HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Momofuku Ko - I had finally tried!

k
kobetobiko Mar 15, 2008 10:21 AM

Hi all,

I was quite lucky that I got a reservation online at Momofuku Ko early this week without any major technical issues that some other people mentioned. I know there was a request of a review in another thread. Although I don't normally write reviews for restaurants (as I believe you need at least 2 or more visits to know if a restaurant is really good or bad), I will write a bit (just some of my thoughts, not a review per se) about my dinner at Ko to share with my fellow chowhounds from whom I have learnt so much over time.

Just as a side note, I actually regretted that I read the reviews (e.g. Ruth Reichl) and pictures posted by other early Ko diners. Why? I felt that with the reviews I had created some unfairly high expectations to the dinner at Ko, and the pictures had somehow eliminated the "wow" factors for me. If I didnt't have the pre-dinner exposure of the dishes, I think the dinner would have been a notch better. In addition, it was afterall a tasting menu that you wouldn't be able to choose the courses anyway, so you don't need inputs for what to order or to avoid. If you are planning to go to Ko soon, please keep this in mind as I don't want YOUR dining experience to be affected by what I wrote below. I am not a professional blogger or critic, so please excuse my unsophisticated language in describing the food and experience.

The 11-course tasting menu was more or less the same as the picture set from Kathryn, with an addition of an amuse and some minor variations. I am not going to post any pictures, but if you are really interested, let me know and I will post some upon request.

The restaurant was only half full when I entered the unadorned tiny Ko with an early reservation. The staff was extremely efficient and friendly in providing us with coat check and seating us. The restaurant applied a simplistic approach to everything from the table wares, the kitchen, and the restaurant décor itself, which was very consistent to other Momofuku restaurants. It wasn’t fancy and the clean design was very unintimidating and causal.

I didn’t choose the wine pairing as I knew I would be too full with all the wine and the food. Instead, I opted for a Momofuku private-labed sake which had a neutrally clean, dry, and slightly sweet taste and it was an excellent companion to all my entire dinner.

To save some words, I will list out the each of the dishes in the tasting menu and a short description of what I felt about them.

1. Pre-Amuse Bouche – Fried Pork Rinds with Togarashi Pepper (2 pcs for 2 ppl)
These were the best pork rinds I had even tasted. The pork rinds were extremely fresh and crispy without any of the rancid fat taste you might have experienced from the vastly marketed pork rinds. I noticed the superior pork flavor and upon asking I was told that the pig skin were from Four Story Hill Farm. No wonder these pork rinds were so decadent and additive. A touch of the togarashi pepper, an ingredient that I used extensively in my Japanese cooking, provided an extra dimension of spicy flavor. My only complaint was that there were only two pieces, and with pork rinds that good, I could really eat them by bucket!

2. Amuse Bouche – Mini English Muffins with Whipped Pork Fat, Sea Salt, and Chives (2pcs for 2 ppl)
The mini muffins were toasted to give a slightly crispy outside and were soft inside. The pork fat had a very mild taste, which might be good to people who did not prefer intense pork fat flavor. However, for me, it was a bit too mild and I wouldn’t have known that it was pork fat if I wasn’t told. It reminded me of the lard served at Del Posto, but this one was a toned down version. I found this amuse good and was not excited by it.

3. Fluke Sashimi with Spicy Buttermilk Sauce, Poppy Seeds, and Chives
I always believe that simple preparation is the best way to highlight high quality fish, and this dish was an excellent example of my belief. The chef entertained the diners with his superior knife skills and sliced the fillet of fresh fluke into slices. Four delicate pieces of fluke sashimi were then placed into a bowl like flower petals with a spicy buttermilk sauce. Topped with poppy seeds and chives, this dish combined the sweetness of the fish and the buttermilk sauce, with an additional spicy kick (Sriracha was the secret, I was told). The poppy seeds not only provided a textural contrast but also a hint of nutty flavor. I found the flavor, texture, and presentation of this dish to be all excellent.

