Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Minneapolis-St. Paul >
Jun 26, 2008 07:01 AM

MSP - Jambalaya & Po Boys

Need a New Orleans Style Fix. This is a duel request for a great Jambalaya and a great shrimp Po Boy in MSP.

All suggestions welcome!!!!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Oooh! What a great quest.

    I love the oyster and catfish po-boys at Sea Salt Eatery in Minnehaha Park, though I can't speak to "authenticity". I've never tried the shrimp po-boy there, though. They have jambalaya on occasion, as well, and it's been a hit with my dining companions...


    3 Replies
    1. re: The Dairy Queen

      I see Stella's Fish Cafe has a Shrimp Po' Boy, but it's $13.95. Sorry, but I don't think I've had a sandwich anywhere yet that is worth $13.95.

      Sea Salt sounds like a great suggestion for a day like today!! Thanks TDQ.

      1. re: tda

        I have had the Oyster Po Boy at Sea Salt Eatery. While is isn't loaded with oysters like New Orleans, it was pretty darn good.
        Ironically, they used to have a huge rock shrimp Po Boy at the Cheesecake factor which was amazing. Sadly it is no longer on the menu.

        1. re: TDS1

          Wow, tda, tds1 and tdq all in the same thread...

          I recently tried the fried oyster basket at Sea Salt--the hot sauce they serve with that is REALLY hot, in that punishingly painful but too delicious to stop eating it sort of way. I wonder if they make that in-house or if they buy it.

          They don't seem to put the same sauce on the po-boys, though, or if they do, it's in such small quanitities the heat doesn't pack the same punch.


    2. I will 100% agree with the Sea Salt recommendation. I was just there with my sister and her boyfriend (who got the oyster Po' Boy, and it was phenomenal).

      I got the catfish Po' Boy, and it was just as good as what I got in New Orleans when I was there in March.

      HIGHLY recommended.

      2 Replies
      1. re: BigE

        I think that Sea Salt is an excellent suggestion and probably does have the best seafood Po Boy in MSP. However, when I've ordered them in years past, they've been served on a soft hoagie roll. (I've been several times this year, but had to bail after seeing the lines.)

        In and around New Orleans, Po Boys are always served on French bread and that's actually the key ingredient that makes a Po Boy a Po Boy, not so much the fillings. (Southern Louisiana French bread is very crispy on the outside and soft on the inside.)

        Is Sea Salt still using the soft hoagie rolls for their PBs? If they've remedied that, then I'll make sure I get down there ASAP.

        1. re: Kilgore

          The Sea Salt and Stella's po' boys are OK. Just OK. I agree that they're probably the best in this area. Sea Salt could really crank it up on a notch if they served it on more appropriate bread (see Kilgore's comments above) and if they used Tabasco mayo, like they do in New Orleans. This is simplicity itself -- a combination of mayonnaise & Tabasco sauce, which imparts great flavor and also holds the itsy-bitsy sandwich pieces together.

      2. Can't help you with the Jambalaya, though I hope someone will have some to report in the area. Isn't there a southern food restaurant, maybe in st paul?, that opened about 1-2 years ago?

        I second the Sea Salt. I have family in Louisiana and get down there a fair bit. i've had worse po boys there, and some about as good as but not really much better than sea salt. Though it's true the bread could be improved.

        4 Replies
        1. re: Enso

          Dixies on Grand is a southern food restaurant in St Paul which has both a shrimp Po Boy as well as Jambalaya. The menu looks really good. I have been wanting to try this place for sometime - but have never been, so can't comment on the quality (but perhaps others could). It's a bit of a hike from EP, so unfortunately haven't made it over there.

          1. re: TDS1

            I've eaten at Dixie's a few times, and it's pretty mainstream. Nothing too spicy, nothing too crazy, nothing really bad but nothing really good, either. In general, not so authentic. I woiuld give it a great big "meh." Always seems to be full, though, but that often tells me that in its inoffensiveness, people who want to feel like they're eating cajun or southern go there because it's so mild.

            1. re: cheeseguysgirl

              I second the "meh." Though I did see a loaded Norm Coleman there once...

              1. re: churchka

                I third the "meh." Dixie's is fine if you want to stop in for a beer and some coconut shrimp at the bar, but other than that...meh. And churchka, I know exactly what you mean on the latter.

        2. If you like to take scenic road trips especially down the Mississippi River, Buzzard Billy's Flying Carp restaurant in downtown La Crosse, WI serves a credible jambalaya and po'boy.

          3 Replies
          1. re: Davydd

            Any relation to Buzzard Billy's Armadillo Bar and Grillo in Waco Texas? Absolutely amazing crawdad etouffe and po'boys. Menus printed on the labels of vinyl LPs. Lots of good local music. Back in the day, when Baylor banned dancing on campus (Baptist school, you know), Buzzard Billy's was slammed with kids. Great fun!

            1. re: Loren3

              I don't know if it is associated with Waco. Here is a pic of the place in La Crosse, WI.

              1. re: Loren3

                I went to school in LaCrosse and we always got the alligator. It's my sister's favorite place, but it kind of reminds me of Applebee's.

            2. The newly opened Citizen Cafe in South Minneapolis actually does a po boy that compares with the one I (greatly!) enjoyed during my last trip to New Orleans. Incredibly bright and fresh bits of tomato help counterbalance the bun + small fried shrimp, and the whole package was nicely enhanced by the smoked tomato aioli. I wolfed it down, and I don't normally wolf down my food.

              I fourth the "meh" on Dixies.