1 romantic original un-stuffy dinner in DC?
My fiance and I are taking an overnight to DC from Southside VA to play tourist and visit the museums and the zoo. We'll be there on a Tuesday night looking for dinner, and since we'll have a nice romantic hotel room to come back to, we're looking for a nice romantic meal to close off the day. Considerations to make in your recommendations should be:
-No suit/tie/jacket requirements. Not that he won't wear one, but I don't want the kind of place that requires it.
-Prefer to lean toward upscale, but not by DC standards. We'd like to stick between $100-150 for the two of us with everything.
-Somewhere with a view would be greatly preferred, but I'm willing to give that up for a fantastic meal.
-No franchises. I can get that at home. Looking for original DC venues.
-Major consideration: I am an incredibly picky eater. It's mental wiring, not upbringing. I know this is a foodie board, so I hope you can still help. I'm a consistency whore, so no gourmet menus where I can't pronounce anything and no meals the size of a crouton. I'm not big on French or Thai, and I'm more of a red meat, potatoes and chicken type of girl. However, my beau will eat anything you put in front of him, particularly fish and vegetables, so a diverse menu would be appreciated.
-Something close to a metro stop would be greatly preferred, as I know about the parking issues downtown. We're staying at the Omni but it doesn't have to be superclose to that.
-Please provide personal recommendations from places you have been to in the past six months or so, and any users that can second or third the recommendation would be greatly appreciated. I'll be sure to post my decision and review once we get back, and thanks to all in advance!
Hmmm...I was going to say the upstairs of Bistro LePic until you said you don't like French (what is it about French you don't like?).
Tabard Inn may be your place. Great food that is upscale American but absolutely approachable, a relaxing and romantic bar area with a fireplace, and a Dupont location that's easy to get to:
Perhaps Blue Duck Tavern? The food is unfussy but very, very good, and they have a nice emphasis sourcing their supplies. I've been very pleased the two times I've been there, both times with "meat-and-potatoes" types. They have a lot of dishes that are uncommon cuts (marrow, trotters, etc) to keep me interested, and fair amount of uncomplicated dishes.
No great view, but view+great food I have found to be a non-starter in most cities.
Blue Duck Tavern
1201 24th Street, NW, Washington, DC 20037
OK, you know what, my wife just had a great idea. Go for drinks at Off the Record in the Hay Adams, then go to Central, which is at 10th and Penn. The view from outside Central, looking down towards the Capitol building, is amazing. You will both be happy with the food there. It's not that romantic...but -> Off the Record is very romantic (tip the concierge to see if you can check out the view from the roof).
Mendocino Grill in Gtown- intimate wine-bar with FANTASTIC food. You can have dessert there or move to the bar at Citronelle for some of Michel Richard's creations. The only issue is that Gtown is not metro accessable but it is an easy cab ride and the food is sooo worth it.
I also love Palena and it is right near the zoo. You can sit in the front of the restaurant (which doesn't take reservations) and simple the food of one of DC's best chefs for a really good price. He does some very creative dishes but you could also sample his famous burger and fries or roast chicken, both of which are awesome.
Also, I agree with the Central rec. and I think it fits the bill completely in terms of your food tastes. My only reservation in rec. it is that I wouldn't call it particularly romantic. Still, it is very "DC" and you can't go wrong with it. Reservations are hard to get, however.
Thank you all so much for the recommendations so far. I've heard good things about Tabard Inn from a few other places, so I guess that's the front-runner for now, and Central seems to come up among foodie boards quite a bit so I'll definitely keep the two of those in mind. I've looked up some other places, and if you have any opinions of them please let me know:
Sea Catch Restaurant & Raw Bar
Cafe Saint Ex
DISH + Drinks
Also if any of these places are perhaps not what I've taken them to be like from food editor's descriptions, please let me know. I haven't been to DC since I was 10 so I know nothing about where anything is or what certain areas are like!
Hook - Waaaay over rated, and overpriced to boot.
Le Paradou - French. You don't like French.
Mendocino Grill - Agree with JAC13. Pretty great.
Firefly - Romantic interior. Good food.
Komi - Too adventurous for you, but one of the top foodie joints in town.
Sea Catch - Decent food I guess, but the interior feels old and dark. Haven't even considered going there in ages.
Ray's - Yes. Yes. Yes. But prepare to wait, and the Arlington location is about a ten minute walk from the Metro and is in a strip mall. Not very romantic.
I'll chime in for those that I can speak to. IMO, the Ray's that's closest to DC, while intimate, definitely isn't romantic, Teatro Goldoni isn't particularly romantic, and if you have cocktails or wine, Le Paradou, Vidalia and Palena are likely to exceed your budget. Based on your criteria, I'd suggest Firefly and Tabard Inn. Too bad it's not warmer, the patio at the Tabard is wonderful. Their bar is wonderfully cozy and romantic, particularly by the fire in the winter, and while the menu and price fit your criteria, I can't speak to the ambiance of the indoor dining room. But I'd trust others recommendations here. My only concern about Firefly is that I know some of the two-tops can be a little too close for comfort, though it's been a while since I was there. So I'd suggest asking for privacy when making a reservation so they don't seat you on top of another couple.
Hook- not way overrated in my opinion is more modern and trendy, but the food is great, if you like fish, if you don't like fish, don't go.
Ray's is great, but no reservations and the decor is sparse, but I love it best steak I can remember eating.
Zola is sexy/chic I love it, it will have something for you both.
Le Paradou- I love it, but it's french, no getting around that. Very French. And I think you would feel out of place dressed casual.
Firefly- don't go you feel packed like a sardine, and will hear everyone elses business while sitting at the table to eat.
I really agree on Blue Duck, it is great for meat. And will have interesting meat preperations for the man. You will be fine in whatever you where.
Central is another good choice mentioned above.