4. Pork Bellies with Oysters, Kimchi Consomme, Bok Choy
I once watched David Chang on the Beekman’s show and he mentioned that the combination of pork and oyster is actually a classic Korean approach. It was not surprising to see that this combination appeared in the Bo Ssam at Ssam Bar and here at Ko.

The two slices of slightly grilled pork bellies had the right amount of fat and meat to provide a luscious mouth feel. Again, there was no question that the pork was of high quality, and a slightly crispy texture was attained from the charred exterior. The flavor resembled the suckling pig you had in tapa bars or in Chinatown, without the crackling skin. Two juicy and plump oysters sitting on an oyster shell tasted oceanic on their own and became mild when eaten with the pork. The slightly warm kimchi consomme was very mild, quite different from I expected from the spicy characteristic of kimchi (and what I would have prefered to give a dish a bit more highlight).

Each element of the dish had its own flavor and when combined, they provided a different taste note. I thought it was a great dish, but at the same time I wasn’t wow’ed because the taste was a bit familiar. Texture-wise, I probably would have liked it more if the crackling skins were present (Did they use them all for the pork rinds?). But that was just my personal preference.

5. Sous-vided Egg with Paddlefish Caviar, Sweet Onion, Crispy Fingerling Potato Chips, Herbs of Chervils
The dinner reached its climax with this ethereal dish, my favorite of the night. The egg was sous-vided to the consistency of a perfectly soft-boiled egg with the silky egg yolk running out like lava. The chef used a knife to slit open the egg before topping it with caviar to create a dramatic presentation. The paddlefish caviar was quite mild and certainly didn’t have any “fishy” taste. Rather, its savory flavor was perfect with the velvety yolk, providing a pleasant sense of taste and texture. I forgot to ask what kind of egg it was, but I did ask the chef how he cooked the onions so that they came out SO sweet and tender. Oh, it was just slowing sweating the onion with butter and constantly adding water. Yes, the simplest at its best.

The tiny potato chips were probably the best chips I had tasted. Crispy without the slightest greasiness, the chips enhanced the dish by providing an invigorating crunch to the dish, the texture that I was looking for in the pork belly dish. The herb, which I first misinterpreted as cilantro, was chervils which tasted like a combination of well, cilantro and parsley.

This dish scored extremely high for me due to my genuine love of egg dishes and its perfect execution in presentation, texture, and flavor. I want to have a bowl of this dish every day for my breakfast!

(side note: In Ruth Reichl’s review, the caviar was Osetra caviar. Mine was from paddlefish...)

6.Seared Scallops and Manila Clams, Bacon Dashi, Pickled Fennel, Sea Beans, Dried Nori, and Puree of Black Trumpet

The presentation reminded me of the sea trout sashimi dish with dill puree at Jean Georges with its stroke of trumpet puree on side of the bowl. Two plump and succulent jumbo scallops were complemented with a flavorful bacon dashi which screamed “pork” to me. I loved the dashi by itself, but didn’t like it once it was muddled with the nori and the puree. The scallops were very sweet, but they were not particularly new or exciting to me as you can find sweet scallops in a lot of fine restaurants these days, especially with my frequent visits to sushi restaurants. (That’s said, they were still really good).

The sea beam added a palatable savory taste to complement the sweetness of the seafood and the smokiness of the broth. Overall, this dish was good but didn’t excite me like other dishes.

7. Shaved Foie Gras, Lychee, Pine Nut Brittles, and Grape Wine Gelee

Certainly a brand new approach to foie gras, this decadent ingredient was completely transformed in appearance and texture in this dish. The frozen foie gras was shaved on top of layers of grape wine gelee, pine nut brittles, and lychees. So, the big question was, how did it taste AND feel like?

While the dish was very intriguing visually, the taste was actually not too different from your normal foie gras mousse or pate, and if I were to say, actually less intense. The mouth feel was also very mild as the minute you put the shaving into your mouth, it melted into a velvety texture like a smear of foie gras pate (and as the shaving sat longer in the bowl, you would find it becoming pate/butter-like). You can probably think of the texture as shaved parmesan cheese on your pasta, which melted in your mouth and your dish. The pine nut brittles were extremely delicious and was the star of me in this dish. The wine gelee was as close to the wine gelee served with the foie gras brulee at Jean Georges as it could be.

