Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Jun 21, 2008 11:49 AM

Grilling whole bluefish tonight for 1st time-recipes/tips?

I'm thinking simple is best. Perhaps just some salt/pepper and olive oil on the outside and salt/pepper, thyme/rosemary and some lemon slices on the inside. Am I on the right track or do you have other suggestions?

Also, the whole fish is a little over 2 lbs. I have a gas grill. What setting should I set the grill on and how long per side should I cook it? Thanks all.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. the splendid table, an italian cookbook, has a good recipe (Lynn Rosetto Kasper). bluefish, given its strong flavor, needs an assertive rub/paste/marinade. I usually take pancetta (or bacon) and put it in a food processor with rosemary, panko bread crumbs and olive oil. Stuff the bluefish with it and grill. I usually add lemone slices as well.

    1. I usually marinade in something like orange juice, it needs it. Make sure to remove the dark parts, that is where the fishy taste comes from.

      1. i mix about a tablespoon of mayo, some mustard, lemon, dill, s&p, olive oil. spread it on top of the fish, grill skin side down. yum.

        i do it on medium/high on the gas grill and don't flip it. cook til it flakes with a fork- maybe 7-10 min

        (edit- just saw you have a whole fish- this is for a filet- sorry! but if you filet the fish, this is awesome)

        1. A guy working at whole foods suggested equal parts of coarse dijon mustard and sour cream mixed together, place a dollop over grilled or broiled blue fish, right after removing from heat source.
          It was delicious!