Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Pacific Northwest >
May 9, 2008 02:42 PM

Molly Moon ice cream in Wallingford (SEA)

Stopped by this new place today. Been waiting for a real ice cream place to open in Seattle. It was the first day they were open, the interior is nice, modern, open - still finishing up some things, but their grand opening is tomorrow. Overall I thought the flavor selection was good, the ice cream was all good, maybe on the sweet side. Tried:
maple walnut - not very maple-y, more like vanilla with walnuts, but nice and creamy
salted carmel - very salty, but I liked it, out of 3 of us, 1 loved it, 1 did not like it and I thought it was good.
cardamon - nice, very cardamon-y
vanilla bean - a good creamy vanilla, with lots of bean
honey lavender - not my taste, but it was ok
thai iced tea - again not my thing, but my sister liked it
Next time I'd like to try the coffee, ginger, and lemon... she also said they would have a chocolate orange sorbet tomorrow, which sounds good.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Salted caramel!! I've only had that at Bertillion in Paris and it was out of this world. Thanks for the review.

    5 Replies
    1. re: christy319

      I had salted caramel at Harvest Vine some months ago and it was amazing. I tried to make it myself, and while good, it didn't hold a candle. I'll have to check out Molly Moon to see what they have!

      1. re: dagoose

        I tried Molly Moon's yesterday, and we had strawberry balsamic, Vivace coffee, cardamom, and lavender honey. The strawberry balsamic was my favorite, and the rhubarb orange sauce was great.

        Christy & Dagoose, I know what you mean about salted caramel. I agree that Harvest Vine's version is great. I found an awesome recipe for salted butter caramel ice cream on David Lebovitz's blog.

        I haven't had the ice cream at Bertillion, but David claims his is better than theirs. ;) All I can say is that it's the best ice cream I've ever had. I didn't try Molly Moon's version while I was there, but it's on my list for next time I'm in.

        1. re: WrightEats

          I'll have to make the Lebowitz recipe. I finally tried Molly Moon's and wasn't that impressed. The Baracky Road was really scarce on marshmallows and nuts, too.

          I still think Fran's makes the best ice cream in town.

          1. re: christy319

            Can you still get Fran's ice cream in Seattle? Last time I went by their shop in UVillage they said they didn't sell it there any more.

            1. re: TravelHound

              I work at Fran's and can confirm that we no longer make ice cream for any of our locations. A few things, including health dept. regulations and a change in management at Fran's, spurred this decision.
              I wish we still had it too!!!

    2. The coffee was *excellent*. And I hate coffee ice cream. But now I know why.

      Normal coffee ice cream tastes like "coffee flavor".
      The Vivace Coffee Ice Cream tasted like *coffee*.

      The balsamic strawberry was also amazing. Odd, but amazing.

      1. I can't believe I didn't know about this! It's blocks from my house. I'm heading there today. Thanks!

        4 Replies
        1. re: Lauren

          I forgot to post back after I went. I thought the place was okay, not great. It's odd that you can't see the ice cream before you order. We tried thai iced tea which was weakly flavored. I liked the salted caramel but I've had much better elsewhere. I'll give it another try (and get the coffee as recommended below) but, after that, if it's not great, it will be "off the list".

          1. re: Lauren

            After reading the phenomenal buzz on this place, I had high expectations, and made a trip there last week. It's a fine addition to the Wallingford strip, but the ice cream itself wasn't exceptional, in my opinion. Seemed to me that the salted caramel wasn't very balanced--it was certainly salty, but otherwise? Bleh. The balsamic strawberry was better, but I wouldn't order it again. Will definitely go there when I'm in the neighborhood and jonesing for an ice cream cone, but I wouldn't drive across town for Molly Moon's ice cream.

            1. re: Snapdragon

              I agree. Went there last weekend and stood in the long line. Got up to the front planning to buy two pints, but left with only the thai iced tea due to some miscommunication with my SO (I thought he liked it, he thought I liked it, turned out we both didn't care for it...oops). We tried the salted caramel and the scoop I had was too salty. Also tried the strawberry balsamic and did not care for it. Neither of those flavors were balanced at all. Also, I dislike the texture of the ice cream - best I can describe is that it's too "fluffy" for premium ice cream.

              1. re: akq

                I have similar complaints about flavor balance and texture.

                I'm a huge, fan, though, of their sorbet: texture is perfect, and I've never had a sorbet as full of fruit.

        2. Sounds like its worth a visit. I hope they last. If Ben and Jerry's can't make it at U Village have to wonder about these guys.

          9 Replies
          1. re: landguy

            landguy, Ben and Jerry's is moving, not completely closing. They'll be reopening at 7900 E. Green Lake Drive N

            1. re: WrightEats

              That's not really U Village but I get your point.

              So they're moving to somewhere near both Baskin and Robbins and Mix? That seems odd to me.

              1. re: Lauren

                Mix closed down a few months ago, so that area could probably use a new ice cream place.

                1. re: HCGirl

                  Aw, man, the Mix on Green Lake closed too? I thought it was just the one on the Ave?

                  And, while that Ben and Jerry's might be moving, the one in Ballard closed as well.

                  1. re: jaydeflix

                    Mix closed? Then it's a good thing that Molly Moon opened!

                    1. re: jaydeflix

                      They both closed, much to my dismay. That was my favorite ice cream spot! I just heard over the weekend that the owner skipped town rather unexpectedly. Must have been having some financial troubles.

                2. re: WrightEats

                  Interesting. Thanks for the heads up.

                  1. re: WrightEats

                    Is this store open yet? Have to say I still prefer it to anything else in town.

                  2. re: landguy

                    The rents at UVillage Shopping Center are phenominally and dizzyingly high. Not only do you pay rent but a pretty good cut of your sales, too. If you don't have strong year-round sales, then you're screwed (my best guess). Not sure how B&J did in the winter months.

                  3. We went last night. The ice cream was pretty darn good. I had vanilla (outstanding flavor and texture) and salted caramel (a little tooooo salty, I thought). My wife had coffee (outstanding) and chocolate (pretty good).

                    These guys are still figuring things out--when we arrived around 9 pm they didn't have any spoons! (How can an ice cream shop run out of spoons?) But the product was very strong, and we will definitely be going back.

                    1 Reply
                    1. re: Earl of Sandwich

                      they aren't restricting number of samples. I don't know about you but hub and I had 4 each. That's 8 spoons right there. Then we bought 3 pints. Sorry. :)