Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Ontario (inc. Toronto) >
Apr 15, 2008 06:40 AM

Diamond Pizza (East York)

Just showing my love for Diamond Pizza (on Main st.) and their other location In Scarborough. Who gets delivery from here? Man, when I was in college My friends and I just about put their kids through college, I seem to remember at the house we lived at sometimes ordering 3 times a day. Faves are the chicken caesar salad (they DRENCH the dressing on sometimes hahah) Garlic bread...anyone ever order the bureka? I think they have the most extensive delivery menu in the city.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. They dump takeout menus in my mailbox every few months. I've been curious, but the breadth of the menu has always frightened me off of ordering from them: I've been of the opinion that if you try to do too much, you end up doing nothing well.

    2 Replies
    1. re: vorpal

      >the breadth of the menu has always frightened me off of ordering from them

      vorpal, my thoughts exactly.

      I'll give it a shot though, even though we've always been happy with Bona, just to try something new.

      1. re: vorpal

        Not always but usually the case.


      2. I will have to try them out. Golden Pizza is probably in the same range of culinary experience, and I like Golden pretty well. I find the Greek-run pizza places tend to offer everything under the sun on their menus, but so far they have all managed to make their pizza taste pretty good.

        Golden Pizza
        1201 Broadview Ave, Toronto, ON M4K2T1, CA

        Diamond Pizza
        510 Main St, Toronto, ON M4C4Y2, CA

        1. Good Pizza, Bad Delivery.

          Their pizza is surprisingly good. But the catch is you often have to wait up to 2 hours to have it delivered by navigationally challenged delivery people who have no working knowledge of the local street grids. It's 2010 for God''s sake. Hasn't Diamond heard of GPS?

          Other irritant is the crazy lady who answers delivery requests. Be prepared for interruptions, misunderstandings, arguments and stream of conciousness rants when ordering from Diamond.

          I finally gave up on Diamond about a month ago after a fruitless conversation with crazy lady who screamed "OH DUMB, DUMB, DUMB, DUMB!!!!!" after the 4th time I corrected her on my street address. Since then, I've stuck with Pizza Pizza (crust tastes like cardboard but at least it arrives under 40 minutes).

          Diamond Pizza
          510 Main St, Toronto, ON M4C4Y2, CA

          3 Replies
          1. re: somewhere4

            Could not agree more. I have had the exact same experiences with this place. Unfortunately, the pizza is good, however the delivery times are not acceptable.

            1. re: vaiguy777

              I started ordering from Diamond about two months ago and never had any contact with the "crazy lady"... Maybe she's no longer there? Haven't had any issues with delivery times either.

              1. re: itsvince

                I got delivery a few times last month and didn't have any time issues either.

          2. Noticed the frequent flyer dumps too... we went to a friend's place who ordered the pizza for dinner & we were sold. It was delicious and price was comparable.

            Now, we order from Diamond (Main St. location) at least every other week. (For at least the last 6 months or so) We always get the same thing - 2 mediums with 2 topping each. Toppings on the bottom, cheese on the top. Hot & fresh. We haven't tried anything else so can't comment.

            We haven't experienced delivery problems, it's been fast & efficient for us. (Exception being an order we placed on a Saturday night...(not surprising of course) it was a little slower than usual but pizza arrived hot.) It is our new pizza place and would never eat pizza from the big franchises now that we have this option. (We prefer Danforth Pizza but without delivery, it's a challenge for us to get over there some nights.)

            Danforth Pizza
            920 Danforth Ave, Toronto, ON M4J1L9, CA

            1. Do they have slices ready to go??


              1 Reply
              1. re: Davwud

                Ive been ordering from the Scarborough placefor the past couple years, I wouldnt say they have incredible food or anything, but its good enough and the wide range of menu items is perfect for someone who mas the munchies and is tired of ordering more common items like pizza.

                I like to order the Gyro on a Pita, its pretty tasty. Their chicken wings are laughable, tiny little things if i remember, but not breaded, and the sauces werent anything to write home about, but i dont mind em when im hungry.

                Ive ordered burgers from there, panzerotto, poutines, even a milkshake once!

                Its been a while since ive ordered from em, but after writing this I think im due.

                Again, Diamonds Pizza probably wont win any awards, but if you are looking for something thats very affordable and has a lot of options, Diamonds will do the trick for sure!