Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Cookware >
Apr 3, 2008 01:40 PM

Kamado vs Big Green Egg

The Chowhound Team split this tangent off from the Pacific Northwest board.
* * * * * *

I have a #9 Kamado cooker that I paid $1,200 for. 1/3 of the tiles have fallen off, hope you have better luck than I have had, willing to sell it for $20 - you haul.

You can get BGE lump at the local bge stores, Walmart will have lump, Cash n Carry will have mesquite lump up there in 40 lbs bags.

You might want to put a post on the BGE forum, lots of egg heads up in Seattle that are more than willing to assist.

Sorry about your purchase, should have bought a BGE.

Go Ducks!!!!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I didn't purchase it, I got it for free off Freecycle. It is one from Japan that looks to be at least 25 years old. No tiles on it, it's just a big terra cotta egg that used to have paint on it. It's not brand new, but nothing at all wrong with it.

    I'm really just looking for advice, there are entire forums on people buying subpar Kamados for people to vent at. I made the mistake of looking at one by accident.

    2 Replies
    1. re: allisonw

      I have my grandmothers Kamado from Japan (no tiles on mine either - it's exactly as you describe it) that must be close to 50 years old and I use it all the time. We use briquettes in it all the time as they tend to burn slower than lump charcoal and it's a pita to add more briquettes while cooking/smoking. Not only that - but because the way the Kamado is designed - each time you open it you lose tons of heat. It's designed to remain closed while cooking. We use the Minion Method ( for the charcoal with a few pieces of hard fruitwood soaked in water placed on top. It's perfect.

      I do use the lump charcoal from Sutter Home and Hearth (on Ballard Ave) but not in the Kamado.

      1. re: Lauren

        Although not for a Kamado or BGE, the virtual weber bullet site linked above is a treasure trove of information and recipes. I've got the weber and have done some mean ribs and pork butts using recipes I found on the message boards there.

    2. I Will try to find a way to have someone pick it up. If you give me details Ill see if I can buy it from you. Do you have photos?


      1. I took a sledge hammer to it and smashed the concrete and chicken wire shell to bits! Easier to haul it to the dump.

        Get a BGE and have a great cooker for life!

        1. If Kamado is still avail please provide contact info and best time to pick up...