Not sure why you would tip any differently on the wine than you would on the food you ordered, drinks, etc. My standard isn't based on the ratio of wine/food cost. Of course I don't generally order multi-hundred bottles of wine either (although if I did, and this involved decanting, etc. ) I still imagine I would tip my standard tip on the total. isn't this kind of like asking if you can tip a smaller % if you go for the expensive caviar service?
i'm very glad you added that FBRUNI link [i was unaware of the article], but
i dont think that is a fair summary of what he says. rather than try to summarize
myself, i'd say "read the article".
others can find many of the other threads on this topic by searching for
"uncapped linear tips" on wine. mr. vino verite's "statistics" arent especially
relevant because we're not talking about what the average table does, we're
talking about what the teeeeeeeeeny minority that orders +$500 [say] bottles
does. would you tell somebody who called the restaurant and asked for
special handling because he was organizing a 100th birthday party for his
grandmother that 99.8% of diners leave 15-20%? would you give the same
tipping advice to the one person a year who goes into anaphylactic shock
due to a kitchen error/failure to communicate.
[BTW, I dunno if tips are fairly normally distributed around a 17.5% mean,
but if as Mr. IVV claims 99.8% of the probability mass of tips is between 15-20%,
he is saying that is -3sd to +3sd, i.e. the std dev of the tips are .83, which i
find pretty surprising ... because i sure doubt service is that consistent. i certainly
consider it odd that the entire ensemble of tips across all of your customers has
such low varance given than my personal tipping variance at a given resto is
probably higher. now what i could believe is "there isnt 1 month in a 1000 where
the aggregate tips for the month falls outside the 15-20% band"].
Depending where you work, it's definitely not a "teeeeeeeny minority" that orders wine that expensive. Just because you personally don't see it often doesn't mean it doesn't happen all the time.
A diner organizing a 100th birthday party at a restaurant would almost always be booking a function, where gratuity is included.
What do a kitchen error and tipping percentage have to do with one another?
You cite examples that aren't relevant. My examples are real, since I've seen them with my own eyes. You can throw all the technical jargon around that you like, but it doesn't change that I first-handedly experience this exact topic EVERY SINGLE DAY...and see servers tipped on the total.
Also, along the lines of Xiao's comment, any restaurant that uses automatic gratuity (due to party size or standard operating procedure) includes your entire bill in the calculation.
This topic has been beaten to death, so just a quick sum of my years of experience.
After selling much fine wine in my day, I no longer wait tables. I DO see the service staff's credit card receipts and it's my job to be in the know regarding their wine sales. I'd say that perhaps one, possibly two tables a month don't leave standard (15-20%) gratuity on their wine. This is out of +/- 1,000 tables per month.
Feel free to tip whatever you'd like on wine, but by not leaving your standard gratuity, you're in a teeeeeeeeeeeeeeeensy minority and definitely labeled by the staff.
re: Up With Olives
Tipping percents (food or wine) have escalated. At one time, 10 percent was standard. Then it got up to 15 percent, somehow, and now is bumping up against 20 percent. I find this annoying, because the cost of the meal goes up due to inflation as well, and the amount of the tip would grow by a similar proportion even without escalating the percentage bais.
I've always thought about this issue myself. At what point does the 15-20% start to be ridiculous. Let's say I order a $500 bottle of wine. Should I be expected to leave $75 - $100 tip, or else be branded as cheap? It makes NO logical sense. I could order 4 bottles at $75 each, which requires 4 times as much work by the server. In that case a $60 tip would really please the server. But the same $60 tip on the $500 bottle and I am cheap???