Lastly, the lychees, one of my favorite fruits, was the failing component for me. I think it might not have been their problem, but having grew up with fresh and intensely sweet lychees, the tiny lychees in this dish was unappealing. They resembled the ones you got with syrup in a can in Chinatown, with both the natural sweetness and juicy mouth feel of the translucent flesh completely lost. I rather had some sort of fruits that were in season to go with the dish than these lychees. Then again, the problem might be me because I am used to extremely fresh ones.

Overall, while I still prefer my foie gras to be served in the more traditional way, I enjoyed this dish and I applauded their creativity in finding a new approach to foie gras.

8. Deep-fried Short Ribs, Daikon with Mustard Seeds, Grilled Scallions, Pickled Carrots

Deep frying short ribs was a courageous approach by Ko. It might sound too heavy at first, but it wasn’t. The flavor of the short ribs was EXTREMELY intense, bursting with “beef” flavor. I wasn’t sure what they did to the beef or what kind of beef they used, but there was a noticeable concentration of meaty taste in the beef that I didn’t find in other beef I have tried before. I couldn’t see any marbling in the meat. I think the fat was probably caramelized in the deep frying process which provided a hidden sweetness to the meat. However, while the inside was perfectly cooked with a vibrant pinkish red color, the outside was too “burnt” and was very dry. The deep frying was supposed to provide a crispy exterior, but mine was too burnt and stringy and too tough too chew. It might have been just my piece of beef, as I saw that most of diners happily savoring every single bite of the meat without anything left on their plates.

The daikon served with the dish was cooked to fork tender, soft to the point that it didn’t required any chewing. The mustard seeds were a bit assertive to me, but that’s just because I wasn’t a big fan of mustard to begin with. The picked vegetables provided just the right amount of acidity to cut through the meat dish.

9. Grilled Rice “Cake”, Pickled Vegetables, Miso Soup

This was the last savory dish of the night, and it was a familiar closing for me as I liked to finish off with grilled onigiri in izakayas. Unfortunately it was also my familiarity of this ending that made this dish the weakest among all. The rice was rolled into a tiny log, grilled to provide a nice char outside, and topped with sprinkle of nori.

The rice wasn’t anything special and certainly didn’t standout in other rice that I had tried. The pickled vegetables were the same as the ones that you could order in the Ssam Bar. The miso soup was also very traditional but average in taste. Overall, every component of this dish was ordinary, and the execution was average.

10. Pre-Dessert: Pineapple Sorbet with Candied Pineapple

This sorbet was a good way to cleanse our palate after the savory courses. Again, I didn’t find either the sorbet or the candied pineapple to be extraordinary. They were good, just not exceptional. However, the diner sitting next to me couldn’t stop raving to the chef how good this sorbet tasted, and that had me puzzled. For me, it was an enjoying dish, but nothing memorable per se.

11. Deep Fried Apple Pie, Sour Cream Ice Cream, Miso Sauce

An upscale version of the deep fried apple pies that I often had in the McDonald’s in Japan and Hong Kong, this dessert was a delightful finish to the meal. The cold sour (cream?) ice cream created a toothsome harmony with the warm apple filling oozing out of the pie crust. The miso sauce provided the extra layer of savory flavor to the dish, something that I found to be not necessarily important, but it didn’t hurt either.

The 2 hour dinner finally came to an end. Overall I enjoyed my first meal at Ko. The dishes mostly ranged from good to great, with the climax of the egg and beef dishes as the most memorable. However, there were something lacking. Perhaps from David Chang & Co., I would to love see more unusual ingredients and more aggressive flavors. Ko seemed to take a relatively mild approach to flavors as compared to the sister restaurants, and I wasn’t wowed by the flavors for the most part.

