Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Feb 13, 2008 08:03 AM

Pork shoulder roast

I got a 3-1/2 pork shoulder roast yesterday because my butcher never has them, and now I don't know what to do with it. My husband wanted a chili (epi has a great spicy pork with beans recipe that I've made numerous times), but I want something different. Suggestions? recipes?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
    1. re: MMRuth

      This easy recipe gets 5 stars. It is like doing "nothing at all" as you state. And the leftovers easily make two or maybe even three more dinners for my family of four. Anybody can do this. It was delicious! (TWICE!) Thank you! Laurie :>)

    2. My favorite pork shoulder recipe is almost like doing nothing at all, except it takes a long time. You put the shoulder roast fat side up in an old fashioned roaster that has a lid, splash Worcestershire sauce over the top and a bit down the sides, then pack it firmly with a generous layer of brown sugar, pour in enough sparkling cider (or apple juice) to come about an inch or so up the side of the roast (do NOT get the brown sugar wet!), cover tightly and roast in a slow 225F oven for five or six hours. Up to ten hours for larger roasts. In fact, if you work you can put it in the slow oven before you leave in the morning and it will be ready when you get home.

      It's great for dinner with a gravy made with the pan juices, and buttered mashed potatoes/turnips. Maybe sugar snap peas as a vegetable? Really simple, mouth watering drop dead delicious, and if you don't have too many people at the table, you have great pulled pork sandwiches the next day. If you decide on this, go back to your butcher and get another roast to cook with it before they're all gone! It's that good.

      6 Replies
      1. re: Caroline1

        I have a 5 pound shoulder in the oven right now using almost the same technique - it'll be done in time for dinner. However, I just used a spice rub and the oven is at 275. I've done this before and it makes it very tender and delicious.

        1. re: vnchile

          Do try the brown sugar and sparkling cider some time. When I first saw the recipe, I thought, "Come on now, NOTHING can be THAT easy!" But it is. The brown sugar and apple just intensify the pork flavor istead of modifying it.

          I think I need to buy a pork shoulder.

        2. re: Caroline1

          What if I don't have a roaster ... any alternatives?

          1. re: foiegras

            Any deep pan or ovenproof casserole will work just fine. Just cover it with aluminum foil and don't forget to poke one or two small holes in it as steam vents. SMALL holes! '-)

          2. re: Caroline1


            I followed your recipe last night and the shoulder was taken out this morning. Overnight baked at 225. Now, what shall I do with plentyful plan juices? Reduce?

            1. re: xiaobao12

              Oh, wow! You'd think this would have shown up on my Recent Threads page before now! Sorry for the very long delay, and I'm the pan juices are no longer a problem! Yes, you can reduce them. Not using a lot of salt (I don't use any) in a very llong braise such as this means you can reduce the juices to a syrup and still not have a problem with salt concentration. Sometimes I reduce, sometimes I just serve it as a pan sauce. And sometimes I use it as part of the cooking liquid for rice, if that's my starch of choice for that meal.

          3. I saw a Jamie Oliver recipe for Spicy Pork and Chili-Pepper Goulash and it looks pretty tasty to me. They peppers sound like they might appeal to your husband if he was looking for chili. I plan on making it soon but have not tried it yet. You can find it at

            3 Replies
            1. re: upstate girl

              I saw the same Jamie Oliver episode, and drooled over the recipe. Told a friend about it and urged her to download the recipe. Unbeknownst to me we both cooked the spicy pork goulash on the same day, and had the same reaction - bland and boring. Followed the recipe to the letter. I think perhaps the pork available in the UK is more flavorful than what's available in US grocery stores. Anyway a very very generous amount of louisiana hot sauce offered some improvement the next day. I will not make this recipe again. Much better things to do with a 4-lb shoulder roast.

              1. re: janniecooks

                I am SO glad you replied. It looked so good on the episdoe, thanks for the tip.

              2. re: upstate girl

                Here's the link to the JO recipe mentioned above:

                I looked at this 'spicy' recipe which contains
                - 4.25 lb. pork shoulder
                - 2 fresh red chiles (good heat)
                - 2 TB smoked mild paprika (low heat)
                - 5 bell peppers (No heat)
                - 10 oz. jar grilled peppers (low to no heat)

                Yikes, no wonder it was bland! That's not a lot of chiles for +4 lb of pork.
                This recipe is a disaster - Jamie can do better.

                OTOH I think this Bobby Flay green chili recipe is closer to the mark:
                I'd cut the liquid volume WAY down, add >16 oz of roasted low heat chiles (Anaheims, Poblanos), and use a slow cooker.

                Have fun!

                1. A lot of "unfortunate" pork here.
                  Shoulder can be reduced to pullable shreds saturated with sauce BUT it needs NOT be.
                  Season the butt or picnic as desired.
                  Roast at 325 to 150 no hotter .
                  Rest 20 min and eat as roast.
                  You are welcome.

                  3 Replies
                  1. re: mr jig

                    Agreed. We like ours sliced too. We also throw in quartered potatoes, chunky carrots and a couple of onioncns and lift the lid at the end to brown them. You must like cold pork sandwiches for lunch too, yes, Jig?

                    1. re: DockPotato

                      We do indeed.
                      Chill well and slice thin on the slicer.
                      Dress a soft roll with mustard and mayo stack high and enjoy.

                    2. re: mr jig

                      Good point. My FIL does a pork pot roast type dish with it that's very good. A little on the fatty side for me but good.