Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > General Topics >
Apr 3, 2008 09:12 AM

Soup dumplings (dumplings FILLED w/ soup)

A friend of mine was telling me about her recent travels to NYC Chinatown. She went to a place that had soup dumplings....and no it's not what they're thinking.

They're actually dumplings that are FILLED with soup. And then when you're done drinking the soup, you dip the dumpling in a sauce. They sounded so good...has anyone heard of these, or is it only just this one place?

Do they have another name?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Search for "xiao long bao" on the boards. They've been talked about extensively.

      1. The place was likely Joe Shanghai, btw

        3 Replies
        1. re: jgg13

          And note also that Joe's Shanghai's soup dumplings are not "authentic" but are a bigger, soupier Americanized version of this Shanghai specialty.

          1. re: Ruth Lafler

            there are several different kinds of dumplings with soup in them in china, most served in shanghai - whatever the origin, from tiny to huge.

            and again - tastes good trumps authentic every time in my book

            1. re: thew

              there are much better places than joe's shanghai (aka dirty dishwater soup) to get soup dumplings in ny. try shanghai tide in flushing.

        2. The best-known place for these in the Los Angeles area is Din Tai Fung in Arcadia. Insanely popular - it's got long lines out the door at any mealtime, and they've opened another one adjacent to it just to handle the crowds.

          FYI, the soup is "inserted" by wrapping the dumpling skin around a glob of cold jellied soup, which then melts when the dumpling is steamed. Probably lots easier said than done.

          11 Replies
          1. re: Will Owen

            "FYI, the soup is "inserted" by wrapping the dumpling skin around a glob of cold jellied soup, which then melts when the dumpling is steamed. Probably lots easier said than done."

            It isn't so bad to make a soup dumpling, but it is hard to make it well. We have made yummy soup dumplings, but our problem was getting enough soup inside it. Also, the skin is very hard to get right. I've been using store-bought skins, and now thanks to some hints from other Chowhounds, I am about to embark on homemade skins. We'll see how it goes. I can certainly make an acceptable comestible, but it is an art to get them just right. For this reason I shall continue to search out the professional version in a restaurant. I had some wonderful xiao long bao in Toronto recently. They were even better than the ones I had at Joe's Shanghai in NYC. Perfect skin and broth, so very special. A very unique dish.

            1. re: moh

              Moh, what type of store bought skins do you buy? Dumpling skins? Wonton skins? Egg roll wrappers cut up? I've kind of got this fear of making anything dough related (probably due to all my past failures) but always wanted to make my own soup dumplings.

              And Toronto defintely has better Chinese food than NYC.

              1. re: Miss Needle

                Miss Needle, I bought square dumpling wrappers. They worked well, and the final dumplings tasted great. The recipe I used was the one based on Anita Lo's recipe in Bon Appetit May 2007 (I believe you can find it online at They specifically state not to use wonton skins, as they are too thin. The recipe is delicious, but because of the size of the wrappers, I found I could not get in enough soup gelatin and still close the skin well enough. So I am going to experiment with homemade wrappers that are a bit bigger, and also adjust the amount of gelatin.

                But there is no question. The professional soup dumplings I tried in Toronto were amazing because the wrapper was sooo delicate and so thin, and yet they held together when picked up, and there was all this rich broth in them. My dumplings were very delicious, but they were not these soup dumplings. Work of art... I am completely obsessed with them. They are fabulous. Still, Anita Lo's recipe is fairly easy to do, and they are fun to make! Worth trying, and it makes a fun kitchen party.

                1. re: moh

                  Thanks for the tip about Anita Lo's recipe. It looks good -- never had soup dumplings with shrimp in them, but sounds delicious. Before I take a stab at homemade wrappers again (made hau gau wrappers that failed miserably) I think I'll try getting some eggroll wrappers and cut it to appropriate size.

                  1. re: Miss Needle

                    In the Bay Area there are a few places that make soup dumplings with crab, either mixed with the pork or pure Dungeness crab.

                    1. re: Ruth Lafler

                      Yeah, we get that as well. Believe it or not, as much as I like crab, I prefer the plain pork ones. I think I'm also going to try this with ground turkey or chicken (the blasphemy!). DH can can eat pork like it's going out of style, but I really like to limit my pork consumption.

                      1. re: Ruth Lafler

                        A friend of mine reported that she found the most insanely delicious crab soup dumplings in Vancouver, huge and rich.

                        I do love Dungeness crab. I still think very fondly of a crab dish in Chinatown in San Francisco (Gold Mountain? I think that was the name of the place) cut into pieces, lightly battered and perfectly fried with salt and pepper. I need to find an excuse to go back to the Bay Area.

                        1. re: moh

                          It would be nice to know the name of this place in Vancouver as we'll be there in a week. However, being "huge" is not a virtual in the XLB world. They are supposed to be small and delicate, not huge.

                          1. re: PeterL

                            I cannot tell you the name of the place as my friend doesn't remember the place, sorry. But have you seen this thread on the best XLB in Vancouver?


                            Sounds like you have a lot of good choices! Have fun eating!

              2. re: Will Owen

                It's not difficult at all -- many times the aspic mixture is incorporated into the filling. So all you have to do is scoop and wrap.

                1. re: Will Owen

                  Anyone interested in making these should look at how Kirk and his missus did a batch at mmm-yoso!!!


                2. People made a huge fuss over them when they first appeared at Joe's Shanghai years ago. After having them twice, I couldn't figure out what the big deal was, myself.

                  1 Reply
                  1. re: Fida

                    The soup dumplings at Joe's Shanghai are good but nothing that extraordinary.

                    When we go there and DON'T order them the waiters seem pissed off (though they rae surly to begin with). They assume that everyone goes there specifically for the dumplings.