HOME > Chowhound > Outer Boroughs >

Best Jamaican Beef Patties (areas or restaurants)?

Xiao Yang Mar 19, 2008 08:23 AM

A transplanted New Yorker just posted a request on the San Francisco Bay Area board for the"best" Jamaican beef patties like he was used to in NY. A hopeless request, if you ask me, but that raised a couple of questions in my mind, as I have only encountered the rather wretched, seemingly ubiquitous ones served at convenience stores and fast food outlets,

Just where ARE the best Jamaican Beef patties in New York, both from the standpoint of neighborhoods/communities and individual vendors?

Secondly, just what makes a good Beef Patty a good Beef Patty?

Focus on Beef Paties please, not on other delights of Jamaican cuisine, (though if you want tease my tast buds with an aside or two......).

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. g
    ginsbera RE: Xiao Yang Mar 19, 2008 10:59 AM

    Little Miss Muffin - Park Place in prospect heights

    3 Replies
    1. re: ginsbera
      biondanonima RE: ginsbera Mar 19, 2008 12:11 PM

      Honestly, the Golden Krust chain of fast food restaurants, which are all over the Bronx and parts of Queens and Brooklyn, have really good Jamaican beef patties. There's also an outpost in the basement at Grand Central.

      I know nothing about Jamaican cuisine and nothing about what is SUPPOSED to make a beef patty good, but the reason I like the ones at Golden Krust is because there's a nice ratio of filling to crust, the filling is nicely seasoned, and the krust is tender and flaky yet sturdy. Other places I've tried tend not to have enough filling and/or the crust is very dry.

      1. re: biondanonima
        editor58 RE: biondanonima Jan 17, 2010 05:59 AM

        I am sorry to disagree, but GK patties are complete garbage. It is the fast food of patties and might even have Alpo inside.

        1. re: editor58
          rxslc RE: editor58 May 30, 2010 07:10 AM

          OMG editor58, I love you, I so agree with you, golden krust beef patties are the nastiest patties I have ever eaten, the filling was like eating gravy with a few specks of beef, just nasty!

    2. oolah RE: Xiao Yang Mar 19, 2008 12:49 PM

      Buff Patty on Myrtle in Ft Greene. Great flaky crust, hot filling with delicious spicy and complex flavor. Christie's on Flatbush is pretty good too, but I prefer the Buff Patty crust texture.

      Christie's Jamaican Patties
      387 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238

      Buff Patty
      376 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205

      3 Replies
      1. re: oolah
        lambretta76 RE: oolah Mar 19, 2008 01:33 PM

        Part of my enjoyment of a pattie is the coco bread, and I just love Christie's version.

        1. re: lambretta76
          vinegarhill RE: lambretta76 Mar 19, 2008 07:25 PM

          I second Christies. The beef patties are incredibly tasty and have just the right amount of heat.

          1. re: vinegarhill
            ginsbera RE: vinegarhill Mar 20, 2008 06:35 AM

            If you haven't tried Little Miss Muffin I highly reccommend it. Though I like their beef patties I actually think their BBQ chicken patties are the best thing they offer, plump, and filling.

      2. Cheese Boy RE: Xiao Yang Mar 19, 2008 07:56 PM

        To answer your question 'what makes a good beef patty a good beef patty' ... First and foremost, the patty should be served hot or warm, NOT cold. Many places cook their patties around lunchtime and have them sit around in glass-enclosed unheated displays all day. Avoid those places if you can. Patty crusts should not break apart easily after one bite, and should be flaky -- indicating freshness. Very hard crusts or soggy crusts are usually old. Fillings should be generous and *moist* with the right amount of heat. It's disappointing to bite into a patty to find that there's not much filling in it. Lastly, if you opt for coco bread, be sure the patty is heated (or reheated in some cases). The coco bread will certainly fill you up. Visit Jamaican/West Indian neighborhoods for the best.
        I can't make any recs b/c my search continues for good beef/chicken patties.

