Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > General Tristate Archive >
Jun 29, 2008 06:46 AM

cake in Westchester

Where can I find a cake in Westchester ( other that Lulu) that has a decent cake to icing ratio. I find most bakery cakes are all icing and very little cake, yuck!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Other than Lulu? I'm not sure why, but since Lulu is my first choice, I'd have to say Plaza Sweets in Mamaroneck.

    Until Lulu's, I hadn't found a bakery cake that I consider good. La Tulipe gets lots of press, but they are not good.

    2 Replies
      1. re: roxlet

        I suspect that is a reference to the Riviera Bakehouse in Ardsley. Love their cake. Can recommend chocolate cake with raspberry mousse filling- mmmm.

        1. re: Bloombee

          We tried a cake from Rivera and it had a freezer burn taste to it, we tossed it. We should have brought it back but it is a little out of the way. I think we might try them again and mention the original problem so it doesn't happen again. We have gotten other items from them that were good.

          1. re: chowdom

            I've heard that about some of the cakes in the refrigerator case, but since I never buy anything there but custom cakes, I've never had a problem.

            1. re: roxlet

              Yes - the cakes we have bought were custom as well

        2. There is Chester Heights Bakery in New Rochelle. Great chocolate ganache frosting!

          5 Replies
          1. re: westchester_hilary

            But I'm still curious, why reinvent the wheel?

            Lulu's has them all beat, why go anywhere else?

            1. re: dolores

              DH does not like the cake, I think it is a little too rich for him.

            2. re: westchester_hilary

              When was the last time you purchased a cake from Chester Heights Bakery?
              When Bruno and Bridget owned it, it was my favorite bakery. We tried a cake under the new ownership and we threw it in the garbage, it was really that bad. I don't think they use real ingredients (butter, sugar...) it tasted like chemicals. And it was all icing.

              1. re: chowdom

                I'm not sure when they changed owners. I've had their cake in the past 6 months and it tasted the same to me. We always get the custard and frosting layers with the chocolate ganache frosting.

            3. The best cake in Westchester has to be Perfect Endings Bakery in Armonk. I would tell you my favorite but I love everything.

              1 Reply
              1. re: busdrivermom

                We tried a few cakes at Perfect Endings recently, couldn't say we were terribly impressed. The chocolate cake was a little dry and the icing tasted waxy.

                The oatmeal cookies were fantastic, though! And also a great coconut cookie! But I think we'll pass on the cakes.

                I think we'll stick to Lulus for the cake. By far the best. And another great place for cakes is CIty Limits, they are also fantastic and you can tell they use real, fresh ingredients. Maybe you can order a cake and request your bakery to have them put less icing and more cake?

              2. Don't laugh but if you need a big sheet cake for a birthday, Costco makes a yummy cake.

                1 Reply
                1. re: bonacbub

                  IThanks for the recommendation,I'm not laughing, we have ordered sheet cakes there in the past, ( for large picnics) however we are looking for something on a smaller scale.