My BF is turning 39 - he is a big fan of great atmosphere in restaurants and loves seafood. Im thinking along the lines of O'learys or Lewnes but not sure how romantic either place is? thanks for your help!
If "bf" is not an adventurous eater, then I would stay with Northwoods. They have basic steak, seafood, and are willing to prepare certain foods to people who are a bit less adventuresome. And, the venue is small, and quite romantic.