        I should also mention that there are those people who order beef patties from neighborhood pizza shops in NY. Those patties are typically Tower Isle brand patties that arrive frozen, are cooked daily around lunchtime, and then reheated upon request throughout the day. Some people opt to get theirs filled with CHEESE -- the same cheese used for pizza toppings. It's probably a NY thing if I had to guess and it is tasty!

        3 Replies
        1. re: Cheese Boy
          Judyluvs RE: Cheese Boy Mar 21, 2008 03:39 PM

          I occasionally give in to the craving for a pizza shop beef patty with sauce and cheese. I'm sure it's deadly, but it's so juicy and tasty! I've seen others who order the patties add on extra things like pepperoni, sausage, grilled onions, jalepenos and red pepper flakes.

          1. re: Judyluvs
            Cheese Boy RE: Judyluvs Mar 21, 2008 07:42 PM

            Judy, wow! I've only seen cheese and pepperoni toppings. Some of the other toppings you've mentioned just remove the whole Jamaican "essence" for me personally. I'm a bit of a purist when it comes to patties - no toppings - only coco bread if I'm really hungry. (I will admit that a patty topped with cheese is really tasty though).

            1. re: Cheese Boy
              Judyluvs RE: Cheese Boy Mar 25, 2008 01:12 PM

              Well, you do have to consider that usually the beef patties and toppings were being ordered by big, hungry guys looking to add something to their snack of the moment... and with a couple of slices! Since I personally can't handle spicy foods very well, the separate ones where the persons added on pickled jalepenos and a (seemingly endless) shake of red pepper flakes made me watch in food prep fascination.

        2. r
          rad RE: Xiao Yang Mar 20, 2008 10:27 AM

          Not a Jamaican patty (hope that's cool), but I always used to get great ones at this very small Guyanese place called Golden Loaf, at 715 Nostrand near Sterling in Crown Heights. Some of the best I've had in the city as far as filling-to-crust ratio, spicy inside with a very fresh and flaky crust. Goes great with a 'Ting.

          1. bosun RE: Xiao Yang Mar 25, 2008 03:44 PM

            I would try The Feeding Tree in the Bronx - 892 Gerard Ave # 161
            Bronx, NY 10452 (718) 293-5025‎
            I still haven't gotten around to going there, but I have heard good things.
            I like the spicy chicken patty from Golden Crust, but I find that their pastry can be a little thick and dry at times. A good patty should have a light a flaky crust, at least that's the way I like 'em.

            2 Replies
            1. re: bosun
              damenacer RE: bosun Mar 26, 2008 09:09 PM

              You have to try Jackie's Bakery in the North East Bronx It is located in the plaza on the intersection of 233rd and Baychester Ave. They have by far the best Coco Bread I have ever had. They bake their own patties and Bread, not like Feeding Tree who outsources their patties.
              FYI....Golden Crust pattyies are a little to flaky for me, not full of meat, and you can taste that they are not fresh.

              1. re: damenacer
                bosun RE: damenacer Mar 27, 2008 06:12 AM

                ooh, have to get to jackie's. thanks!

            2. missmasala RE: Xiao Yang Mar 25, 2008 07:43 PM

              take a walk down flatbush ave, starting right below prospect park. you'll pass many many jamaican and other west indian eateries and bakeries, most of which have patties.

              As for what makes a good patty—look for flaky pastry and nicely spiced beef filling that isn't too much like pap. Look for ones that aren't too big (bigger ones are often dried out and don't have as good a crust to filling ratio) in places that have a high turnover.
              personally, i prefer chicken patties, because in the best ones the scotch bonnet pepper flavor just sings.
              if you discover any real gems, please report back.

              3 Replies
              1. re: missmasala
                Xiao Yang RE: missmasala Mar 25, 2008 08:17 PM

                Scotch Bonnet, or Habaneros to us out here, yowzah! Um, and a Red Stripe with that, please.

                I'm a virtual newbie to Jamaican Beef/Chicken Pies so I probably wouldn't know a gem, but maybe I'll lean fast once I get back there.

