance. Average food. High prices for what it is. Appropriate for a business lunch.

[offthebeatenpath1]

Altantic Grill is a place that is consistently good, but won't blow you away and probably won't disappoint you. It is well executed seafood. I recommend the Big Eye Tuna salad, it is quite refreshing for a summer lunch.