HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >


Dying for a good egg cream

I used to go to Gem's spa in the east village where I will be staying but I heard it is not as good as other places. What's new in the best soda in the world

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Ray's on Ave A and 7th- ask for it sweet.

    2 Replies
      1. re: hungrycomposer

        I totally agree with this rec. However, if one comes to Ave. A looking for "Ray's," it can easily be missed there is no name signage. It's on the block b/t 7th & St. Mark's, literally a hole-in-the-wall candy store with an overhead sign jutting into the street that says, "Belgian Fries."

        Imo, Gem Spa's egg cream is equally as good as the one at Ray's.

        The one egg cream I had at Eisenberg's was poor.

    1. Lexington Candy Shop is great. Worth the hike uptown.

      1. Soupburg on Lexington Ave at 77 Street makes a great chocolate egg cream, just like the ones I remember when I was a kid in the 1950's.

          1. The Gem Spa and the Eisenberg Sandwich Shop are my current favorite places for egg creams. I remember the 2nd Ave Deli making a pretty good one too.

            7 Replies
            1. re: vinegarhill

              It is not possible for you to have had an egg cream at the 2nd Avenue Deli because the original location was kosher, as is the re-incarnated one. Kosher restaurants cannot mix meat and dairy, and since egg creams require milk, they would never be served there. They can serve a mixture of chocolate syrup + seltzer, but that's a chocolate soda, not an egg cream.

              1. re: RGR

                My dear child had her first egg cream, made with loving care, at Russ and Daughters on the LES. It was not only delicious, but the experience of being in the store was wonderful. We especially loved the white lab coats worn by the staff...it gave a formal, old-world feel to the experience.

                1. re: RGR

                  In the Midwest when I was growing up, an egg cream without the milk was called a chocolate phosphate. Is that the case here?

                  Also, if you really want to go for oldworld European food (chicken shmaltze on the tables for the bread!) Sammys Romanian will bring you the makings of an egg cream to the table (milk, seltzer, choolate syrump) and you can make your own at the end of the meal.

                  1. re: BW212

                    I'm a NYC native, and I recall that back in the day, candy stores and lunch counters offered carbonated drinks called "phosphates." Googling, I found this explanation re: their composition:

                    http://www.cloudcreations.com/cafe/so... (Scroll down.)

                      1. re: RGR

                        Heck, we just called it a chocolate soda- syrup and seltzer. Rarely bothered to order it because the seltzer we had delivered to the house did just as good a job. Not so with the egg creams- they were always better at the candy store, probably because their seltzer fountain dispensed with more even force onto the spoon.

                    1. re: RGR

                      Yes, you're right. My mind must be going.

                  2. Check out Ronnybrook milk bar at Chelsea Market. They make amazing milk to begin with so the egg cream is absolutely fantastic.

                    1. Another strong vote for Ray's over Gem Spa... Last time I went to Gem Spa the egg cream wasn't very good, and the guy who made the egg cream put the spoon he used back into a glass filled with old water diluted with egg cream dregs instead of using a fresh spoon or washing it. Ick.

                      1. I know Gem's spa was sold but the owner gave the secret receipe to the owner though it might have been sold again. I never went to Ray's but to ask for it sweet seems they don't know there is only one way to make it . correct me if I am wrong on that. I will be in the East Village so I can try Rays and the one in Chelsea Market. I have never been there . Is that like a mall?

                        2 Replies
                        1. re: lisettte

                          I have never directed the ladies at Ray's on how to make the egg cream, and it always turns out perfectly. Same goes for Gem Spa.

                          Chelsea Market is an enclosed space with lots of food shops and places to eat. The website has the list: http://www.chelseamarket.com And, btw, the Food Network has its studios there.

                          1. re: RGR

                            "Sweet" just means an extra half squirt of syrup. It's a mood thing.

                        2. The Soda Shop on Chambers has a great one.

                          1. I am so glad egg creams have not gone the way of the candy store where I had my egg on a roll and a hot chocolate before High school. I will try all when I visit next month