On the other hand, I did see a lot of new approaches in textures and appearance (e.g. the shaved foie gras), as well as cooking techniques. The experience was also enhanced by the open kitchen and it was great to be able to see the 3 chefs in actions to prepare the dishes right in front of you. The swift moments, the enchanting knife skills, the interactive dialogues with the chefs, and the efficient moves of the staff all contributed to positive sides of this dining experience. If I could keep my kitchen half as clean as they did while they cooked, my mom would have been praising me for months.

I asked the chef how often they would change their tasting menu, and he wasn’t sure either as they just opened. I believe I will wait a bit before I visit Ko again, probably after they change some dishes in the tasting menu.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. j
    jasmurph RE: kobetobiko Mar 15, 2008 06:06 PM

    Great review. Thanks. How much was the meal?

    1 Reply
    1. re: jasmurph
      k
      kobetobiko RE: jasmurph Mar 15, 2008 07:49 PM

      The tasting menu was $85, with an option of wine pairing for an extra $50. They did have a large selection of bottled wines (a few by glass) and sake and some non-alcoholic drinks for you to choose.

    2. u
      UES Mayor RE: kobetobiko Mar 16, 2008 06:10 AM

      Thanks for the great review!!

      1. g
        george42 RE: kobetobiko Mar 16, 2008 06:56 AM

        Are you sure the egg was cooked "sous vide"? I know that's what Ruth Reichl said about hers too, but eating at Ko on Thursday, I saw my egg being taken out of a pot of water. The chef (who may have been down-playing things a bit) said it was simply a "five-minute egg" albeit with a smoky flavour added, I think, to the water and "no shocking". To complicate matters, another chef called the butter and water technique for the onions cooking them "soubise" which might be the source of the confusion.

        2 Replies
        1. re: george42
          k
          kobetobiko RE: george42 Mar 16, 2008 08:05 AM

          Hi george,

          Thanks for pointing out about the sous vide technique. As for the question "am I sure the egg was cooked sous vide?", I am not sure if any of my descriptions was 100% accurate as the chef only mentioned the name of each dish once (and there wasn't any written menu). I asked some questions but I had a lot more that I didn't ask as I was afraid to interrupt the chef in his work stream. The egg could very well be just cooked in low temperature without being vacuumed (so not really sous vide as you pointed out). I apologize if that caused any confusion.

          There might be another information in my post that needs correction, so please feel free to point that out so other hounds will know as well.

          1. re: kobetobiko
            k
            kathryn RE: kobetobiko Mar 18, 2008 08:21 AM

            The article in the New Yorker describes it as soft-cooked hen egg with soubise [onion] which leads me (and others) to believe that Reichl may have misheard soubise as "sous vide."

        2. s
          SuJinOh RE: kobetobiko Apr 2, 2008 08:51 AM

          Great review! I hate to ask such a basic question but how many tries online before getting the reservation? I feel like I've tried almost every day (today at 9:58am, 10am, 10:01am, etc.) and can't get anything.

          3 Replies
          1. re: SuJinOh
            r
            roze RE: SuJinOh Apr 2, 2008 03:52 PM

            I just went on Monday. We actually just checked on Monday night around 6:00 and there had been a cancellation for 8:45 that night. This is the second time that has happened to me.

            1. re: roze
              s
              SuJinOh RE: roze Apr 14, 2008 09:59 AM

              Thanks. I'll keep trying then.

              1. re: roze
                s
                SuJinOh RE: roze Apr 14, 2008 03:31 PM

                So, roze,
                when you went to make the reservations, you came to the page with the grid and all the X's?

            2. b
              BW212 RE: kobetobiko Apr 2, 2008 04:36 PM

              Thanks for such a great description. I wonder why they are so heavy with the pork dishes.

              1. c
                cimui RE: kobetobiko Apr 2, 2008 04:54 PM

                Goodness gracious. What an amazing sounding meal and a well written review (esp. all that commentary about mouth feel)! (You say you are not a food blogger / critic, but maybe you should be. :) Momofuku Ko wasn't high on my list of places to try before reading your review. It is now.

