HOME > Chowhound > Austin >
What's your latest food project?
TELL US

Threadgill's in South Austin

Helind Apr 28, 2008 12:59 PM

As of today, I've lunched at Threadgill's at least half a dozen times. And each time, I'm disappointed. The people who take me there seem happy as clams. The place is usually packed. Is there something wrong with me? I think there is a severe problem in the kitchen. It takes along time for my food to get to me after I've ordered it; and it usually comes out luke warm to cold. The menu looks great but the food is somehow bland or oddly prepared. For instance, today I had black eyed peas that were more sweet than salty. I love the decor and the vibe. The wait staff is nice enough. What's up with the food? I'm from the south, and love southern cuisine, can someone suggest someplace better? It would be great if it was in the same area.

  1. Veggo Apr 30, 2008 05:07 PM

    How I yearn for the Kenneth's original veggie platter. Where else in America can you get a lunch of 9 (spelled NINE) vegetables on a lunch platter, including squash casserole, creamed spinach, okra, plus 6 more of your favorites, PLUS a huge chunk of center-cut corn bread, for a lunch?
    Where?

    1. MPH Apr 30, 2008 04:42 PM

      In my opinion, Threadgill's has been bad for years. Some disagree, of course, but I notice that it's almost never recommended on this board. You can count me as another chowhound who doesn't like Hoover's, either.

      If you're looking for similar types of food, check out these older threads for ideas:

      Where is the best fried catfish within 25 miles of Austin?
      http://www.chowhound.com/topics/371520

      Soul Food in Austin?
      http://www.chowhound.com/topics/420043

      Feed Me Feed Me Feed Me Feed Me Feed Me Feed Me
      http://www.chowhound.com/topics/474770

      1. a
        angelfoodmaker Apr 30, 2008 08:01 AM

        I still am waiting for ThreadGills to come to Cedar park any ideas when?

        1 Reply
        1. re: angelfoodmaker
          amykragan Apr 30, 2008 08:10 AM

          Last I heard they were in a fight with Cedar Park over permits, etc. It was supposed to already be open but obviously has been very delayed.

        2. El Jefe54 Apr 29, 2008 09:48 AM

          I have to agree with the posters here. The south locations is lame and always has been. It's not a patch on the north store (although I must admit I have not been there in a long time). I also have to say I don't see what others do in Hoover's; I think it's vastly over-rated. While Freddy's is really good, I don't understand why posters here compare it to Threadgill's; in my estimation that's apples and oranges.

          1 Reply
          1. re: El Jefe54
            amykragan Apr 29, 2008 10:00 AM

            I think the comparison is strictly based on "home cooking" comfort foods with chicken fried & veggies.

          2. r
            renz Apr 28, 2008 09:15 PM

            The one time I visited (south location) with my brother and his wife, every thing we had, except for one potato side, was utterly bland and unpleasant in texture, from the rolls to the meats to the sides. Personally I think Luby's has far better food.

            I'm eager try Lola's on Rosewood.

            1. l
              Lara_Noel Apr 28, 2008 09:04 PM

              It's not just you. Two days ago I got the bronzed chicken, which I thought was adequately seasoned but I didn't like the meat's consistency/texture(?). For some reason I kept feeling a burst of liquid in my mouth every time I chewed, but it was not flavorful or savory by any means. The mashed potatoes were bland, bland, bland, as was the cream gravy--heavy salt and pepper needed. Although the collard greens had a great spicy kick to them, they were a little too stiff.

              The lemonade was pretty good (very sweet) and had lots of pulp (yum!) I'd like to comment on the strawberry rhubarb pie I paid for, but it never made it into the to-go bag with the rest of my meal.

              I'll venture to say I prefer Luby's, especially since it's cheaper.

              1. m
                mkwng Apr 28, 2008 03:15 PM

                I ate pretty regularly at the original several years ago and I almost always enjoyed it. I agree, though - recent trips to both locations have been below average.

                Other options include Hoover's on Manor, Arkie's Grill on E. Cesar Chavez, Gene's on E. 11th, and Nubian Queen Lola's on Rosewood.

                1. amysuehere Apr 28, 2008 02:00 PM

                  To me, Thredgill's is a lot like an upscale Luby's. Firstly, because it's a central Texas icon and continues much because of this. Secondly, it's the "warm fuzzy" effect. People like it because it revitalizes warm memories through its food. I admit, once in a blue moon I crave the veggie platter. I know the "veggies" are faaaar from being great food and they've buttered/cheesed/cooked any healthiness or vitamin content out of it, but it feels good to have once in a while. btw, husband HATES the place.

                  Agreed, Freddie's is my current fav for chicken fried chicken and spinich casserole.

                  1. i
                    ieathereforeiam Apr 28, 2008 01:51 PM

                    bad luck maybe? I've found the food there to have gotten better in the last 6 months or so. the north store especially. and the vegetables are usually very consistent, at least in my experience there.

                    1. amykragan Apr 28, 2008 01:16 PM

                      I think Freddy's is much better for southern style food. Plus they have great outdoor seating.

                      Show Hidden Posts