HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
What are you cooking today? Get great advice
TELL US

Ben & Jack's Vs. Wolfgang's

r
rjm Feb 11, 2008 01:32 PM

Which would you say comes closer to Peter Lugers' perfection?

I've been to Wolfgang's many times and find it to be a fine substitution short of Lugers. However, I've never tried Ben & Js and was thinking about doing so. Unless, of course, I shouldn't. Please tell me what you think.

  1. h
    Hungry Brooklyn Mike Feb 11, 2008 01:44 PM

    I have been to both and I liked Ben and Jack's better...I mean not by a lot, but I thought it was more "Lugaresque" from top to bottom. I've been to Wolfgang's a few times, but am always kind of annoyed by the acoustics. I would absolutely give Ben & Jack's a try.

    4 Replies
    1. re: Hungry Brooklyn Mike
      r
      rjm Feb 11, 2008 01:53 PM

      Great. Thanks for the feedback. I'll def. try it then. : )

      1. re: rjm
        t
        tpigeon Feb 11, 2008 02:09 PM

        I was unimpressed with Ben & Jacks when I went almost a year ago. It looked like lugers but sure didn't taste like it. Never been to wolfgangs.

        1. re: tpigeon
          e
          ESNY Feb 11, 2008 02:19 PM

          Thats exactly how I felt about Wolfgang's the two times I went. Looked like a duck, quacked like a duck but didn't taste like a duck. The porterhouse steak looked the part, was cooked properly but had no taste either time.

          1. re: ESNY
            r
            rjm Feb 11, 2008 02:27 PM

            ESNY - I agree with you re: Wolfgang's. In the end, it always falls short...

    2. steakman55 Feb 11, 2008 02:56 PM

      Been to both, one time each, and enjoyed the food at B&J slightly more

      1. l
        Lau Feb 11, 2008 03:28 PM

        i think B&J's is substantially better...the bacon is excellent there and the steak is good as well

        1 Reply
        1. re: Lau
          e
          elecsheep9 Feb 11, 2008 06:20 PM

          Never been to Wolfgangs (or Lugers), but I've been to B&Js two times and it is fantastic!

        2. s
          sugartoof Feb 11, 2008 10:05 PM

          I've heard great things about their salads at B& J's, go figure. They're supposed to be worthy of meals in their own right.

          2 Replies
          1. re: sugartoof
            l
            Lau Feb 12, 2008 07:10 AM

            im not sure why B&Js gets killed on the board, i think its really good...im probably going to get killed for this, but i dont think that peter lugers is that much better

            1. re: sugartoof
              e
              elecsheep9 Feb 15, 2008 06:21 AM

              The caesar salad at B&Js is excellent.

            2. snoballz Feb 14, 2008 07:51 PM

              Interesting to see the differing opinions here.

              I've been to Wolfgang's (midtown and downtown) and Ben & Jack's. At all three locations, I went with the same couple of friends and ordered the same cut steak (porterhouse for four). I prefer Wolfgang's midtown both in terms of food and atmosphere. I like the architecture of the restaurant. The one downtown was inconsistent and the restaurant was like any other steakhouse.

              With that said, the porterhouse at Ben & Jack's was well served. Close to Wolfgang's and Luger's in terms of taste and char. The gold bull was a bit over the top. Also, when I asked about a particular red wine, the "sommelier", which later I found was Jack, he said it would be perfect with steak. When I pressed why, he remarked "because it's red".

              1. b
                bobby06877 Feb 15, 2008 02:00 PM

                Great thread, I had recently posted one regarding a similar topic. As far as Luger clones, how does MarkJoseph rank compared to Wolfgangs or Ben & Jacks?

                Show Hidden Posts