                1 Reply
                1. re: cimui
                  oonth RE: cimui Apr 2, 2008 05:56 PM

                  Agreed, it's a great review. I think that Kobe is way too modest especially considering that she is writing in what I am assuming is her 2nd or 3rd language.

                  Haven't tried Momofuku Ko but have to say, based upon my meals at the other Momofukus, that, whilst I think that David Chang is good conceptually and a talented chef, I've found his places to be more form than substance overall.

                2. x
                  xigua RE: kobetobiko Apr 15, 2008 10:10 AM

                  I made it there last friday and now have a problem.. I'm getting yelled at by friends whom I could not invite due to space restrictions...
                  The food was definitely good to excellent, the whole experience fun, casual and innovative, but did not love love the place as much as some other reviewers did, maybe due to the ultra-high amounts of anticipation that had built up prior. Loved the foie gras, the beef ribs and the pannacotta, but like kobe, I feel that they may still need to tweak the menu a little. The kimchi consomme we thought had no discernible kimchi taste and we weren't enthused about the fluke carpaccio.
                  But overall, definitely a solid meal. more pictures on the blog...
                  www.orderinny.com

                  1. d
                    David W RE: kobetobiko Apr 19, 2008 08:32 AM

                    We made it in the other night-I'll highlight a few changes from the OP's menu-
                    #3- my wife had diver scallops rather than fluke...I received a simple hamachi preparation, with oil and salt...she was kind enough to switch with me halfway through.
                    #6-soft shell crabs, sauteed and served with pickled carrots.
                    #11-I received the apple pie, my wife a hazelnut/wafer with avocado.

                    Frankly, this is one of the better dining experiences I've had of late--I loved the food, the space-everything.
                    A few other points--they also offer a higher-end pairing for $80...my wife had the $50, and I had the $80 (she suggested it...). I'm not usually a fan of pairings, but I felt this worked very nicely, and the pours were quite generous (we still managed to make it back to the subway.) I had an especially great wine from the Scholium Project (check out their website sometime-- http://www.scholiumwines.com ).
                    The seats are suprisingly comfortable for our entire 2 1/2 hours dining. The pacing was just right. They also serve a very nice espresso.

                    6 Replies
                    1. re: David W
                      b
                      brooklyndude RE: David W Apr 19, 2008 08:39 AM

                      The more expensive pairing was 85 when I went. Completely agree about the Scholium Project white.

                      1. re: brooklyndude
                        d
                        David W RE: brooklyndude Apr 19, 2008 01:04 PM

                        Hmmm...it may have been $85...looking at my credit card receipt, that makes more sense-thanks for the correction.

                        1. re: David W
                          b
                          brooklyndude RE: David W Apr 19, 2008 06:09 PM

                          Do you know the name of the Scholium White? I asked them to email it to me and they didn't.

                          1. re: brooklyndude
                            d
                            David W RE: brooklyndude Apr 21, 2008 07:00 AM

                            No, I don't...I had asked for the name as well, and the server gave me the cork...but all it has on it is Scholium Project. When she poured my glass, she claimed it was only sold to them and to Daniel...

                            1. re: brooklyndude
                              shane RE: brooklyndude Apr 21, 2008 09:41 AM

                              The Scholium white on the $50 pairing (as of a few weeks ago) was this one: http://scholiumwines.com/the_prince.html

                              They have it at Union Square Wines for $55.

                              1. re: shane
                                d
                                David W RE: shane Apr 21, 2008 09:56 AM

                                Thanks...my wife had that one, and it was very good.
                                To clarify--I was splurging on the higher pairing, and that's the one the server told me was only sold to them and Daniel...

                      2. Travels4Food RE: kobetobiko Apr 19, 2008 03:18 PM

                        Just wanted to say thanks for a wonderful review. I'd wanted to go before reading it, but now I'm completely intrigued, and your review seemed extremely fair and even-handed.

