Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Los Angeles Area >
Jun 25, 2008 04:30 PM

sona, melisse or ortolan?

I think I've narrowed it down to these three - for one special dinner. I've read the reviews on the board but am looking for most up to date and recent advice for dinner in a week or so.

I'm from SF and am looking for something in the quality area of The Dining Room at the Ritz, La Fole or Manresa - to give you an idea of my taste

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. The original comment has been removed
    1. Although I haven't been to Melisse or Ortolan yet (will be going soon) I have always had great experiences at Sona.

      1. of these three, i'd say sona. i find melisse a bit stuffier for my taste.

        1. Of the three, I find Ortolan to be the most consistently interesting and enjoyable, while Sona is the most "hit or miss" and has the least attractive room. Providence is also well worth considering if you like Manresa.

          1. I know it's not one of the ones you mentioned, but I say go to Providence. Just dined there this past weekend and it was easily the best meal I've ever had. Had the 9 course with wine pairing and it was worth every penny.

            3 Replies
            1. re: TailbackU

              I'd say Melisse over Providence. In my opinion, Melisse's menu has a much wider range than Providence, is more flexible to accomodate tastes and desires, and the sommelier is better. Providence certainly has many devotees, and is clearly capable of delivering an amazing experience. It is also inconsistent. We've been twice for special dinners. The first time Providence hit it out of the ball park and the second time the experience was substandard largely because of numerous issues with the service; some of the food was incomparably good. At this point in time, I wouldn't recommend them for a dinner on a special night.

              1. re: TailbackU

                Had considered Providence but given lawdogs recent poor experience it just doesn't seem like a place I'd choose to patronize.

                1. re: estnet

                  every restaurant will have customers not happy with their matter how good they are. Obviously it's your choice as to where you spend your hard earned money on a nice meal, but choosing not to go to a restaurant based on one bad review seems kind silly. Providence probably receives 20 excellent reviews for every one bad one like lawdog's.