HOME > Chowhound > Minneapolis-St. Paul >
What's your latest food quest? Tell us about it
TELL US

[MSP] Pastrami Jack's

d
Dragon Apr 22, 2008 12:44 PM

I just had lunch at Pastrami Jack's, and it was delightful enough to warrant its own quick review rather than the one-off mentions in the deli threads of this board.

Finding myself in Eden Prairie near the lunch hour is very rarely a pleasant prospect, but the occasional work outing lands me in the middle of the devil's triangle of the Crosstown, 169, 494 and 212 around the noon hour. Most of the time, in such cases, I head to Campiello's and ask for Jean, the long-time beverage director, to shake up me up a martini...and I forgo the gloppy alfredo sauce, close my eyes and wish I was in Uptown.

Today, rather than taking a long detour into a cold beverage, I chose the left-hand path and walked into Pastrami Jack's. From the outside it seemed a fairly deserted, typical suburban strip mall dining experience...except for the alluring "We Do Our Own Corned Beef" prominently plastered on the plate glass. Huh!? Sign me up...

On entering I joined a crowd (a crowd...in Eden Prairie!) queuing up around the counter and down the long service hall. Often, in joints like this, there are signs and omens about how good the chow is going to be, even before biting into the piled-high pastrami on rye. Sometimes, you can tell the caliber of a joint even before hitting the order station just by looking at who's in line. Slumming C.E.O.'s? Hmmm, interesting. Dusty, whip-thin construction workers? Getting warmer. Gaggles of old Jewish women (I'm assuming, they ordered kosher)? It's a winner. Over-weight suburban cops taking up time before their next call? Bingo! All of them? A definite dinaliscious scene. I don't see this diversity of diners in either of the downtowns, or inner ring suburbs...to find them in Eden Prairie over the lunch hour was more than surprising...it was revelatory.

After reading the first couple of lines of the board, I glanced away...I knew it without having to look. Hot pastrami, corned beef...I got the rest by inference (although I checked while savoring my tender, pepper-spiked pastrami). Brisket, soft salami (kosher), hard salami (not kosher), turkey pastrami, tongue...it was all there. As was the possibility of reubenizing all of the above...yikes! Matzo ball and chicken noodle were representing the soups...and, just in case you forgot you were in the middle of Minnesota rather than in New York...a nice bowl of chicken wild rice.

Service was quick and no-nonsense. I got my well-worn, little red number, and I sat down at my sparkling little formica two-top and within mere moments I was delivered one of the best culinary experiences I've had in the last coupla months...months that included visits to Porter and Frye, The Strip Club and Alma. The odor wafting off the pile of deliciousness was redolant of rye, and pepper, and beefy smoke...enough to set off alarms of excess that had me reaching for my dose of Vytorin before sucking down the savor.

There is, as we all know, an art to making a sandwich...particularly a hot sandwich. Too much meat and not enough bread it all breaks down into chaos. Too little of either and it's a disappointing, dry mess. Those whose art form is sandwich, who sculpt in mayo and meat, in bread and mustard, exist in a rarefied, rarely entered realm. Here, in front of me, was a shining example of the form. Perfectly executed, the bread sliced just so thick and reeking of rye, the proportion of meat, half-fatty half-lean, balancing on the edge of stuffed...it was tender and airy and dense...and delicious.

Add in a an open cole slaw and pickle bar (I just want to write that again...an open cole slaw and pickle bar), new dinner hours and a location that nearly guarantees chowish credibility for finding and you've got yourself a bona-fide, lunch-time, destination drive.

Leaving, I noticed an elderly lady, grinningly being pushed in a wheelchair through a door held open by a Brooks Brother-suit-wearing, Dolce & Gabbana-tie-sporting business type, both holding, "have a nice day" smiley bags filled with leftover containers. If there is a better endorsement of Pastrami Jack's, I don't know what it is.

Dragon

  1. Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. The Dairy Queen Apr 22, 2008 12:52 PM

    Sounds like a place I'd better add to my ever-growing list of places I*MUST*GET*TO.

    Thanks for the great read!

    ~TDQ

    1. k
      KTFoley Apr 22, 2008 01:17 PM

      yes, gotta go see what all the fuss is about.

      (Lunch martinis would be a career-limiting move, but a plateful of pastrami is not yet illegal. Gotta enjoy it how we can, plus there are leftovers!)

      1. Jordan Apr 22, 2008 03:14 PM

        Thanks for the great write-up. Pastrami Jack's is a favorite of mine in the Twin Cities -- the best Jewish corned beef experience I've had here.

        7 Replies
        1. re: Jordan
          d
          Danny Apr 23, 2008 07:42 AM

          I concur with everything Dragon has said. Their Potato Knish is pretty good too. Not the best in the world, but very good for around here.

          They were shipping in H&H Bagels for a while too. I don't know if they still are.

          1. re: Danny
            m
            mifish May 30, 2008 06:42 AM

            I was there for breakfast with a friend about three weeks ago. A Saturday at 10:00 a.m. and we were the only people in the place. H&H bagels were still advertised on the menu, but they were serving something closer to a thawed Lender's Bagel. The type that's been left in the freezer way too long.

            1. re: mifish
              w
              whoopdido May 31, 2008 07:30 AM

              In my post about best delis in the twin cities this was mentioned along with Cecil's, Brother's and a few others. In my personal opinion, Brother's is fantastic. How does Pastrami Jack's compare to Brother's Deli in downtown Minneapolis?

              1. re: whoopdido
                katebauer May 31, 2008 08:30 AM

                I can only compare the matzoh ball soups, but Brother's is my favorite, followed by Cecils, followed by Pastrami Jacks, and finally with Crossroads (which I thought had HORRIBLE matzoh ball soup). Perhaps I'm looking for that ever elusive comparison to my grandmother's soup, but Brother's and Cecils definitely take the top spots, and don't require suburban trips!

                1. re: katebauer
                  t
                  tex.s.toast May 31, 2008 09:12 AM

                  out of curiousity, kate, were your grandmother's balls (did i just write that?) sinkers or floaters?

                  i know that in my family we usually had to put two pots of soup on, one for the folks who wanted texture approximate clouds (heretics) and one for the sensible people who wanted leaden stones which threaten to jump from the bowl as you try to cut them using multiple pieces of silverware (preferably a sharp knife).

                  1. re: tex.s.toast
                    katebauer May 31, 2008 01:11 PM

                    They were sinkers but able to be cut through with the edge of a spoon, so not as heavy as yours sound like. According to her, my grandmother followed the Manishevitz recipe exactly but yet still, I've never been able to recreate it. Perhaps it was the New York City tap water.

                2. re: whoopdido
                  Jordan May 31, 2008 10:34 AM

                  I've never made it to Brothers (got lost in the skyway system once trying to find it). The matzoh ball soup at Pastrami Jack's is pretty good -- not great, but acceptable. The matzoh balls are very big and very fluffy.

          2. bivouac May 31, 2008 11:05 AM

            Call me a heretic, but I get pastrami on a challa roll with swiss and mustard and I dare say that PJ's pastrami is as soft as the roll. It's something to behold. As far as matzo ball soup is concerned, I'll stick with Crossroads, but PJs pastrami sandwich stands alone.

            1. bivouac Feb 28, 2010 01:14 PM

              RIP - Pastrami Jacks.

              1 Reply
              1. re: bivouac
                s
                scooter260 Feb 28, 2010 02:45 PM

                Closed 6 months ago.

              Show Hidden Posts