Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
May 21, 2008 09:04 AM

Mom's 50th- Which TOP restaurant to wow her?

Hey all my mother's 50th birthday is coming up in a few weeks and I really want to treat her to an amazing meal and experience. I have booked Del Posto but am rethinking it since I don't know if it is great bang for the buck. Money really is no issue but I don't want to plop down 500 bucks on a dinner I don't absolutely LOVE. My mother loved Babbo as did my entire family, so I figured Del Posto would be a great choice and you get that added atmosphere. However, from what I have seen and read it looks like paltry portion sizes and they recently took the ribeye for two off the menu that I was dying to try after seeing it at Babbo.

Other restaurants that get tons of press that I am considering are Daniel (mainly because I think it looks like one of the most beautiful restaurants in the city), Gotham Bar and Grill, Cafe Boulud, and Felidia (she loves Italian and Lidia in particular, however wasn't too impressed with the menu).

For Daniel- Do they offer specials or do you have to choose from the prix fixe menu for $105pp? How does the food stackup and are the portions decent for what you pay? I know Gayot gave it a 19/20 rating. Seems like one of those "you have to try it at least once in your lifetime" experiences.

Would love thoughts about the other places as well. Should I just keep my Del Posto reservation??

Out of these which would be the best based on food, atmosphere, bang for your buck, and really overall experience? Any other recommendations are welcome as well but I am really concentrating on these.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I think you're right about Del Posto--besides, it's overrated, in my opinion. The Gayot 19/20 for Daniel is deserved. You really have to go at least once I think your mom would love it. But also consider Per Se, which Gayot also gave a 19 to.

    1 Reply
    1. re: electrosnack

      A dinner "in a few weeks" isn't much lead time for Per Se, but I suppose you could always try for the wait list.

    2. I am a huge fan of both Daniel and Cafe Boulud, and actually prefer Cafe Boulud. Last year I treated my mother to a dinner at Jean Georges for her 55th birthday and she loved it. Also, Blue HIll is a great choice I think. If you are big seafood eaters, then I would hands down recommend Le Bernardin. Great atmosphere and food.

      1. The original comment has been removed
        1. Hi SR85,

          I know this notion of "bang for your buck" is important for you, and hence in my previous post I mentioned Del Posto may not be the right choice for you as you will find it overpriced. I think going to another restaurant will indeed improve your dinner experience based on your criteria.

          Have you ever considered Craft? The dishes at Craft are meant to be shared and are very generously sized. There are also a huge variety of dishes to choose from (which may trigger you to post another post : what should I order at Craft? ;D), so there will be something for everyone. The steak / beef there is awesome, so it will be a bonus for steaklover like you.

          1 Reply
          1. re: kobetobiko

            I am actually taking my father to Craft for his 50th lol! I have narrowed it down to Daniel, Del Posto, and Gotham Bar and Grill.

            Like I said money really isn't the issue. I do not mind spending tons of money at Del Posto or anywhere for that matter as I love and appreciate great food. I just want to get the best experience possible.

            Called Daniel and I can score a reservation for around 5:45 on a Saturday. I am thinking about going for it since it is a $105 prix fixe which is about the same I'd spend at Del Posto. How has everyone's experience went at Daniel?

          2. Have you considered the tasting menu at WD-50? Mom probably will have never eaten anything like it and it might be more memorable in the end. Plus the food is so interesting that it makes for great conversation.
            Bruni's recent review: