Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Mar 15, 2008 04:08 AM

are H&H bagels still the best??

and if not, which bagel is best

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. They never were, though they are fine for most purposes. A bit too much sugar, overly soft interior as a vehicle for lox etc. Depends on what you are using the bagel for.

    1. A lot of people like Ess-a Bagel, which I tried once and didn't love. Other contenders are Absolute Bagels and Murray's Bagels.

      1. i really prefer h&h over ess-a-bagel by far. actually, i don't feel there is any comparison and i just don't understand their appeal. but, then again, i prefer a soft interior.

        absolute bagels is also very good. murrays is not bad either. i still can't find an equivalent manhattan bagel to the ones i 've had in the outer boroughs or nj. i love those bubbles on the crust with a soft interior and more porous with a crispy exterior but nothing too heavy.

        i also appreciate the fact that h&h has fresh bagels no matter what time you saunter in there. even as late as 1am, you can actually get a fresh bagel (sometimes even hot) . any other place will either be long closed, out of bagels or toss a stale bagel at you for being stupid enough for wanting a bagel outside of the only time you are ever supposed to eat bagels (6am-11am)!!!!!

        1 Reply
        1. re: nativeNYer

          are H&H bagels still the best??

          You betcha they are! :-)

        2. absolutely the best. And as nativeNYer pointed out, you can go in there almost any time of day and get a fresh one, still hot from the oven. Crispy exterior, soft interior.

            1. re: guttergourmet

              i like H&H fine, although i will say i've never had one direct from them.

              i really like Tal bagels, and think they're awesome, esp. the sesame (my personal favorite).