                        1. g
                          ginsbera RE: kobetobiko Apr 24, 2008 07:15 AM

                          Just got a 6:20 reservation for next Wednesday. So Thrilled! One thing, the big question, is it worth the money? The hype has drawn me, the food pictures have made me drool, but is it worth it?

                          2 Replies
                          1. re: ginsbera
                            b
                            bob gaj RE: ginsbera Apr 24, 2008 07:25 AM

                            yes, yes, and triple yes.

                            for the quality of food, it's definitely worth the price. and it's quite delicious.

                            1. re: bob gaj
                              g
                              ginsbera RE: bob gaj Apr 24, 2008 07:46 AM

                              Thats what I thought, I was just probably worrying about the lack of money in my account.

                              On another note, what about the wine pairings, is that worth it? I know my gf won't want it and would be happy with 2-3 glasses of wine total. Would you recommend a bottle if its reasonably priced?

                          2. a
                            armccaffrey RE: kobetobiko Jun 3, 2008 11:07 AM

                            Ate at Mofofuku Ko last night- Since kobetobiko's review above is so complete, I'll just offer up my satisfaction with each dish that we tried. In all, I genuinely loved the meal and anything negative below should be tempered with the thought that it was almost all still better than things you'd find elsewhere (the egg custard, not included). So, negative comments are only in relation to the other dishes that were served. We got the $50 pairing, which was nice even if the pours might have been a tad light.

                            First 2 offerings (the rind and the muffin) quite weak. Both needed a bit more of something. Would have been good if they were not a 'course' so to speak.

                            Fluke- A knockout. Just fantastic.

                            Oyster with Pork Bellies- ok. Pork should have been crispier, but it was good.

                            Pea Soup- Pea soup with crawfish and morel mushrooms in yuba. Perrfect!. Cannot be improved. Should never be altered.

                            Shaved Foie- ditto. I was downright livid when I had no more to eat. Got better per bite.

                            Trout and Halibut courses- Trout I liked quite a bit, halibut was well seasoned but a little bit dry). I liked these dishes more than the others I was with.

                            Lasagna- One of the best course for sure. Two types of ricotta (crumbly and whipped). Really really delicious.

                            Short Ribs- Woowwweee-- delicate and rich. On the money. Sous-vide(d)- perfect.

                            Poulard with Morel (i think) Mushrooms- served at the same time as the ribs, and was simply not nearly in the same league as the ribs and it therefore paled terribly in comparison.

                            Egg Custard (don't know actual name) with asparagus. The biggest miss for us. No one liked it.

                            Soft Boiled egg/ Caviar- unlike kobetobiko, I thought this dish missed the mark a little as the carviar overwhelmed the egg. I was a fan of all the ingredients, yet together they didn't work for me all that much. Still ate it happily.

                            Two Sorbets- both average.

                            Cake batter ice cream- loved it. Frozen cake batter-- what's not to like

                            Cereal Milk panna cotta- really does taste like milk that sat in a bowl with cornflakes for an hour.

                            This sort of seems like a negative review but I assure you the dishes that were great were GREAT. This cannot be overstated.

                            2 Replies
                            1. re: armccaffrey
                              k
                              kathryn RE: armccaffrey Jun 3, 2008 12:49 PM

                              Egg custard = chawan mushi?

                              1. re: kathryn
                                a
                                armccaffrey RE: kathryn Jun 3, 2008 01:46 PM

                                Yep I think so.

                            2. streamwise RE: kobetobiko Jul 31, 2008 08:47 PM

                              Went here for the first time recently....the food was good but the service was a bit awkward/amateurish, e.g. it's the only restaurant where my entire party showed up 3 minutes before the reservation, and we were asked to wait outside because the staff was not ready. WTF? Considering the amount of crap one puts up with to get the reservation, the dire warings about showing up late, and the credit card requirements, that's pretty much unacceptable. In addition, many of the glasses stunk....we thought some of the wine was off, but it was the glasses which had not been dried properly. They gave us a free bottle of water to comp. Gee thanks!
                              Next time, I'll just walk into Ssam and not deal with the place or the amatuer FOH.

                              Show Hidden Posts