                1. re: Xiao Yang
                  bolletje RE: Xiao Yang Nov 9, 2008 12:19 PM

                  I wanted to bump this to add some of my Patty research findings. I really love the beef patties at the Haitian Immaculee Bakery which I first heard about courtesy of the Porkchop Express: http://porkchop-express.blogspot.com/...
                  Although they aren't all that similar to the Jamaican ones, they're amazingly delicious and satisfying and due to their extreme flakiness they're more of a beef croissant. The price has gone up to 80 cents.

                  I love the patties at Jamaican Pride bakery on Flatbush--they're pretty much perfect with plenty of spicy filling and superior golden crust. Their salmon ones are good too, flavored with onions and celery I think.

                  Gordon's Bakery, also on Flatbush is not as good IMO, the patties don't have as high a turnover rate and are a little pedestrian.
                  I had a yummy veggie patty somewhere on Church near the post office...will have to walk by again and check what the name of the place was.

                  1. re: bolletje
                    jmj RE: bolletje Nov 10, 2008 08:35 AM

                    Jamaican Pride definitely the best in that short stretch of F'bush (try the Meatloaf, only Fri/Sat I believe), followed by Erroll's, with Gordon's a distant third. Golden Crust doesn't even count, IMHO--you would do (much) better getting frozen patties from the supermarkets.

              2. Cheese Boy RE: Xiao Yang Nov 10, 2008 09:07 PM

                I very recently had the beef patty at The Feeding Tree and I admit that it's still the best I've had anywhere in the Bronx. The chicken patty wasn't very good (too loose, too watery). Both patties were served to me PIPING hot. I'm so not accustomed to that. Often times other places serve them room temp or outright cold. "Hot" was a rather nice "mode".
                Give them a try if visiting the Yanks or otherwise.

                The Feeding Tree, 892 Gerard Ave near 161st St, Bronx (718) 293-5025.

                1. tasaday RE: Xiao Yang Nov 10, 2008 09:09 PM

                  In Queens, try Patmar Bakery on S Conduit Ave, in Rosedale, they're fantastic, and much better than the patties at Golden Crust, who also have a restaurant on the same block.

                  1. bigmackdaddy RE: Xiao Yang Nov 10, 2008 11:25 PM

                    I've been a fan of Christie's since the '70's. However, if you have the energy for a long walk I suggest you walk on Nostrand Ave. starting at Fulton St. and take it a few miles to The Junction where you will see plenty o independent beef patty places. Most of which are delicious and most of whom I don't remember the names. I will also second Little Miss Muffin. I like their veggie patty better, it has a great whole wheat crust and I usually hate whole wheat crust. Avoid the pizzeria's/Tower Isle. They're plain gross.

                    1. malibu RE: Xiao Yang Nov 11, 2008 02:51 AM

                      another vote for Christie's on Flatbush.

                      1. t
                        tabs RE: Xiao Yang Nov 15, 2008 02:47 PM

                        I've been obsessing over these, certainly the best homeade Jamaican beef patties (I've tried almost all the ones mentioned below on this thread.) It's a place on 164th street in Jamaica Queens off of Jamaica Avenue across from the 1st Presybyterian Church in Jamaica. I don't remember the name...I went last Sunday and there was a guy chopping meat in the kitchen. They also have Jamaican chicken patties. It's really worth the trip. And the patties freeze well. (If you are in the area Marguerita Pizza on Jamaica Avenue is 1-2 blocks away. It's one of the best slices in the city.)

                        2 Replies
                        1. re: tabs
                          tabs RE: tabs Nov 15, 2008 02:50 PM

                          I just found the place..... Patty World Restaurant 89-59 164th Street, Jamaica Queens NY 11432 718-658-6838

                          1. re: tabs
                            Jeffsayyes RE: tabs Jan 7, 2009 03:37 PM

                            Thanks for the Jamaica rec. I will have to try next time I have to do something civil or get caught.

                          2. h
                            heavykeitel RE: Xiao Yang Oct 31, 2010 07:59 AM

                            Hey, anyone have authentic Jamaican beef patty recipe? I've tried various recipes online but just can't seem to get it right. I am willing to pay for it. Please see more info there http://jamaicanbeefpatty.wordpress.com/

                            Show Hidden Posts